Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Tried Baking Bread Cookies and Muffins in One Day, Here's What Worked
72
items Planning a full-day baking marathon sounds fun until you're three hours in, out of parchment paper, and your stand mixer is making a weird noise. I spent a whole Saturday baking six recipes back to back and figured out exactly which tools, ingredient...
Sections
8
Flour and Dry Ingredients That Don't Clump or Disappoint
Butter Eggs and Dairy That Actually Make a Difference
Chocolate Vanilla and Flavor Boosters Worth Buying
Mixers and Tools That Survive a Full Day of Baking
Sheet Pans Muffin Tins and Bakeware That Won't Warp
Bread Specific Supplies for Loaves That Actually Rise
Flour and Dry Ingredients That Don't Clump or Disappoint
I used to grab whatever flour was cheapest and then wonder why my bread was dense and my cookies spread into flat discs. Switching to the right flours for each recipe was the single biggest upgrade to my baking day.
Grab this before anything else. I switched from store brand and my cookies finally held their shape instead of melting into sad little puddles on the sheet pan.
King Arthur Baking Company, All-Purpose Flour, 5 lb Bag
Use this specifically for your bread recipes. My sourdough went from a flat frisbee to an actual loaf with a real crumb structure the first time I tried it.
Gold Medal Premium Quality Bread Flour for Baking 5 lb
Toss a cup of this into your muffin batter if you want that nutty flavor without making everything taste like cardboard. Perfect for anyone trying to sneak in more whole grains.
Bob's Red Mill Whole Wheat Flour, 5 lbs.
Keep a fresh box on hand. I once used baking soda that had been open for four months and my muffins came out flat as hockey pucks. Never again.
ARM & HAMMER, Baking Soda, 1 lb Box
Pair this with your muffin and cookie recipes. It's double acting so your batter doesn't go flat while you're busy shaping bread dough across the kitchen.
Clabber Girl Gluten-Free Double Acting Baking Powder 8.1
Try measuring your salt instead of eyeballing it. I ruined an entire batch of chocolate chip cookies last spring because I got cocky with a pinch.
Morton All-Purpose Iodized Sea Salt, Fine Sea Salt, 26 oz
Stock up on the bigger bag. One baking marathon chewed through almost three pounds between cookies, muffin tops, and the sugar wash on my bread. I ran out halfway through once.
Domino Pure Cane Granulated Sugar, 4 lb. Bag
Snag two bags if your lineup includes chocolate chip or oatmeal cookies. Brown sugar disappears fast, and there's nothing worse than being one cup short at 3pm.
C&H Premium Pure Cane Light Brown Sugar 2 lb. Zipper-Pak
Get this for glazing your muffins at the end of the day. A simple lemon glaze takes blueberry muffins from good to the thing everyone fights over at brunch.
Great Value Confectioners Powdered Sugar, 32 oz
Butter Eggs and Dairy That Actually Make a Difference
Cheap butter burned me, literally. One marathon I used bargain butter and every cookie batch had a weird greasy film. Now I'm picky about dairy and my baked goods finally taste like they came from a bakery.
Swap to unsalted so you control the salt in each recipe. I used salted butter in my shortbread once and it tasted like a salt lick. Lesson learned the hard way.
Land O'Lakes Unsalted Butter, 8 Half Sticks, 1 lb Pack
Grab the 18 count because a single marathon day can eat through a dozen fast. I cracked my last egg into bread dough and had none left for the cookie recipe. Rookie mistake.
Great Value Large White Eggs 18 Count
Throw a few tablespoons into your muffin batter. Sounds weird but it keeps them moist for days. My coworkers thought I bought bakery muffins when I brought these in on Monday.
Daisy Pure and Natural Sour Cream, 16 oz Tub ...
Use whole milk, not skim, in your bread dough. The fat content gives you a softer crumb. I did a side by side test and the skim milk loaf was noticeably tougher.
Great Value Milk Whole Vitamin D, Half Gallon, 64 fl oz
Keep a block cold for cream cheese frosting on your muffins. If you let it get too warm before mixing, you'll end up with lumpy frosting and mild rage.
Philadelphia, Whipped Cream Cheese Spread, 8 oz tub
Bring this out for enriched bread doughs. A splash in your brioche makes it pillowy. Also great for whipped cream on top of warm muffins if you're feeling fancy.
Great Value Heavy Whipping Cream, 32 oz Carton
Try this for your shortbread or butter cookies specifically. The color is deeper, the flavor is richer, and you'll taste the difference in simpler recipes where butter is the star.
Kerrygold Grass-Fed Pure Irish Unsalted Butter, 8 Oz
Pour this into your muffin batter instead of regular milk. The tanginess makes blueberry muffins pop, and the acid reacts with baking soda for a better rise.
Shop Buttermilk & Buttermilk Powder
Swap this in for sour cream if you run out mid-marathon. Works almost identically in muffins and adds a slight tang that pairs well with lemon or berry flavors.
bettergoods Plain Whole Milk Greek Yogurt, 32 oz Tub
Chocolate Vanilla and Flavor Boosters Worth Buying
Plain baked goods are fine but nobody at my house gets excited about plain. These are the flavor additions that made people actually come back for seconds instead of politely saying it was nice.
Toss these into cookies obviously, but also try folding them into banana muffins. My kid went from muffin hater to eating three in one sitting after I added chocolate chips.
Nestlé Toll House, Semi-Sweet Chocolate Baking Chips
Use real vanilla, not imitation. I did a blind taste test with sugar cookies and everyone picked the real vanilla batch. The imitation ones tasted weirdly chemical.
McCormick, Vanilla Extract, 2 fl oz, Non-GMO, Pure
Keep this for double chocolate muffins and chocolate cookies. A little goes a long way. I once doubled the cocoa and everything tasted like bitter chalk.
Hershey's Natural Unsweetened Cocoa Powder, Can 8 oz
Shake this into your muffin batter and use it for cinnamon swirl bread. Fresh cinnamon smells incredible and your whole kitchen will smell like a bakery for hours.
McCormick Kosher Ground Cinnamon, 2.37 oz Bottle
Pair these with macadamia nuts in cookies. My neighbor literally asked me for the recipe, which has never happened before with anything I've baked.
Ghirardelli, Baking Chips, 11 oz, White Vanilla Flavored
Try half a teaspoon in your sugar cookie dough. It adds a subtle warmth that people can't quite identify but always comment on. Secret weapon territory.
McCormick Almond Extract 2 fl oz Pure Natural No Artificial
Squeeze this into your muffin glaze for a lemon drizzle that actually tastes like lemon. Lemon zest alone never gave me enough punch.
McCormick Non-GMO Gluten Free Pure Lemon Extract
Spoon a little into the center of your muffins before baking for a surprise jam filling. My daughter calls them treasure muffins and honestly it takes ten extra seconds.
Smucker's Strawberry Preserves, 18 oz Jar
Swirl this into cookie dough for peanut butter chocolate chip cookies. For anyone who thinks regular chocolate chip cookies are boring, this fixes that immediately.
Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 oz Jar
Mixers and Tools That Survive a Full Day of Baking
My old hand mixer died halfway through a cookie marathon last year. Literally started smoking. I've since figured out which tools can handle six straight hours of dough, batter, and bread without quitting on you.
Get this if you're serious about baking days. My arms were giving out kneading bread by hand, and this thing handles dough, cookie batter, and muffin mix without breaking a sweat.
KitchenAid Classic Series 4.5-Quart Tilt-Head Stand Mixer
Keep this as your backup for whipping cream or quick batters while the stand mixer handles bread dough. Having two mixers running cuts your timeline by at least an hour.
Hamilton Beach Electric Hand Mixer, 6-Speed Corded
Swap out the regular paddle for this one. It scrapes the sides of the bowl while mixing so you don't have to stop every 30 seconds to push butter clumps back down.
Customer reviews for Flex Edge Beater for Kitchenaid
Use the biggest bowl for bread dough rising and the smaller ones for dry ingredients. I used to try to do everything in one bowl and it was a flour-covered disaster.
Oxo SoftWorks 3-Piece Mixing Bowl Set with Handles
Grab these so you can pre-measure all your ingredients before you start. Having everything portioned out in advance is the difference between chaos and a smooth baking day.
Pyrex 3-pc Glass Measuring Cup Set
Use this for whisking dry ingredients together instead of sifting. Faster, less messy, and honestly my sifter just collected dust in the drawer anyway.
OXO International OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Whisk
Throw your bread dough on this hook and let it knead for 8 minutes while you prep cookie dough. Multitasking is the only way a one-day marathon actually works.
KitchenAid Stainless Steel Dough Hook for KSM5THDHSS
Toss your old cracked spatulas. These don't stain, don't melt, and scrape every last bit of batter out of the bowl. I wasted so much cookie dough before switching.
OXO Good Grips Silicone Everyday Spatula - Non-Stick
Drop your bread dough in here for bulk fermentation. It's big enough for a double batch and the clear sides let you see exactly how much your dough has risen without opening the lid.
RUBBERMAID Round Storage Container,12 qt,PK6
Sheet Pans Muffin Tins and Bakeware That Won't Warp
Nothing ruins a baking marathon faster than a sheet pan that buckles in the oven and sends cookies sliding into each other. I went through three cheap pans before landing on ones that stay flat.
Grab two of these minimum. They don't warp at high heat and my cookies bake evenly every single time. Cheap sheet pans buckle and you end up with one side burnt and the other raw.
Nordic Ware, Half Sheet, 18"x13" Aluminum
Ditch whatever muffin tin you got as a wedding gift. This one releases muffins without a fight. I used to destroy every other muffin trying to pry them out of my old pan.
Muffin Pan, 12 Cup, Nonstick
Bake your sandwich bread in this and the crust comes out golden and slightly crispy. My bread used to have a pale, sad crust until I switched from glass to cast iron.
Lodge 8.5" x 4.5" Loaf Pan, Seasoned Cast Iron
Set your cookies and muffins on this immediately. I used to let cookies cool on the pan and the bottoms kept baking. Soggy on top, burnt underneath. Problem solved.
Wilton Perfect Results Cooling Rack, 3 Tier, Non-Stick
Stock up on the big roll. A full baking day can burn through half a roll between cookie batches and lining your bread pan. Running out mid-marathon is a nightmare I've lived.
Reynolds Kitchens Parchment Paper with SmartGrid
Lay this on your sheet pan for cookies that slide right off. Also saves you from going through an entire roll of parchment in one day. Pays for itself in two baking sessions.
Silpat Premium Non-Stick Silicone Baking Mat
Use this for bar cookies or focaccia if you want to add a flatbread to your lineup. Versatile enough that it pulls double duty between sweet and savory recipes.
Wilton Premium Steel Non-Stick Oblong Cake Pan with Lid
Keep this around for smaller batches of brownies or bar cookies. Sometimes you want a half batch and a 9x13 pan makes them paper thin. This size is just right.
Anchor Hocking Glass Baking Dish Set
Snag these as your rotation pans. While one batch bakes, you load the second sheet. Cuts your cookie baking time nearly in half and keeps the momentum going.
Rachael Ray 3pk Nonstick Bakeware Cookie Pan Set
Bread Specific Supplies for Loaves That Actually Rise
My first homemade bread was a dense brick that could have doubled as a doorstop. Turns out I was missing a few key supplies that make the difference between bread and a weapon.
Check the expiration date before you start. I once spent two hours waiting for dough to rise before realizing my yeast was dead. Fresh yeast is non-negotiable for bread day.
Customer reviews for Fleischmann's Active Dry Yeast, 4 oz
Use this to check your water temperature before adding yeast. Too hot kills it, too cold and nothing happens. I killed three batches of dough before I started measuring.
Taylor Instant Read High Temp Digital Meat Thermometer
Drop your shaped dough in here for the final rise. It gives artisan bread those beautiful spiral lines and holds the shape so your loaf doesn't spread into a flat disc.
Mrs. Anderson's Baking Rattan Brotform Bread-Proofing
Score the top of your loaf before it goes in the oven. Without scoring, my bread used to crack open in random ugly spots. This gives you that bakery-style slash on top.
DUOYOU Bread Lame Sourdough Scoring Tool 2PCS
Bake your artisan bread inside this with the lid on for the first 20 minutes. It traps steam and gives you a crackling crust that sounds hollow when you tap it. No fancy steam oven needed.
Lodge Pre-Seasoned 5 Quart Cast Iron Dutch Oven
Keep this on the counter for handling sticky bread dough. My hands used to be caked in dough until I started using this to fold, lift, and shape. So much cleaner.
Silicone Dough Scrapers for Baking Tools
Switch to this for your crusty loaves. Regular all purpose works for cookies but bread flour has more protein, which means more gluten, which means actual chew and structure.
King Arthur Baking Company, All-Purpose Flour, 5 lb Bag
Lay baguettes on this linen for their final proof. It wicks moisture and holds the shape so they don't flatten out. My baguettes went from blobs to actual baguette shapes.
Professional Proofing Cloth, Thick Bread Bakers Couche
Fill this with water and spritz the inside of your oven right after loading bread. The burst of steam gives you a crispier crust. Cheap trick that works better than any fancy equipment.
Rubbermaid Commercial Spray Bottle 32oz. Clear
Cookie Decorating and Finishing Touches
Plain cookies are fine for Tuesday but if you're doing a whole marathon, you might as well make some of them look impressive. These are the finishing supplies that got me actual compliments instead of polite nods.
Squeeze a tiny amount into royal icing for decorated sugar cookies. A little goes far. I used half a bottle once and ended up with icing so dark it stained my kid's teeth blue.
Wilton Icing Colours Set
Pair these with a piping bag for clean icing lines on sugar cookies. I used to spread icing with a butter knife and it looked like a kindergarten art project.
Ateco 6-Piece Pastry Tube and Tips Set
Toss these after each color instead of washing piping bags between batches. During a marathon you don't have time to scrub frosting out of reusable bags six times.
Wilton 12 inch Disposable Decorating Piping Bags
Sprinkle these on top of sugar cookies before baking for a sparkle that doesn't taste artificial. My niece specifically requests the pink sugar cookies every time I bake now.
India Tree, Decorating Sugar Spring Green, 3 Ounces
Keep a tube of this as your emergency backup. When you're eight hours into baking and too tired to make royal icing from scratch, this squeezes right on and dries perfectly.
Betty Crocker, Cookie Decorating Icing, 7 Ounce Pouch
Grab this if you're making shaped sugar cookies. Having seasonal cutters means you can knock out holiday cookies during the same marathon. Two birds, one very long Saturday.
Wilton, Plastic Cookie Cutter Set, 101-Piece, Assorted Colors
Use this in your white icing so it stays bright white instead of turning tan. Regular vanilla extract adds color, which ruins the look if you're going for clean decorated cookies.
Watkins, Imitation Clear Vanilla Extract, 2 fl oz, No color
Dip half your cookies in melted chocolate for a bakery finish. These melt smoother than regular chocolate chips. I used to microwave chips and they seized into a clumpy mess.
Merckens Melting Wafers White 25 lb
Toast this in a dry pan for 3 minutes and press it onto chocolate-dipped cookies. Adds texture and makes plain chocolate cookies look like something from a pastry case.
Bob's Red Mill Shredded Coconut (Unsweetened), 12-ounce
Storage and Cleanup So You Don't Lose Your Mind After
The baking is the fun part. The aftermath is 47 dirty bowls, flour on the ceiling, and nowhere to put six dozen cookies. These are the things that kept my kitchen from looking like a crime scene.
Stack your cookies in these with parchment between layers. Airtight seal keeps them fresh for a full week. I used to use zip bags and everything got crushed by day two.
Rubbermaid Food Storage Containers
Wrap your cooled bread loaves tightly in foil before freezing. Plastic wrap alone lets freezer burn in. Double wrapping with foil first kept my bread tasting fresh for a month.
Reynolds Wrap, Aluminum Foil, 12" x 200 Sq Ft, Standard
Layer this under your foil wrap for bread going into the freezer. The double barrier is worth the extra 30 seconds. I lost a beautiful sourdough loaf to freezer burn last December.
Glad Cling'N Seal Food Wrap, 200 sq ft Roll
Spray this on your crusty mixing bowls and sheet pans immediately. Dried-on cookie dough is basically cement after an hour. This cuts through baked-on grease without soaking overnight.
Dawn Platinum Powerwash Dish Spray, Dish Soap
Keep fresh sponges on hand for marathon cleanup. Your old sponge that's been sitting by the sink for three weeks is not going to cut it against six hours of baked-on batter.
Scotch-Brite, Cleaning Sponges, Blue
Toss your extra flour, sugar, and baking supplies in these bins between marathons. Keeps pantry moths out and everything organized so you're not hunting for baking powder next time.
Sterilite 6 Qt Small Clear Plastic Storage Bin with Snap-On
Pour your brown sugar and powdered sugar into these so they don't turn into solid rocks between baking days. I chiseled through a brick of brown sugar once. Never again.
OXO POP Container 5-Piece Set White Food Storage
Bounty Paper Towels Select-A-Size White, 8 Triple Rolls
Portion your extra muffins into these and freeze them flat. Pop one in the microwave for 30 seconds on a weekday morning and you've got a homemade breakfast without any effort.
Ziploc, Freezer Bags, Gallon, Grip 'n Seal Technology, 28 ct