Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Everything I Use to Make Cute + Spooky Clay Creatures (Beginner Friendly)
18
items If you want to make tiny ghosts, mushrooms, creepy-cute creatures, little trinkets, or clay jewelry. This is everything I personally use (or would recommend starting with). Simple and beginner-friendly—no gatekeeping, just cozy crafting vibes.
Sections
5
Clay
Basic tools
Texture-detail helpers
Painting & finishing
Extras
Clay
Clay I use for making trinkets, mushrooms and more
This is what I recommend if you’re just starting out. It’s super easy to work with, no baking needed, and perfect for making little ghosts, mushrooms, and simple creatures.
Das® Modeling Clay, Size: 2.2 lb, Color: White | Michaels
If you want more detailed, long-lasting pieces, this is the one. It takes a little more effort since you have to bake it, but the results look cleaner and more “finished.” I use this when I want tiny details like faces or textures to really stand out...
Sculpey® Premo! Classics Sampler Kit - Michaels
Basic tools
Tools for sculpting and making details look perfect on your creations
This is one of those things that instantly makes everything easier. You can shape, carve, and smooth without struggling, and it helps your pieces look way more intentional instead of lumpy.
Clay Tool Set by Craft Smart® | Michaels
Perfect for tiny details like eyes, mouths, and little textures. I use these constantly for faces—they make even simple pieces look 10x cuter.
9pcs Sculpting Tools,4pcs Double-Ended Metal Ceramic Clay Ball Stylus Dotting Tools and 5pcs 2 Way Silicone Polymer and Embossing Paper Flower Indentation Tool Set
Great for clean cuts and small details. If you want neat edges or to trim things without ruining your piece, this helps a lot.
Craft Knife by Recollections™ | Michaels
Makes flattening clay so much easier and more even. You can use anything honestly, but having a small one just feels nicer and more controlled.
9" Rolling Silicone Pin by Makery™ | Michaels
Texture-detail helpers
For little details our nimble fingers can’t reach
Cheap, simple, and weirdly essential. I use these for everything—details, texture, even just moving tiny pieces around without squishing them.
Great Value Round Toothpicks, 500 count
Perfect for smoothing and soft blending. They help get rid of fingerprints and give your pieces a cleaner finish without messing up the shape. Can be old makeup brushes just using this as a reference
EcoTools Start the Day Beautifully Makeup Brush Kit with Storage Tray, 6 Piece Set
Lightly dabbing with a sponge can smooth out rough spots and add subtle texture. It’s a small step that makes a big difference.
Variety Sponge Value Pack by Craft Smart® | Michaels
These are amazing for clean, smooth finishes. They don’t stick to the clay as much, so you can shape things without leaving marks everywhere.
Clay Shaper Set #2 By Craft Smart® | Michaels
Painting & finishing
Super beginner-friendly and works on pretty much everything. This is where your pieces really come to life—perfect for adding personality, color, and little details.
16 Color Matte Acrylic Paint Value Pack by Craft Smart® | Michaels
If you’re painting tiny faces or designs, these are a must. They make it so much easier to get clean lines instead of messy blobs.
Detail Paint Brushes - 11 Piece Set
This gives your pieces that shiny, slightly magical look. I love using it on eyes or little accents to make them look more “alive.”
Mod Podge® Gloss, Size: 8 fl oz - Michaels
If you like a softer, more natural or earthy finish, this is perfect. It protects your piece without making it shiny.
Mod Podge® Super Matte Sealer, 8oz. - Michaels
Extras
Totally optional these are just little extras to give you creative ideas
These turn your creations into charms, necklaces, or keychains. Super small detail, but it opens up so many possibilities.
Cousin DIY 1030-Piece Gold Finish Jump Ring & Lobster Clasp Assortment – Metal Jewelry Findings Kit for Bracelet and Necklace Crafts
If you want to actually carry your little creations around, this is it. Makes your pieces feel more like something you’d buy in a shop.
Rhodium Keychain-Making Findings Kit by Bead Landing™ | Michaels
Perfect if you want to make tiny wearable pieces. Lightweight clay + these = really cute handmade earrings.
925 Sterling Silver Earring Hooks 150 PCS/75 Pairs,Ear Wires Fish Hooks,500pcs Hypoallergenic Earring Making kit with Jump Rings and Clear Silicone Earring Backs Stoppers (Silver)
Honestly one of my favorite uses—turn your creations into little fridge creatures. It’s such a fun and easy way to display them.
Pro MAG® Value Pack Button Magnets, .5" | Michaels