Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

10 Creative Promposal Ideas to Make Them Say Yes!

Purple Star emoji 34 items
Prom season is here, and it's time to make your promposal unforgettable! Whether you're looking to charm your crush or delight your sweetheart, these creative promposal ideas will surely get a "yes." From sweet and simple gestures to elaborate surpri...
** Please note, some links in my lists are affiliate links. If you make a purchase through my link I'll make a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you.
Sections
10
 
 
 
 
 
 

Sweet & Simple Cupcake Proposal

Bake or buy a batch of cupcakes and decorate them to spell out "PROM?" Arrange them beautifully in a box or platter and surprise your date by presenting it as a sweet invitation.

 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Bake or buy a batch of cupcakes
Cupcakes
placeholder
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Decorate the Cupcakes to spell out "PROM?"
Edible icing pens
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Add some decorative sprinkles
Sprinkles for Cupcakes
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Arrange them beautifully in a box or platter and surprise your date by presenting it as a sweet invitation.
Cupcake Gift Boxes
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Include their favorite cupcake flavor or customize the frosting in their favorite colors for a personal touch.
Extra Cute Tip: favorite cupcake flavor

Glow-in-the-Dark Surprise

Write your promposal message with glow-in-the-dark paint or markers on a large poster board. Set it up in a dark room and invite your date inside—turn off the lights to reveal your glowing proposal!

 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Write your promposal message with glow-in-the-dark paint or markers on a large poster board.
Glow In The Dark Paint Pens
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Write your promposal message with glow-in-the-dark paint or markers on a large poster board.
Extra Large Poster Board
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Set it up in a dark room and invite your date inside—turn off the lights to reveal your glowing proposal!
Dark room or space for the reveal
placeholder
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Have glow sticks or fairy lights around the room for added atmosphere.
Extra Cute Tip: GLow Sticks

Puzzle Proposal

Order or create a custom puzzle with your promposal printed on it. Gift the puzzle pieces to your date, and wait excitedly as they piece together your question.

 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Order or create a custom puzzle with your promposal printed on it.
Custom Puzzle
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Gift the puzzle pieces to your date, and wait excitedly as they piece together your question.
Box or cute container to gift puzzle pieces
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Include a photo of you both on the puzzle for an unforgettable keepsake.
Extra Cute Tip: Photo Puzzle

Balloon Surprise

Fill several balloons with small notes or letters spelling out “PROM?” along with confetti. Have your date pop balloons one by one until your special message is revealed.

 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Fill several balloons with small notes or letters spelling out “PROM?” along with confetti.
Balloons (helium or regular)
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Fill several balloons with small notes or letters spelling out “PROM?” along with confetti.
Confetti
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Attach ribbons to balloons and tie them to their favorite candy or small gifts.
Extra Cute Tip: Ribbon with Candy

Pet-assisted Proposal

Attach a cute sign or ribbon with your promposal question to your (or their) pet. Have the adorable animal deliver your special message personally.

 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Attach a cute sign or ribbon with your promposal question to your (or their) pet.
Cute pet (dog, cat, bunny, etc.)
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Dress the pet in a cute bowtie or floral collar for extra sweetness.
Extra Cute Tip: Cute bowtie or floral collar

Starry String Light Proposal

Spell out your promposal message using string lights in an outdoor area or cozy indoor space. Invite your date to discover your bright and romantic request.

 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Spell out your promposal message using string lights in an outdoor area or cozy indoor space.
String lights or fairy lights
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Invite your date to discover your bright and romantic request.
Outdoor or cozy indoor location
placeholder
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Add candles or flowers around the area to enhance the romantic atmosphere.
Extra Cute Tip: Candles or Flowers

Fortune Cookie Proposal

Get a custom fortune cookie made with a message inside asking your date to prom. Give it to them after a meal or in a cute takeout box.

 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Get a custom fortune cookie made with a message inside asking your date to prom.
Custom Fortune Cookies
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Give it to them after a meal or in a cute takeout box.
A small takeout box for the presentation
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Include a handwritten menu of "reasons why you should say yes."
Extra Cute Tip: A handwritten menu
placeholder

Fairy Tale Theme

Create a short storybook or scroll telling the tale of how you met and how the story leads to the perfect prom date request.

 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Create a short storybook or scroll telling the tale of how you met and how the story leads to the perfect prom date request.
Handmade storybook
placeholder
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Create a short storybook or scroll telling the tale of how you met and how the story leads to the perfect prom date request.
A royal crown
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Extra Cute Suggestion: Dress as a prince or princess and present the book in a dramatic fashion.
Extra Cute Tip: Dress as a prince
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Extra Cute Suggestion: Dress as a prince or princess and present the book in a dramatic fashion.
Extra Cute Tip: Dress as a princess

Red Carpet Moment

Set up a mini red carpet leading to you holding a sign that says "Be my prom date?" and have friends act as paparazzi taking "celebrity" pictures of them as they walk in.

 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Set up a mini red carpet leading to you holding a sign that says "Be my prom date?"
Red Carpet Runner
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Have friends act as paparazzi taking "celebrity" pictures as they walk in.
Friends with cameras or phones to act as paparazzi
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Hand them an invitation
A sign or formal invitation
placeholder
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Extra Cute Suggestion: Hand them an "award" for being the best prom date ever.
Extra Cute Tip: "Award" for best prom date.
placeholder

Car Trunk Message

Decorate the inside of your car trunk with fairy lights, photos, and a sign that says "Prom?" Ask your date to grab something from the trunk for a fun surprise.

 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Decorate the inside of your car trunk with fairy lights
String Lights
placeholder
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Decorate the inside of your car trunk with fairy lights, photos, and a sign that says "Prom?"
Photo Clip String Lights
 
Ann Vanhuysse profile picture
Extra Cute Tip: Add their favorite snack or a stuffed animal for an extra thoughtful touch.
Extra Cute Tip: Add their favorite stuffed animal.