Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Replaced Kraft Mac and Cheese and My Kids Didn't Even Notice
28
items Every week it was the same thing. Two boxes of the blue box, gone in minutes, and my grocery bill kept climbing. I started testing cheaper alternatives and off-brand options until I found a full lineup my three kids actually request by name. If you'r...
Sections
7
Boxed Mac and Cheese That Tastes Like the Blue Box
Cheese Powders and Mix-Ins for Homemade Batches
Noodles That Hold Cheese Better Than Elbows
Shredded Cheeses for Baked Mac and Cheese
Breadcrumb Toppings That Make It Feel Fancy
Spices and Seasonings That Kids Actually Accept
Boxed Mac and Cheese That Tastes Like the Blue Box
My oldest literally did a blind taste test and picked two of these over Kraft. I almost didn't believe it until he asked for seconds.
Grab a few boxes and do your own blind test. My seven-year-old picked this over the name brand three times in a row, and it's less than a dollar a box. Stock your pantry before the next grocery price hike.
Great Value Original Macaroni & Cheese, 7.25 oz
Switch to this if your kid is the type who inspects every noodle. The cheese coating is smoother than most organics I've tried, and my daughter who rejects anything ‘weird looking’ eats it without complaints.
Annie's Classic Mild Cheddar Mac & Cheese
Keep this on hand for the nights when nothing else will do. The sauce is creamier and thicker than powder-based options. My neighbor's kid literally cried happy tears the first time I served it.
Velveeta Shells and Cheese Mac and Cheese
Try this if you go through three boxes a week like we do. Tastes close enough to Kraft that nobody at my table noticed the swap, and the savings added up to almost $15 a month.
Marketside Ready to Heat Classic Macaroni and Cheese
Cheese Powders and Mix-Ins for Homemade Batches
One Saturday I made a pot from scratch and my kids looked at me like I'd invented something. These are the ingredients that made it happen in under 20 minutes.
Toss a few tablespoons into any plain elbow macaroni and you've got mac and cheese that rivals anything from a box. I bought a bag in January and I'm still using it. Perfect for families who eat this stuff on rotation.
Hoosier Hill Farm, Cheddar Cheese Powder, 1 lb Jar
Use this instead of regular butter when stirring in the cheese. It melts faster and blends smoother, which matters when you've got three hungry kids yelling from the table and exactly four minutes of patience left.
Land O'Lakes Butter with Canola Oil, Spreadable, 15 oz Tub
Swap out water or skim for whole milk in any boxed recipe. Sounds obvious but the difference is wild. My mac went from grainy cafeteria vibes to something I'd actually eat myself.
Great Value Whole Vitamin D Milk, Gallon
Snag a brick and stir in about two tablespoons per pot. This is the secret my aunt used for years and I'm mad she waited until I was 34 to tell me. Makes the sauce ridiculously velvety.
Philadelphia Cream Cheese, 2 Blocks, for Recipes
Noodles That Hold Cheese Better Than Elbows
Regular elbows let half the sauce slide right off. Once I switched shapes, my kids started scraping the bowl clean instead of leaving a cheese puddle at the bottom.
Use these spirals and watch how much cheese clings to every twist. My middle kid used to pick out the ‘naked noodles’ and leave them on the plate. That stopped completely with these.
Barilla, Cellentani Pasta, 16 oz, Kosher Certified
Grab this for a budget-friendly spiral option. The ridges and curves hold sauce like a champ. I made a batch for a playdate and two other moms asked me what brand I used.
Specialty Cut Cavatappi Pasta, 16 oz- Pack of 3
Try rotini if your kids are suspicious of new shapes. They look familiar enough that nobody revolted, but they hold about twice the cheese of regular elbows. Win-win for under two bucks.
Barilla, Rotini Pasta, Kosher Certified, Non-GMO, 16 oz
Keep a box around for baked mac and cheese nights. Each little shell turns into a tiny cheese cup. My five-year-old calls them ‘cheese boats’ and honestly that's the best product review I've ever heard.
Great Value Shells, 16 oz
Shredded Cheeses for Baked Mac and Cheese
Friday nights became baked mac nights at our house. Took me a while to figure out which cheeses melt right without turning into an oily mess.
Ditch pre-shredded mild and go sharp. The flavor is stronger so you actually use less, and the finer shred melts without clumping. My grocery bill dropped and the taste improved. Rare combo.
Great Value Sharp Cheddar Finely Shredded Cheese
Toss a handful on top before baking. These melt into that glossy, stretchy layer that makes kids (and adults, no judgment) pull the dish apart like pizza. Nothing else melts quite the same way.
Velveeta Shreds Original Flavored Shredded Cheese
Use this for a milder baked version when you're feeding a crowd of kids with different spice tolerances. It melts evenly and doesn't separate like some store brands I wasted money on.
Sargento® Colby-Jack Sliced Cheese, 11 slices
Pair this with cheddar for a stretchy top layer that browns perfectly. My kids fight over the crispy cheese edges, and mixing in mozzarella gives you way more of those golden spots.
Great Value Low-Moisture Part-Skim Mozzarella Shredded
Breadcrumb Toppings That Make It Feel Fancy
My husband said my baked mac tasted ‘restaurant quality’ after I started adding a crunchy topping. Took about 30 extra seconds and zero extra skill.
Grab the basic canister and mix with a little melted butter before sprinkling on top. Bake until golden. My kids went from 'what's that crunchy stuff' to requesting it every single time within one week.
Great Value Plain Bread Crumbs, 15 oz
Switch to panko if you want bigger, crunchier flakes. The texture contrast with creamy mac underneath is something my picky eater actually gets excited about. That alone makes it worth the extra dollar.
4-C
Toss these on top during the last five minutes of baking. Sounds weird for mac and cheese but my sister-in-law did it at Thanksgiving and now my kids ask for ‘the crunchy onion kind’ by name.
French's Kosher Original Crispy Fried Onions, 6.0 oz Can
Use these when you're too tired to season plain crumbs yourself. Italian herbs are already mixed in and it adds just enough flavor that the topping doesn't taste like cardboard. Weeknight shortcut I refuse to apologize for.
Great Value Italian Style Bread Crumbs, 15 oz
Spices and Seasonings That Kids Actually Accept
Getting flavor into mac and cheese without my kids detecting ‘something different’ was a months-long covert operation. These passed the inspection every time.
Use a quarter teaspoon per pot. It's subtle enough that no kid has ever flagged it, but it rounds out the cheese flavor in a way that plain mac just can't touch. I add it to every batch now without thinking.
McCormick® Garlic Powder, 3.12 oz
Try just a tiny pinch mixed into the cheese sauce. You can't taste mustard at all, but it sharpens the cheddar flavor like magic. My mom taught me this trick and I'm passing it along before you waste another bland pot.
Great Value Ground Mustard, 1.5 oz
Swap regular salt for this and the whole pot tastes more intentional. My neighbor brought her kids over and asked why my mac tasted ‘more like something’ than hers. This was the only difference.
Lawry's Kosher Economy Size Seasoned Salt, 16.0 oz Bottle
Snag this for older kids who can handle a tiny bit of smokiness. Half a teaspoon gives the cheese sauce a warmth that made my ten-year-old say ‘this tastes like the fair.’ Highest compliment he's ever given food.
McCormick Gourmet Organic Smoked Paprika, 1.62 oz Bottle
Quick Proteins to Turn Mac Into a Full Meal
I got tired of making mac and cheese plus a separate protein. Adding one of these straight into the pot turned it into a one-dish dinner that actually fills everyone up.
Chop these up and toss them right into the pot. Dinner goes from side dish to full meal in about two minutes. For parents running on fumes by 6 PM, this is the move. My kids call it ‘chicken mac’ and request it weekly.
Grilled Chicken Breast Strips, 22 oz (Frozen, Fully Cooked)
Throw a handful on top of each bowl. My kids act like they're at a restaurant when bacon shows up on mac and cheese. It's shelf-stable so I keep a bag in the pantry for emergencies, which happen more often than I'd like to admit.
Hormel, Real Crumbled Bacon Topping, 20 oz, Shelf Stable
Drain it and stir it in for a protein-packed version that costs almost nothing. My grandmother made tuna mac every Friday and I thought it was fancy. Turns out it was just budget-friendly genius. Works especially well with shell pasta.
Great Value Chunk Light Tuna in Water, 5 oz
Dice this up and pan-fry the pieces until crispy, then mix into the mac. Sounds chaotic but it's basically a deconstructed grilled cheese sandwich. My kids went absolutely wild the first time I tried it and now it's a regular rotation meal.
Bar-S Classic Bologna, Sliced Deli Lunch Meat, 12 oz