Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
How I Got My Book Club to Actually Pick Books Without a Three-Hour Argument
50
items Every month it was the same drama — someone dominates the pick, half the group quietly resents it, and two people ghost the next meeting. I switched to anonymous voting with a real system and suddenly everyone shows up having actually read the book. ...
Sections
10
Ballot and Voting Supplies That Keep It Anonymous
Book Display and Organization for Nominees
Cozy Reading Nooks That Make People Finish the Book
Snacks That Keep the Discussion Going
Wine and Drink Setup for Book Club Night
Discussion Prompts and Conversation Starters
Ballot and Voting Supplies That Keep It Anonymous
People in my group were too polite to disagree out loud but too annoyed to keep showing up. Anonymous ballots fixed everything — no hurt feelings, no side-eyes, just honest picks.
Print your ballot categories right on these — I format mine with title, genre, and a one-sentence pitch so voters actually know what they're choosing between.
Avery Index Cards, 3" x 5", Laser & Inkjet, 150ct (5388)
Assign each voter a random color so you can tally without names. My friend Sarah figured out the system immediately but everyone else loves the mystery.
Crayola Colored Pencil Set, 50 Ct, School Supplies
Keep one of these as your running archive of every vote result. Flip back through it when someone claims ‘we never pick thrillers’ — receipts don't lie.
Small Notebooks 3X5 3X5 Inch Pocket Spiral Notepad
Laminate your nomination cards so they survive being passed around with wine-sticky fingers. Learned this after a Merlot incident destroyed three picks.
Scotch, Thermal Laminating Pouches, 8.5" x 11", 3 mil
Toss a handful on the table so nobody has to ask for a pen and accidentally reveal their handwriting. Paranoid? Maybe. But my group takes anonymity seriously.
BIC Round Stic Xtra Life Ballpoint Pens, Medium Point
Book Display and Organization for Nominees
Dumping a pile of books on a coffee table wasn't working — people just grabbed whatever was on top. A little display setup made everyone actually consider all the options.
Line up all the nominated books spine-out on this so people can browse like a tiny bookstore. Fits perfectly on a side table without taking over the room.
Three Tier Bamboo Shelf: Storage & Accessories
Stick a neon label on each nominee's spine with a number so voters can just write a number instead of a title. Speeds up the whole process.
Avery, Removable Labels, 1" x 2-5/8", Assorted Neon 360ct
Use this to display a printed card with the month's voting rules — sounds extra but it stopped three people from voting for two books at once.
Mainstays 5x7 Front Loading Picture Frame, Black, Set of 12
Hang nominee book covers on the wall gallery-style for the meeting. Peel them off clean afterward — my landlord will never know.
Command Medium (10 lb) Picture Hanging Strips
Grab this as your ballot box. Slot the votes through the lid gap, shake it up dramatically before counting. The theater of it makes people actually care.
CLEAR
Cozy Reading Nooks That Make People Finish the Book
Half my group wasn't finishing books because they had nowhere comfortable to read. Sounds like an excuse until you realize they were trying to read in bed and falling asleep on page twelve.
Dedicate one shelf per month's pick and stack related reads nearby. Seeing the physical book every day guilts you into picking it up — works on me every time.
Sauder Beginnings 5-Shelf Bookcase, Highland Oak Finish
Wrap up in this on the couch and suddenly you're reading for two hours instead of scrolling. Bought one for myself and three more as club gifts.
Better Homes and Gardens Sherpa Blankets
Use this when your partner goes to sleep and you still have 80 pages left before tomorrow's meeting. Saved my marriage and my book club reputation simultaneously.
Customer reviews for Mainstays Clip Light 18.5" LED
Switch to magnetic bookmarks so they don't fall out when you shove the book in your bag. Lost my place in a 400-page novel once and almost quit the club.
Pen + Gear Magnetic Page Markers, 6 Count, White & Black
Prop two of these behind your back in that reading corner chair. Comfort is the difference between reading one chapter and finishing half the book.
Mainstays Decorative Throw Pillow, Brown, 18 in x 18
Snacks That Keep the Discussion Going
Nobody debates plot twists on an empty stomach. The meetings where I forgot snacks lasted twenty minutes. The ones with a full spread went two hours.
Grab this on your way home from work the day of the meeting — zero prep, looks like you tried, and the ranch runs out first every single time.
Marketside Vegetable Tray with Ranch Dip, 20 oz
Pair these with literally any dip and watch them disappear. Crunchy enough to eat during heated literary debates without being obnoxiously loud.
Stacy's Pita Chips, Simply Naked, Party Size, 18 oz
Set these out individually so everyone gets their own little snack tray. Feels fancy, costs almost nothing, and no double-dipping drama.
Sargento® Balanced Breaks® Cheese & Crackers
Put these in a bowl for dessert and watch the person who hated this month's pick suddenly feel better about everything. Chocolate fixes book opinions.
Ghirardelli Milk Chocolate Squares with Caramel Filling
Keep a case of these cold for people who don't drink wine at book club. Normalize non-alcoholic options — some of my best members are sober.
La Croix Sparkling Water Variety Pack, 12 Fl Oz Cans
Wine and Drink Setup for Book Club Night
Our first few meetings had mismatched mugs and warm white wine. A small drink station made it feel like an actual event people wanted to dress up for.
Ditch the random collection of cups and get a matching set. Sounds silly but everyone commented on it and the meetings immediately felt more intentional.
Libbey Classic Smoke All-Purpose Stemless Wine Glass
Keep this in your book club supply box so you're never hunting through drawers while guests wait. Opened probably 60 bottles with mine and it still works perfectly.
Rabbit Wine Opener Set Zinc Alloy with Foil Cutter
Bring this for the sweet wine people — every group has at least two and they'll love you for remembering. Crowd-pleaser that pairs with literally any genre.
Barefoot Cellars Pink Moscato Wine - 1.5L Bottle
Brew individual cups for the people who drive far and need caffeine for the ride home. One member told me this is why she keeps coming back.
K-Express™ Single Serve Coffee Maker
Offer tea alongside coffee and wine — on cold nights half the group picks chamomile and the conversation gets surprisingly deep.
Twinings of London Variety Pack Black Tea Bags
Discussion Prompts and Conversation Starters
Without structure, our discussions turned into ‘I liked it’ or ‘I didn’t' and then awkward silence. Printed prompts cracked everything open.
Pass this around and have each member fill a page about their reading habits. Pull from it when you need to match book picks to actual preferences.
Customer reviews for Piccadilly Guided Journal Ages 12-16
Rip discussion questions straight from this instead of spending an hour writing your own. Freed up my Sunday nights completely.
Books Boxed Set Collections for Readers
Stick these throughout your copy while reading and jot reactions in real time. Bring the marked-up book to the meeting and you'll never sit there with nothing to say.
Post-it Super Sticky Notes Limited Edition Pack
Use this as your dedicated book club journal — write reactions after each chapter so you remember what you actually thought, not what the group tells you to think.
Moleskine, Classic Notebook, Hard Cover, Large 5" x 8.25"
Pull a card when conversation stalls — these go way deeper than ‘did you like the ending’ and have started actual arguments in the best way.
TableTopics Book Club Questions
Tracking Reads and Building a Book Club History
After a year we couldn't remember what we'd read or who nominated what. Building a system turned our random meetings into something that actually felt like it mattered.
Track every club pick with ratings, favorite quotes, and who nominated it. Flip through it at your anniversary meeting and watch everyone get weirdly emotional.
Customer reviews for Clever Fox Reading Journal
Tab your journal by month so you can flip to any meeting's notes instantly. Settled a ‘we already read that author’ debate in under ten seconds.
Avery Margin Ultra Tabs, 2.5" x 1"
Print your own voting ballots, discussion guides, and monthly reading calendars. Paid for itself after three months of not running to the copy shop.
Canon PIXMA TR4720 Wireless Inkjet All-in-One Printer
Print book cover collages for your year-in-review meeting. Someone framed theirs and I've never felt more validated as a club organizer.
HP Everyday Glossy Photo Paper | 8.5 x 11 in, 50 Sheets
Pin up each month's pick cover and final vote tally. Hang it in your reading nook — it's basically a trophy wall for your group's taste.
Quartet Cork Bulletin Board, 36 x 24 Inches
Comfortable Seating for Groups of Six to Ten
Four people crammed on a loveseat while two sat on the floor wasn't working. A few seating additions meant everyone could actually relax and focus on the discussion.
Toss one of these in the corner for the person who always arrives last. Folds flat and stores behind a door — nobody has to sit on the floor anymore.
Mainstays Faux Fur Saucer Chair, Pink
Inflate this, pile it with pillows, and suddenly you have a lounge spot for two. Weird? Yes. Comfortable? Extremely. My group fights over it.
Intex 10" Twin Standard Dura-Beam Airbed Mattress
Stack three of these for floor seating that doesn't destroy your back. Way better than the yoga mat situation I was running before.
Floor Cushions for Comfortable Seating
Keep two of these in a closet for overflow guests. They're surprisingly comfortable and fold small enough that storage isn't an issue.
Ozark Trail Quad Folding Camp Chair with Cup Holder, Red
Scatter these on the floor and couch for extra back support. Cheap enough to buy several and they make the whole room look like you planned a real event.
Mainstays Chenille Decorative Pillow Set, 18 x 18
Ambiance and Mood Setting for Meeting Night
Reading a thriller in fluorescent lighting felt wrong. Small atmosphere tweaks made people linger longer and actually enjoy being there instead of checking their phones.
Light this thirty minutes before people arrive so the room smells like a cabin bookshop. Three members have asked me what candle I use — this is the one.
Better Homes & Gardens Fragrance Oil Warm Rustic
Wrap these behind your bookshelf for a warm glow that makes the whole room feel like a reading lounge. Took fifteen minutes to install and changed everything.
Daybetter 50FT LED Strip Lights, Music Sync 5050 RGB
Play low instrumental vinyl while people settle in and vote. Something about the crackle makes everyone put their phones down without being asked.
Customer reviews for Victrola Bluetooth Belt Drive Vintage
Drape these across your patio for summer meetings outside. Moved our July meeting to the deck and attendance hit 100% for the first time ever.
Mainstays 35-Count Outdoor LED Edison Bulb String
Swap to these if anyone in your group is sensitive to candle flames. Same cozy smell, no fire anxiety, and your smoke detector stays quiet.
Yankee Candle Lemon Scented Wax Melts, Clean Cotton
Books That Won Every Vote in My Club
After two years of anonymous voting, certain books crushed it unanimously. These are the ones that sparked the longest discussions and zero regrets.
Bring this to nomination night and watch it win — every single person in my group rated it five stars and we talked for three hours straight.
Gabrielle Zevin, Novel, Tomorrow
Nominate this if your group skews toward people who say they don't like romance and then devour it in two days. Happened to three of us.
The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo: A Novel (Paperback)
Toss this into the ring when your club needs something funny after a heavy month. Sharp, warm, and the person who almost quit our group came back for this one.
Bonnie Garmus: Lessons in Chemistry: A Novel (Hardcover)
Try this on the sci-fi skeptics — two members said they'd never read science fiction and both texted me at midnight saying they couldn't stop. Unanimous pick.
Andy Weir, Novel, Project Hail Mary, A Sci-Fi Thriller
Save this for a month when your group is ready to feel something real. Dense but worth it — our discussion ran so long we had to schedule a part two.
Barbara Kingsolver, Novel, Demon Copperhead, Hardcover