Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Found Pie Tools That Keep My Crust Flaky Without Cracking
35
items If you spend hours on a homemade pie only to watch the top crust bubble, crack, or turn into a soggy mess, this list is for you. I ruined more Thanksgiving pies than I care to admit before I landed on these specific tools. Whether you bake once a yea...
Sections
5
Pie Birds and Steam Vents That Actually Work
Pie Crust Shields That Prevent Burnt Edges
Rolling Pins and Mats for Even Crust Thickness
Pie Plates and Dishes That Bake Evenly
Finishing Tools for a Professional Looking Pie
Pie Birds and Steam Vents That Actually Work
My crusts used to crack right down the middle every single time. Turns out letting steam escape through a pie bird instead of slashing the top changed everything. These little guys sit in the center and do the work for you.
Grab this if you've been slashing vents into your crust like a horror movie. Placed it dead center in my apple pie and the steam vented perfectly through its beak. Crust stayed intact for the first time in years.
Mrs. Anderson's Baking Pie Bird, Fine Porcelain
Use this one for deeper dish pies. It's tall enough that the filling doesn't bubble over and block the vent. My cherry pie came out clean for once instead of looking like a crime scene.
Norpro Ceramic Pie Bird, 4in/10cm tall, Black, Oven Safe
Toss this in if you're someone who always overfills the pie. It handles the extra steam without tipping over. My sister borrowed one and immediately ordered her own.
Mrs. Anderson's Baking Pie Bird, Fine Porcelain
Try this for a simpler look that blends into the crust. Works just as well as the fancier ones. I use it for pot pies on weeknights and it keeps the pastry from getting that weird dome.
Fox Run Cherry Pie Vent, Pie Bird for Baking
Switch to this funnel style if the bird shape feels too kitschy for your kitchen. Same steam-venting principle, just a straight cylinder. Perfect for savory pies where you want a cleaner top.
Ceramic Pie Funnel - KITCHEN CRAFT - 7cm
Keep this one around if you bake a lot and worry about chipping ceramic. It's metal, heats evenly, and survived three years of weekly pie baking in my house without a scratch.
Norpro Ceramic Pie Bird, 4in/10cm tall, Black, Oven Safe
Snag this if you want something pretty enough to leave in the pie at the table. It's a conversation starter at dinner parties. My mother-in-law asked about it before she even tasted the pie.
Emile Henry 9 Inch Round Modern Classic Ceramic Pie
Pie Crust Shields That Prevent Burnt Edges
Nothing worse than a perfectly vented center and edges that look charcoal. I used to wrap foil around the rim like some kind of aluminum foil sculptor. These shields saved me the hassle and actually fit.
Grab this before your next bake. It stretches to fit 9 and 10 inch pans without slipping off. My pecan pie edges finally came out golden instead of black.
Customer reviews for Norpro Silicone Mini Pie Crust Shields
Use this for standard pie plates. It sits on the rim and doesn't budge even when you slide the pie in and out of the oven. Took me three burned pumpkin pies to finally buy one.
Customer reviews for (4 pack) Mrs. Anderson's Baking Pie
Try this if you're on a budget and just want something that works. It's adjustable and fits most pie dishes. Paid less than a cup of coffee and saved every pie since.
Wilton Adjustable Silicone Pie Crust Shield
Keep a couple on hand if you bake multiple pies at once. Thanksgiving with four pies and only one shield was a nightmare I only lived through once.
Set Of 2 Silicone Pie Crust Shields
Pair this with a deep dish pan. The adjustable size means it works on oddball pie plates too. I have a vintage dish from my grandma that nothing else fits.
Fox Run One Piece Pie Crust Shield, Carbon Steel, 10-Inch
Snag this for a sturdier option that won't warp after a dozen uses. It holds its shape in high heat. Been using the same one since 2021 and it still looks new.
Pie Crust Shield
Get the multi-pack if you're the person everyone calls for holiday desserts. Five shields means five pies with perfect edges. I go through all of them every December.
Norpro Reusable 10" Pie Crust Shield, Inch, As Shown
Rolling Pins and Mats for Even Crust Thickness
Uneven crust was my biggest enemy for years. Thick spots stayed doughy, thin spots cracked. Getting the dough uniform before it even hits the pan fixed half my problems overnight.
Use the removable rings to set your dough thickness. I stopped guessing and my crusts went from inconsistent to restaurant-level. It's the single tool that made the biggest difference.
Joseph Joseph 20085 Adjustable Rolling Pin
Toss this on your counter before rolling. The circle guides show you exactly how wide to go for your pan size. No more trimming off huge chunks of wasted dough.
Mainstays Reusable Silicone 24"x 16" Pastry Mat
Try this if you want more control over pressure. The tapered ends let you feel exactly where the dough is thicker. Took me one pie to understand why French bakers prefer this shape.
French Wood Rolling Pin 15.7 Inch Tapered Dough Roller
Grab this if you want a reliable handled pin that doesn't cost much. It's heavier than it looks, which means less effort from your arms. My wrists thank me every baking day.
FARBERWARE Classic Wood Rolling Pin
Switch to this when you're tired of dough sticking to wood. The nonstick surface means less flour on the dough, which keeps the crust tender instead of tough.
OXO Good Grips Non-stick Rolling Pin
Keep this under your dough while rolling. It grips the counter so nothing slides around. Before this, I was chasing my dough across the kitchen like it was trying to escape.
GORILLA GRIP Nonstick Silicone Baking Mats, 2PK
Snag this if your kitchen runs warm and your butter keeps melting into the dough. The metal stays cool, which means flakier layers. Cold butter is the whole secret and this pin helps.
Ateco Fondant Rolling Pin
Pie Plates and Dishes That Bake Evenly
I blamed my oven for years before realizing my cheap tin pie pan was the real problem. Switching to the right dish meant the bottom actually cooked through instead of staying pale and soggy.
Use glass so you can actually see the bottom browning. I flipped my first pie out of this and the bottom was golden for the first time ever. Felt like I unlocked a cheat code.
9 Inch Glass Pie Plate for Baking and Freezing, Pyrex
Grab this for fruit pies where you pile the filling high. The ceramic holds heat evenly and the deep walls keep everything inside. No more juice rivers on the oven floor.
Emile Henry Pie Dish White Deep Dish
Try this if you want that diner-style crust. The steel conducts heat fast so the bottom sets before the filling makes it soggy. My banana cream pie finally had structure.
USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Pie Pan, 9-Inch
Keep this around for pies you serve right in the dish. It looks nice enough for the table and bakes evenly. I bring this to potlucks and people think I'm fancier than I am.
CorningWare FW111 French White 9 in Pie Plate
Switch to cast iron if your bottom crust is always underdone. The heat retention is unreal. Takes longer to cool but the crust comes out crispy every single time.
Lodge, Cast Iron Pizza Pan, 15 inch, Black, Pre-Seasoned
Pair this with a crust shield for the perfect combo. It's thinner glass so it heats quickly. Great for weeknight pot pies when you don't want to wait forever.
(2 pack) Anchor Hocking 9" Glass Pie Pan
Snag this as a backup pan when you're baking multiple pies. Lightweight, nonstick, and cheap enough to own four. I keep a stack in my cabinet for the holidays.
WILTON INDUSTRIES Recipe Right 9-Inch Non-Stick Pie
Finishing Tools for a Professional Looking Pie
Once I fixed the cracking and burning, I wanted pies that actually looked good too. These tools handle crimping, glazing, and decorating without requiring pastry school or steady hands.
Use this to cut clean lattice strips instead of hacking at dough with a knife. My lattice went from kindergarten art project to something I'd actually post online.
Ateco 5 Wheel Stainless Steel Cutter, 2 1/8 Inch Wheels
Grab this for egg wash. The silicone bristles don't shed into your crust like cheap ones do. I found a bristle baked into a pie once and that was enough motivation to switch.
OXO Good Grips Silicone 1" Pastry Brush
Keep this in your drawer for cutting butter into flour. A food processor works but this gives you more control over the chunk size. Bigger butter chunks mean flakier crust.
Norpro Stainless Steel Pastry Blender, One Size, Silver
Try these for decorative cutouts on top. Leaves, flowers, little shapes that make people think you spent way longer than you did. My Thanksgiving pie looked like it came from a bakery.
Wilton Fall Pie Crust Cutter Set, 6-Piece
Toss this in your toolbox for lifting dough off the counter cleanly. It doubles as a divider when you're splitting dough into portions. Cost almost nothing and I use it constantly.
Amerteer Spring Chef Stainless Steel Pastry Scraper
Pair this with your pie plate for smoothing fillings flat. Pumpkin pie with a perfectly level top looks so much better. Small detail but people notice.
Mercer Culinary Offset Spatula | 4.25"
Snag this immediately if you've never checked your actual oven temperature. Mine was off by 25 degrees. Every burnt crust, every raw center, explained in one $7 purchase. I was furious.
Taylor Oven Thermometer
