Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

I Tried Every Squash Recipe This Fall and These Kitchen Tools Nailed It

Purple Star emoji 33 items
You bought a delicata or kabocha on impulse, stared at it on the counter for three days, then gave up and made pasta again. Been there. This list is for anyone who wants to actually cook seasonal squash without wrestling it with a dull knife or endin...
Sections
7
 
 
 
 
 
 

Squash Cutting and Prep Tools That Save Your Hands

Spent twenty minutes sawing through a butternut with a flimsy knife last October and nearly lost a finger. These tools turned a dreaded chore into something I actually don't mind doing on a Tuesday night.

 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Grab this before you attempt another butternut. I went from white-knuckling a bread knife through squash to clean cuts in seconds. For anyone whose current knife makes them genuinely nervous.
8.00 inch, Chef Knife
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Use this on delicata and honeynut when you want the skin off. Peeled six squash for Thanksgiving without a single hand cramp. Your potato peeler is not cutting it, literally.
OXO Good Grips Swivel Peeler
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Switch to a board this size if you've been balancing a kabocha on a tiny one. Stability matters when you're pressing down hard. Wish someone told me this before I scratched up my countertop.
Totally Bamboo, Destination Texas Cutting Board, 20" x 18.9"
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Keep this next to your board. Scooping seeds and transferring cubed squash to a sheet pan takes one motion instead of five handfuls. Weirdly satisfying every single time.
Spring Chef Stainless Steel Pastry Scraper/Bench
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Toss one of these under your main board so it stops sliding around. Sounds small, but when you're leaning into a hard squash, that grip is the difference between confidence and a near-miss.
GORILLA GRIP, Cutting Board, Oversized

Sheet Pans and Roasting Gear for Perfect Caramelization

My squash kept coming out steamed and soggy until I figured out it was my cheap warped pan crowding everything together. Flat pan, space between pieces, high heat. That's the whole secret.

 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Get two of these so you can spread cubes in a single layer. Crowded squash steams instead of roasting. I learned this after three mushy batches and a lot of frustration.
Nordic Ware, Half Sheet, 18"x13" Aluminum
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Use pre-cut sheets instead of fighting a roll. Cleanup takes thirty seconds and nothing sticks. For anyone who's scrubbed caramelized maple off a pan at 10 PM, this is your fix.
foil cooking - Substituting freezer paper for parchment paper
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Swap this in when you run out of parchment. Squash slides right off and the edges get crispy without burning. Paid for itself in about a week of fall cooking.
Customer reviews for Silpat Silicone Mat for Baking Non
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Bring this out for whole acorn squash halves face-down. Deep sides catch the juices so your oven doesn't smoke. Handles actually stay cool long enough to pull it out safely.
Rachael Ray, Roaster, 16" x 12", Nonstick with Dual-Height
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Try flipping roasted squash wedges with this instead of tongs that crush them. Flexible enough to get under each piece without destroying the caramelized side. Small upgrade, big difference.
OXO International OXO Good Grips Silicone Spatula
placeholder

Maple Glazes and Seasonings That Actually Taste Like Fall

Dumping cinnamon on everything is not a flavor strategy. I went through a dozen spice combos before landing on the ones that make people ask for my recipe at every potluck.

 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Pour this on squash about ten minutes before it's done roasting. Grade A dark has that deep caramel thing going on. Pancake syrup will not give you the same result, don't even try.
Butternut Mountain Farm 100% Pure Vermont Maple Syrup
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Use half of what you think you need. Seriously. A quarter teaspoon per sheet pan is plenty when paired with maple. Went overboard once and my acorn squash tasted like a candle.
McCormick® Ground Cinnamon, 2.37 oz
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Toss this on with the maple for a sweet-smoky thing that catches people off guard. My brother-in-law who hates squash ate an entire pan. That's the only review that matters.
Simply Organic, Ground Smoked Paprika
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Sprinkle this right when squash comes out of the oven, not before. The crunch against soft roasted flesh is the part nobody tells you about. Changed everything for me.
Morton Kosher Salt Flakes 3 lb.

Oils and Fats for Crispy Roasted Edges

Olive oil works fine but it's not the only option. Playing around with different fats is what finally got me those dark, almost burnt-looking edges that taste incredible.

 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Drizzle this as your everyday base. Fruity enough to taste but won't overpower the squash. Stock up now because you'll go through it fast once roasting becomes a weekly habit.
Pompeian Robust Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 16 fl oz
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Melt a tablespoon into your maple glaze and brush it on halfway through roasting. The browning is unreal. For anyone who's been holding back on butter, fall squash is your permission slip.
Kerrygold Grass-Fed Salted Pure Irish Butter, 8 oz
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Try this with kabocha specifically. Something about the slight sweetness pairs perfectly. Went from skeptic to converting every friend who tried my coconut-roasted kabocha in one dinner.
Spectrum Naturals, Organic Virgin Coconut Oil, 14 fl oz
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Use this when you're roasting above 425 degrees. Higher smoke point means crispy edges without that bitter burnt taste. Learned the hard way after setting off my smoke alarm twice.
La Tourangelle High Heat Avocado Oil Spray, 5 fl oz (148 ml)
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Pair a drizzle of this with your maple for a double glaze situation. Sounds excessive but on carnival squash it's perfect. The friend who always brings wine to dinner will lose their mind.
Raw Honey

Squash Varieties Worth Trying Beyond Butternut

Butternut gets all the attention but there are at least five squash at the store right now that you're walking past. Each one roasts differently and some are way easier to prep.

 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Grab this one first if you're nervous about cutting hard squash. Skin is edible, seeds scoop out easy, and it roasts in 20 minutes. The gateway squash that started my whole obsession.
Roasted Delicata Squash Side Recipe
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Cut this in half, scoop seeds, roast face-down, then flip and fill with maple butter. Looks impressive at dinner but takes about five minutes of actual effort. Perfect for showing off.
Fresh Acorn Squash, Each
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Use this when you want a lighter base under roasted vegetables. Fork out the strands, toss with brown butter and sage. For anyone trying to eat more vegetables without feeling deprived.
Fresh Spaghetti Squash, Each
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Try this if you want something denser and sweeter than butternut. Skin gets tender when roasted so no peeling needed. Tastes like sweet potato met chestnut and they got along perfectly.
Shop Butternut Squash Fresh and Packaged

Storage and Meal Prep Containers for Batch Roasting

Once I started roasting squash I couldn't stop making huge batches. Needed somewhere to put it all that wasn't a pile of foil-wrapped lumps in my fridge.

 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Keep roasted squash fresh for five days without getting soggy. Clear sides so you actually see what's in there instead of playing fridge roulette. Lids snap tight and don't leak.
Rubbermaid, Food Storage Container, 9.6 Cup
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Pour leftover squash soup straight into these and freeze. Thaw one on a cold Thursday when you don't want to cook. For the person who batch cooks on Sunday and coasts all week.
Ball, Glass Mason Jars, 32 oz, Wide Mouth, with Lids
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Toss this over a sheet pan of leftover roasted cubes when you're too tired for proper containers. Sticks to itself, peels off clean. Lazy meal prep that actually works.
Glad, Press'n Seal Plastic Food Wrap, 100 sq ft, Clear
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Reheat squash right in these without transferring to another dish. One less thing to wash matters at 7 AM. Survived my dishwasher for two years and counting.
Pyrex Glass Storage Set 10-Piece Tinted Round
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Write the date on every container. Future you will not remember if that frozen soup is from October or February. Takes two seconds and prevents the sad moment of throwing out mystery food.
Sharpie, Permanent Markers, Fine Point, Black, 2 Count

Serving and Finishing Touches That Make It Feel Special

Eating roasted squash straight off the pan is fine, but spending thirty seconds on presentation turned a weeknight side into something my family actually gets excited about.

 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Drizzle a thin line over plated squash right before serving. The acid cuts through all that sweetness and wakes everything up. Took my roasted delicata from good to genuinely crave-worthy.
Pompeian Balsamic Vinegar - 16 fl oz
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Toast these in a dry pan for three minutes and scatter over your squash. The crunch against soft roasted flesh is addictive. For anyone whose side dishes always feel like they're missing something.
Fisher Chef's Naturals Pecan Halves 24 oz Resealable
placeholder
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Drop chunks over hot squash so they get slightly melty. Salty against maple glaze is the combo I never knew I needed. My vegetarian friend requests this specific dish at every gathering now.
Athenos Crumbled Traditional Feta Cheese 12 oz
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Pinch a few over the top if you like a little heat with your sweet. Not enough to burn, just enough to make your mouth pay attention. Turns a simple side into something people talk about.
McCormick Gourmet Organic Crushed Red Pepper
 
Scarlett Hayes profile picture
Zest a lemon over finished squash and watch it go from cozy to bright in one pass. Nobody expects citrus on roasted squash and that surprise factor is exactly why it works so well.
Microplane Premium Classic Zester Grater - White