Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Christmas Cookie Baking Supplies I Wish I Had Before Ruining Three Batches
40
items Last December I burned two trays of sugar cookies, cracked my only rolling pin, and ran out of vanilla extract mid-recipe with guests arriving in four hours. If your holiday baking sessions feel more like kitchen disasters than cozy traditions, this ...
Sections
8
Cookie Sheets That Actually Bake Evenly
Mixing Bowls and Measuring Tools That Don't Drive You Crazy
Rolling Pins and Cookie Cutters Worth Keeping
Vanilla Extract and Baking Staples That Make a Difference
Sprinkles and Decorating Supplies for Cookies That Look Homemade-Good
Stand Mixers and Hand Mixers That Handle Thick Dough
Cookie Sheets That Actually Bake Evenly
Half my cookies came out golden, the other half came out charcoal. Turns out my old dark pans were the problem, not the oven.
Swap out those warped dark pans — since switching to these, every single cookie on the tray comes out the same shade of golden brown. Perfect for anyone whose oven runs hot on one side.
Wilton, Recipe Right Cookie Sheet Set
Grab a couple of these before December hits. They don't warp, they don't stain easily, and my royal icing cookies finally stopped getting brown bottoms. Worth every penny.
Nordic Ware, Half Sheet, 18"x13" Aluminum
Keep these on hand for back-to-back batches — they cool down fast between rounds. Saved me so much time when I was cranking out five dozen gingerbread men in one afternoon.
Farberware Bakeware 3-Piece Nonstick Cookie Pan Set
Toss your rusty old sheet pans and try this one. My shortbread came out restaurant-level crispy on the edges, soft in the middle — and cleanup took about 30 seconds.
Wilton Premium Steel Non-Stick Medium Cookie Sheet, Gray
Use these instead of greasing your pans every single time. Cut my cleanup in half and my cookies slide right off. Honestly can't believe I spent years scrubbing pans for no reason.
Great Value Unbleached Parchment Paper, 50 Sq ft
Mixing Bowls and Measuring Tools That Don't Drive You Crazy
Nothing kills the holiday mood faster than realizing your measuring cups are buried somewhere and your only bowl is too small for a double batch.
Get the nesting set so they actually fit in your cabinet — I used to have five random bowls that took up an entire shelf. These stack perfectly and handle everything from whipping cream to mixing dough.
Pyrex® 8-piece Mixing Bowl Set with Assorted Lids
Ditch those flimsy plastic ones from the dollar store. The tablespoon on my old set snapped mid-recipe last Christmas and flung molasses across my counter. These feel solid and the markings don't fade.
Kitchenaid Universal Measure Cup Spoon Set in Black
Try reading a regular measuring cup at eye level while holding a toddler — impossible. The angled design lets you look down into it, which sounds small but changed everything for this tired parent.
OXO Good Grips 3-Piece Angled Measuring Cup Set
Use this for melting butter in the microwave and measuring liquid ingredients in one step. Fewer dishes, fewer splashes, and it pours without dribbling down the side.
Anchor Hocking 2 Qt. Graduated Glass Measuring Cup
Snag these if you need bowls that can handle hot sugar mixtures without warping. My plastic ones started looking sad after one caramel recipe — stainless steel just takes the heat.
Mainstays Stainless Steel Mixing and Storage Bowls Set
Rolling Pins and Cookie Cutters Worth Keeping
My wooden rolling pin literally split in half mid-roll last year. The dough stuck to everything and my cookie shapes looked like abstract art.
Bring this out for sugar cookies and pie crust — it's got a good weight so you're not pressing down like you're arm wrestling the dough. Replaced my cracked one and it's held up through three holiday seasons.
Farberware, Wood Rolling Pin with Classic Handles
Grab the big set so the kids can pick their own shapes without fighting. Stars, trees, snowflakes, gingerbread people — covers every classic without needing to buy five separate packs.
Wilton Halloween Cookie Cutter Set, 18-Piece
Use these for clean, perfect circles when you're making sandwich cookies or linzer cookies. The edges are sharp enough to cut cleanly through chilled dough without dragging.
Ateco 7808 Plain Edge Star Cutter Set in Graduated Sizes
Switch to this if your cookies always come out different thicknesses. The removable rings set the exact height — finally got uniform cookies that all bake in the same amount of time.
Joseph Joseph PrecisionPin Baking Adjustable Rolling Pin
Toss this on your counter before rolling out dough. No more flour everywhere, no more dough glued to the surface. My kitchen looked like a crime scene before I started using these.
Kitzini Silicone Baking Mat Set. Non-Stick
Vanilla Extract and Baking Staples That Make a Difference
Ran out of vanilla extract mid-batch once and tried subbing maple syrup. Don't do that. Stock up early because these sell out faster than you'd expect in December.
Stock up on this in November — I waited until December 20th last year and my store was completely wiped out. The real stuff makes sugar cookies taste like actual bakery cookies, not just sweet cardboard.
McCormick All Natural Pure Vanilla Extract, 4.0 fl oz Box
Keep a fresh box on hand because the one that's been deodorizing your fridge for six months will make your cookies taste weird. Learned that one the hard way with a batch of molasses cookies.
Baking Soda Arm and Hammer Multipurpose Food
Try tapping the can before opening — if nothing moves, it's dead and your cookies will come out flat. Fresh baking powder is the difference between puffy snickerdoodles and sad discs.
Clabber Girl, Baking Powder, Gluten-Free
Grab two bags before your baking marathon. I ran out halfway through a triple batch of gingerbread and had to make an emergency store run in flour-covered sweatpants. Not my finest moment.
Gold Medal All Purpose Flour, Baking Flour, 5 lb Bag
Use this for creaming with butter — the slightly larger crystals create better air pockets in the dough compared to store brand. My chocolate chip cookies got noticeably puffier after switching.
C&H Pure Cane Granulated Sugar, 4 lb Bag
Sprinkles and Decorating Supplies for Cookies That Look Homemade-Good
My first attempt at decorating looked like a toddler sneezed glitter on a tray of cookies. These supplies actually made me look like I know what I'm doing.
Pair this with some royal icing and suddenly you're piping clean lines on sugar cookies like you watched a YouTube tutorial — because you did, and now you finally have the right tips to pull it off.
Wilton 2104-1364 12-Piece Cupcake Decorating Set
Keep a tube in the pantry for quick fixes. When my piped icing cracked on a few cookies, I squeezed this over the top and nobody at the party knew the difference. Lazy? Maybe. Effective? Absolutely.
Betty Crocker, Cookie Decorating Icing, 7 Ounce Pouch
Snag this before the holiday rush — six colors in one container means fewer tiny jars rolling around your counter. The kids went wild decorating and I didn't have to clean up a sprinkle explosion.
WILTON JIMMIES RAINBOW SHORT 6 CELL 72g
Use the squeeze bottles for precise color mixing — I finally got that exact shade of Christmas red instead of hot pink. For anyone who's tired of their green icing looking like radioactive slime.
Wilton Color Right Performance Food Coloring Set
Toss a handful on sugar cookies right before baking for that sparkly, professional-looking finish. My neighbor asked if I ordered them from a bakery. Nope, just sanding sugar and good timing.
Wilton Sprinkles Sanding Sugar, Gold, Silver, and White
Stand Mixers and Hand Mixers That Handle Thick Dough
Tried mixing stiff gingerbread dough by hand once and my arm was sore for two days. A decent mixer turns a 20-minute arm workout into a 3-minute job.
Grab this if you don't have counter space for a stand mixer — it powers through butter and sugar without splattering everywhere. Whipped up three batches of buttercream frosting in one afternoon without my wrist giving out.
Hamilton Beach Electric Hand Mixer, 6-Speed Corded
Splurge on this before cookie season — it handles thick dough without stalling and the tilt-head design makes scraping the bowl actually possible. Paid for itself in sanity alone.
KitchenAid Classic Series 4.5-Quart Tilt-Head Stand Mixer
Try this for lighter batters and whipping egg whites stiff. Doesn't weigh a ton so your arm won't be dead after holding it for ten minutes over a double boiler melting chocolate.
Mixmaster® Hand Mixer
Switch to this from the regular paddle — it scrapes the sides of the bowl while it mixes, so you're not stopping every 30 seconds to push ingredients back down. Small upgrade, massive difference.
Customer reviews for Flex Edge Beater for Kitchenaid
Use this if you want a stand mixer without spending rent money. It handled my double batch of peanut butter cookie dough without struggling, and the splash guard actually works.
Hamilton Beach 4 Quart Stand Mixer for Kitchen
Cooling Racks and Storage That Keep Cookies Fresh
Stacked warm cookies on a plate once and they fused together into one giant cookie brick. Cooling and storing properly is the part nobody talks about until it's too late.
Get the three-tier version — it takes up the same counter space as one rack but holds three trays worth of cookies. When you're baking five dozen at once, vertical space is everything.
Wilton Perfect Results Cooling Rack, 3 Tier, Non-Stick
Keep decorated cookies in these without them sticking to the lid. The seal is tight enough that my sugar cookies stayed soft for four days — usually they're rocks by day two.
Rubbermaid Brilliance Plastic Food Storage Container
Toss a sheet between cookie layers in your storage container. Without it, the icing on my bottom layer gets smashed by the cookies on top. Cheap fix that saves hours of decorating work.
Reynolds Cut-Rite Wax Paper, 75 Square Feet
Use this for transporting decorated cookies to parties — each compartment holds a cookie without them sliding into each other. Showed up to a cookie swap with zero casualties for the first time ever.
Customer reviews for Sterilite Adjustable Ornament Box
Wrap individual cookie types separately so the flavors don't bleed together. My peppermint cookies made everything in the container taste like mint last year. Lesson learned.
The Difference Between Glad Press'n Seal and Glad ClingWrap
Specialty Ingredients for Cookies Nobody Forgets
Plain sugar cookies are fine, but the ones people actually remember have something unexpected. These are the add-ins that got me invited back to every cookie exchange.
Chop this up instead of using chips — the irregular pieces create pockets of melted chocolate throughout the cookie that chips just can't match. People will ask what's different and you'll feel smug.
Ghirardelli Premium Baking Bar Semi-Sweet Chocolate
Snag a fresh jar because that tin from 2019 has lost all its punch. Fresh cinnamon in snickerdoodles is the difference between ‘these are fine’ and ‘can I take some home.’
McCormick® Ground Cinnamon, 2.37 oz
Toast these in a dry pan for five minutes before chopping them into your dough. The smell alone will make your kitchen feel like a holiday movie set, and the flavor is unreal in butter cookies.
Fisher, Pecan Halves, 16 oz Bag, Naturally Gluten Free
Swap these in for regular semi-sweet chips in any chocolate chip cookie recipe. The slightly bitter edge balances out the sweetness and makes the cookies taste more grown-up. For anyone tired of one-note sweet cookies.
Nestlé Toll House, Dark Chocolate Baking Chips
Grind a few twists on top of chocolate cookies right out of the oven. That salty-sweet combo is why people hovered over my cookie plate at the office party while the store-bought tray sat untouched.
Morton All-Natural Coarse Sea Salt, Finishing Salt 17.6 Oz