Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Avocado Toast Seasonings That Made My Kitchen Taste Like a $18 Brunch Spot
40
items Every weekend I'd drop $16-20 on avocado toast at some trendy brunch place and then stare at my sad, plain mashed avocado at home wondering why it tasted like nothing. Turns out the difference isn't technique — it's the right seasoning lineup. If you...
Sections
10
Flaky Finishing Salts That Change Everything
Red Pepper Flakes and Chili Seasonings
Everything Bagel Seasoning Mixes
Citrus Acids That Wake Up Flat Avocado
Garlic Powders and Granulated Garlic
Black Pepper and Peppercorn Grinders
Flaky Finishing Salts That Change Everything
Plain table salt on avocado toast is why yours tastes flat. The first time I hit my toast with a proper finishing salt, I literally said ‘oh’ out loud to nobody. The crunch and burst of flavor is what restaurants rely on.
Grab this before anything else on the list — I used regular salt for years and the first pinch of these flakes on warm avocado made me realize what I'd been missing. Perfect if you're the person who thinks their toast is ‘fine but not great.’
Maldon Sea Salt Flakes: How to Use Them While Cooking
Keep this by the stove for seasoning your avocado while you mash it. Table salt dissolves weird and over-salts in patches — switched to this and my base layer finally tastes evenly seasoned every single time.
Morton Kosher Salt Flakes 3 lb.
Snag this if you want something a little more delicate than Maldon. My partner couldn't figure out why my toast suddenly tasted ‘fancy’ — it was literally just swapping the salt. Worth every penny.
Jacobsen Salt Co. Pure Flake Finishing Salt, 17.6 Ounce
Try this for a slightly mineral, earthy flavor that pairs ridiculously well with ripe avocado. A friend who's a line cook told me about it and now I can't go back to anything processed.
Redmond Real Salt Ancient Fine Sea Salt 16 oz
Red Pepper Flakes and Chili Seasonings
That kick you taste at brunch spots isn't hot sauce — it's usually some kind of crushed chili flake situation. Once I figured that out, my toast went from ‘breakfast’ to ‘I’d actually pay for this.'
Toss a big pinch on right after you finish assembling — the heat blooms slowly and doesn't overpower the avocado. For anyone who wants warmth without sweating through brunch.
McCormick Crushed Red Pepper with Oregano and Garlic All Purpose Seasoning
Shake this on when you want that Tajín-adjacent vibe without the candy-like sweetness. Brought this to a friend's brunch potluck and three people asked me what I put on the toast.
Trader Joe's Chile Lime Seasoning Blend, 2.9 oz, Pack of 2
Switch to this if you care about where your spices come from — tastes noticeably fresher than the stuff that's been sitting in your cabinet since 2019. Bigger flakes too, which matters on toast.
Simply Organic Crushed Red Pepper, 1.59 oz, 6 pack
Use this instead of regular red pepper flakes when you want fruity, slow-building heat instead of sharp spice. This one single swap is what finally made my toast taste like the $18 version downtown.
Edi Gourmet Spice Aleppo Pepper Flakes - 113g / 4oz
Everything Bagel Seasoning Mixes
I resisted putting everything bagel seasoning on avocado toast for way too long because it felt too trendy. Then I tried it and immediately understood why every brunch menu has it. The sesame and garlic combo on creamy avocado just works.
Grab this for the most consistent blend — some brands skimp on the garlic but this one actually delivers. Sprinkle it on right before eating so the seeds stay crunchy against the soft avocado.
McCormick® Everything Bagel All Purpose Seasoning, 4.8 oz
Try this if you want a slightly more garlic-forward version at a lower price point. Went through the whole jar in about three weeks because I started putting it on eggs too. No regrets.
Great Value Everything Bagel Seasoning, 2.6 oz
Keep the grinder version on your table for lazy mornings — just twist and go. The built-in grinder cracks the sesame seeds slightly, which releases more flavor than pre-ground. Small detail, big difference.
Olde Thompson Everything Seasoning For Bagels & More
Snag this when you're going through seasoning fast and don't want to spend $7 every two weeks. Tastes nearly identical to the name brands and the jar is bigger. Practical wins count.
Great Value Everything Bagel Seasoning, 2.6 oz
Citrus Acids That Wake Up Flat Avocado
Squeezing lemon on avocado toast isn't optional — it's structural. Without acid, avocado tastes one-dimensional and kind of greasy. This is the thing most home cooks skip and it's exactly why their toast falls flat.
Keep a bottle in the fridge door for weekday mornings when cutting a fresh lemon feels like too much. A quick squeeze over mashed avocado brightens everything and keeps it from browning while you make coffee.
Concord Foods Lemon Juice from Concentrate
Toss a packet of this into your avocado mash when you're out of fresh citrus — dissolves instantly and adds that tangy punch. Perfect for anyone who always forgets to buy lemons until it's too late.
True Lime Crystallized Water Enhancer Powder
Swap in a tiny splash of this instead of lemon when you want a deeper, more complex tang. Discovered this accidentally when I ran out of citrus and now I alternate between the two depending on my mood.
Pompeian Acai Pomegranate Infused Red Wine Vinegar
Use literally half a teaspoon mixed into your mash — sounds weird but it adds this rounded acidity that makes people ask what your secret ingredient is. Too much ruins it though, so go easy.
Bragg Organic Raw Unfiltered Apple Cider Vinegar 473ml
Garlic Powders and Granulated Garlic
Fresh garlic at 7am is a lot to ask. Garlic powder mixed right into the avocado mash gives you that savory depth without the prep or the dragon breath that lasts until lunch.
Shake a quarter teaspoon into your avocado while mashing — it disappears into the texture but your taste buds absolutely notice. This is the invisible backbone of every good avocado toast.
Mccormick garlic powder Nutrition Facts
Switch to this when you want a more potent garlic hit — it's ground finer so it distributes better through the mash. One jar lasted me about four months of near-daily toast making.
Spice Islands Garlic Powder, Kosher, 2.25 oz
Try the roasted version when you want mellow, almost sweet garlic flavor instead of sharp raw garlic vibes. Makes your toast taste like the kind of place that has exposed brick and $7 lattes.
McCormick Kosher Garlic Powder, 3.12 oz Bottle
Grab this for a coarser texture that adds tiny pops of garlic flavor as you eat. Cheaper than most options and the container is huge — for anyone who seasons aggressively and isn't sorry about it.
Badia Granulated Garlic Seasoning, 24 oz.
Black Pepper and Peppercorn Grinders
Pre-ground pepper from a tin tastes like dust compared to freshly cracked. The first time I used a real pepper grinder on my toast I felt betrayed by every previous breakfast I'd ever made.
Keep this next to your toaster — the built-in grinder means zero extra dishes and the cracked pepper actually tastes like something. Threw out my pre-ground tin the same week I bought this.
Premium Black & White Peppercorn Grinder
Pair these with a decent grinder and you'll notice the difference on your first bite. They smell almost floral when you crack them fresh, which sounds pretentious but it's genuinely true.
Simply Organic Whole Black Peppercorns, 2.65 Oz
Snag the big jar if you grind pepper on everything like I do — ran out mid-toast once and had to eat it plain. Never again. Stock up so you don't face that sadness.
Olde Thompson Whole Black Pepper, 5 lbs
Use these when you want to understand why pepper snobs exist. More complex, slightly fruity, noticeably different from generic peppercorns. Once you try Tellicherry on avocado toast, regular black pepper feels like a downgrade.
McCormick Gourmet Organic Black Peppercorns Tellicherry
Dried Herb Blends for Complexity
A little dried herb sprinkled on top is what separates ‘I mashed an avocado’ from ‘I made avocado toast.’ Restaurants almost always finish with herbs and it takes exactly two seconds.
Shake a pinch on top right before eating — dill and avocado together taste like a fancy cafe in Portland and nobody can explain why. For anyone who wants their toast to feel intentional without trying hard.
McCormick Gourmet Organic Dill Weed, 0.5 Oz
Try a light dusting when you want a Mediterranean direction — oregano and basil play surprisingly well with creamy avocado and a squeeze of lemon. Discovered this combo hungover one Sunday and it stuck.
Simply Organic, Italian Seasoning, 0.95 oz Bottle
Grab this for the single biggest flavor upgrade on this entire list. Za'atar on avocado toast with a drizzle of olive oil tastes like something a chef would charge you $19 for. Not even exaggerating.
McCormick Gourmet Organic Za'atar, 1.25 oz Bottle
Use a tiny shake of this when you want savory depth without committing to one specific herb. It's a Latin American pantry staple that works on basically everything — avocado toast included.
Badia, Complete Seasoning, 6 oz, All Purpose Spice Blend
Seeds and Crunchy Toppings
Texture contrast is the thing that makes restaurant toast addictive. Creamy avocado needs something crunchy on top or every bite feels the same. Took me embarrassingly long to figure this out.
Toss these on for a nutty crunch that also happens to be ridiculously good for you. My doctor told me to eat more fiber and this was the most painless way I found to actually do it.
Bob's Red Mill, Organic Whole Flaxseed, 13 Oz, Gluten-Free
Scatter a small handful on top for salty crunch that makes every bite interesting. These are dirt cheap and they add the kind of texture that makes homemade toast feel like a real meal.
Great Value Sunflower Kernels, Roasted & Salted, 7 oz Bag
Sprinkle these on after everything else — they're subtle but they add a toasty nuttiness that ties all the other flavors together. Think of them as the quiet ingredient that makes everything louder.
McCormick Sesame Seed (Pack of 24)
Swap in pepitas when you want a bigger, more substantial crunch. The green color against the avocado looks restaurant-quality too, which matters if you're the type who photographs breakfast. No judgment.
Great Value Roasted & Salted Pumpkin Seeds, 5 oz
Hot Sauces and Drizzle Finishers
Sometimes you want more than a sprinkle — you want a drizzle that pulls the whole thing together. The right hot sauce or finishing drizzle is like the period at the end of a really good sentence.
Drizzle a zigzag across the top right before you eat — Cholula has enough vinegar tang and gentle heat to complement avocado without bulldozing it. Been my go-to finish for over a year now.
Cholula Original Hot Sauce with Wooden Topper, 12oz.
Use a thin line of sriracha when you want more heat than Cholula but still want flavor, not just pain. The slight sweetness pairs with avocado better than you'd expect. Brunch places know this.
Huy Fong Sriracha Hot Chili Sauce
Finish with a light drizzle right before the first bite — good olive oil on seasoned avocado toast is the difference between homemade and ‘wait, you made this?’ Trust the process on this one.
Pompeian Organic Robust Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 16 fl oz
Try a thin drizzle when you want sweet-heat contrast against creamy avocado — sounds chaotic but it works brilliantly. Brought this to a brunch gathering and watched six people immediately add it to their grocery lists.
Mike's Hot Honey Chicken Wings Recipe
The Right Bread Because It Actually Matters
Spent months perfecting my seasoning game only to realize my grocery store white bread was undermining everything. The bread is the vehicle and a flimsy vehicle ruins the cargo. Learned that the hard way.
Switch to this and your toast immediately has more structure and nuttiness to stand up to loaded toppings. The seeds in the bread plus seeds on top creates layers of crunch that cheap bread simply cannot deliver.
Dave's Killer Bread 21 Whole Grains and Seeds Organic
Grab this for that tangy sourdough base that makes avocado toast taste like it came from a real bakery cafe. Toasts up sturdy enough to hold a thick layer of mash without getting soggy halfway through eating.
Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Sourdough Bread, 24 oz Loaf
Try these thick slices when you want a heartier toast that feels like an actual meal and not a snack pretending to be breakfast. Holds up under heavy toppings without flopping over when you pick it up.
Nature's Own Perfectly Crafted Multigrain Bread
Keep this in rotation for weekends when you want the closest thing to fresh bakery bread without leaving your house. Crispier crust than most grocery sourdoughs and the crumb has real chew to it.
Labrea Bakery Round Country White Sourdough Bread