Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Chia Pudding Supplies I Rotate Every Weekday Morning for Breakfast Prep
25
items Staring at the same sad yogurt cup every morning was killing my motivation to eat breakfast at all. I started making chia pudding five nights a week and rotating flavors so I never get bored. This is the exact lineup of ingredients, mix-ins, and cont...
Sections
5
Chia Seeds and Base Ingredients
Monday and Tuesday Flavor Add-Ins
Wednesday Through Friday Flavor Rotation
Toppings and Crunch Elements
Containers and Prep Tools
Chia Seeds and Base Ingredients
I went through four brands of chia seeds before landing on ones that actually gel properly overnight without turning into a weird clump. These are the foundation ingredients I restock every two weeks.
Grab this bag if your chia pudding keeps coming out watery. These gel thick and creamy overnight, and the 12 oz lasts me about three weeks of daily batches.
Nutiva Organic Ground Chia Seeds Powder, 12 ...
Switch to this from regular milk and the texture goes from thin oatmeal to actual pudding. Perfect for anyone who's dairy-free and tired of almond milk tasting like nothing.
Thai Kitchen Unsweetened Coconut Milk, 13.66 fl oz Can
Use a tiny squeeze of this instead of honey if you like your pudding sweet but not cloying. I was oversweetening everything before I found this, and a bottle lasts forever.
Agave Power Eau De Toilette
Toss half a teaspoon into every batch. Sounds basic but I forgot it once and the whole thing tasted like fish tank water. Don't skip it.
Great Value Pure Vanilla Extract, 2 fl oz
Try this as your base on days you want something creamier than coconut milk. It froths into the chia mixture and makes Monday mornings feel slightly less painful.
Califia Farms Oat Barista Blend Calcium
Monday and Tuesday Flavor Add-Ins
Mondays get a tropical mango situation, Tuesdays go chocolate. Having a set rotation means I never stand in front of the fridge wondering what to do at 10pm on a Sunday.
Keep a bag in the freezer and drop a handful on top of Monday's jar. They thaw overnight and turn into this soft, syrupy layer that makes you forget it's a weekday.
Dole Mango Chunks, 16 Ounce -- 8 per case. - Frozen Fruit
Stir a tablespoon into Tuesday's batch for chocolate pudding that doesn't wreck your diet. For anyone who gets a 3pm candy craving, eating this at breakfast actually kills it.
Navitas Organics Cacao Powder, 8.0 Oz
Toss a small handful on top of the cacao batch. They stay firm in the fridge and give you little crunchy bits. Way better than the carob chips I wasted money on last year.
Hershey's Zero Sugar Chocolate Baking Chips, Bag 8 oz
Pair these with the mango on Mondays for a tropical thing that genuinely tastes like vacation. Stock up because once you start adding them to everything, the bag disappears fast.
Bob's Red Mill, Coconut Flakes, Unsweetened, 12 oz
Swirl this into the mango jar for color and a tart kick. My roommate thought I bought it from a juice bar. It's just powder and frozen fruit, but nobody needs to know that.
Suncore Foods Organic Yellow Goldenberry Powder
Wednesday Through Friday Flavor Rotation
Mid-week is when I used to fall off and just grab a granola bar. Having Wednesday as peanut butter, Thursday as berry, and Friday as cinnamon apple keeps me locked in all five days.
Drop a big spoonful into Wednesday's jar and stir it halfway so you get swirls. For anyone who thinks chia pudding is too “health food,” this makes it taste like a Reese's cup.
Jif Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread
Dump these into Thursday's jar frozen. By morning they've thawed into this jammy mess on top that stains everything purple but tastes incredible. Wear a dark shirt.
Great Value Mixed Fruit, 16 oz (Frozen)
Shake a generous amount into Friday's batch with some diced apple. I used to underdose cinnamon until a friend told me to triple it. She was right, don't be shy.
McCormick® Ground Cinnamon, 2.37 oz
Swap this in for peanut butter on weeks you want variety. It's thinner so it actually melts into the pudding and creates this nutty base layer. Worth the slightly higher price.
MaraNatha Natural Creamy Almond Butter, 12 oz
Sneak a teaspoon into any jar and you won't taste it at all. My doctor told me to eat more fiber and this was the laziest possible way to follow that advice.
Spectrum Essentials Organic Ground Premium Flaxseed
Toppings and Crunch Elements
Plain chia pudding without toppings is like pizza without cheese. Technically food, but why would you do that to yourself. These give every jar the texture it needs.
Sprinkle this on right before eating, not the night before, or it turns into mush. Learned that the hard way during week one. Crunchy on top of creamy is the whole point.
Bear Naked, Granola, Vanilla Almond Crisp, 12 oz snack
Chop a few and scatter them on the peanut butter day. The salt against the sweet pudding does something your brain will thank you for. Keep a bag at your desk too.
Wonderful Pistachios, Roasted & Salted Nuts, 6 Ounce Bag
Use these on berry day for a subtle crunch that doesn't overpower anything. They're cheap, last weeks, and honestly I throw them on salads too so nothing goes to waste.
Great Value Pepitas, 8 oz
Crumble a few on top of Friday's cinnamon apple jar. They soften just slightly overnight and taste like pie topping. For anyone doing Whole30 or paleo, these are compliant too.
Bare Snacks, Apple Chips, Crispy Reds, 3.4 fl oz, Baked
Toss these on any day that feels rough. They're allergy-friendly so basically everyone can eat them. I call it my emergency topping and I am not ashamed.
Enjoy Life Dairy Free Dark Chocolate Morsels, 9 oz
Containers and Prep Tools
I ruined three batches using the wrong jars before figuring out the right setup. These containers and tools make the whole five-day rotation take under fifteen minutes on Sunday night.
Get the 16 oz size, not the tiny ones. You need room for toppings. I label mine with a dry erase marker so I know which day is which without opening every lid.
Ball, Mason Jars, 16 oz, Regular Mouth Pint with Lids
Use this to pour milk into each jar without spilling everywhere. Before I had it, my counter looked like a crime scene every Sunday. It's three bucks and saves your sanity.
OXO International OXO Good Grips Angled Measuring Cup
Keep prepped toppings separated in these during the week. They seal tight enough that granola stays crunchy for days, which was a problem I didn't know I had until I solved it.
Rubbermaid, Food Storage Container, 9.6 Cup
Grab one for mixing the base before pouring into jars. Glass doesn't stain from berries or cacao, unlike the plastic bowl I threw away after it turned permanently purple.
Customer reviews for Pyrex Simply Store 2-Cup Glass
Stir each jar with these instead of a fork. Forks leave clumps. I know that sounds picky but once you've bitten into a dry chia seed pocket, you become a spoon convert real fast.
KitchenAid Spoons and Utensil Sets