Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Replaced My Big Oven With a Toaster Oven and My Kitchen Stays Cool
72
items If you dread turning on your full-size oven just to reheat two slices of pizza in July, you already know the problem. This list is for anyone living in a small apartment, trying to cut energy bills, or just tired of heating up the whole kitchen for a...
Sections
9
Toaster Ovens That Actually Fit a Full Pizza
Sheet Pans and Trays Sized for Countertop Ovens
Air Fryer Baskets and Accessories That Actually Fit
Pizza Stones and Pizza Gear for Small Ovens
Bagel and Toast Upgrades for Mornings
Reheating Leftovers Without Ruining Them
Toaster Ovens That Actually Fit a Full Pizza
I measured every single one of these with a 12-inch frozen pizza because the box dimensions always lie. These fit real food, not just marketing photos.
Grab this if you cook for two or three people regularly. I stopped preheating my wall oven entirely after the first week. Fits 6 slices of toast and a 13-inch pizza without any awkward angling.
Breville BOV900BSS Convection & Air Fry Smart Oven Air
Use this when you want something that roasts a whole chicken. My Thanksgiving side dishes all came out of this thing while the turkey hogged the big oven. Serious workhorse for a countertop appliance.
Cuisinart Toaster Oven Broilers Chef's Convection
Perfect for anyone watching their budget but still wanting air fry capability. I paid less than half what the fancy brands charge and my frozen fries come out crunchier than the deep fryer ever managed.
Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp Digital Air Fryer Toaster Oven
Keep this in mind if you batch-cook on Sundays. Two sheet pans fit inside at once, which cut my meal prep time nearly in half. The digital controls are dead simple too.
Oster® Extra Large Digital Countertop Oven
Snag this one if counter depth matters to you. It's wider than it is deep, so it actually fits under my cabinets without sticking out. Eight slices of toast at once is no joke for a busy morning.
Black + Decker Extra-Wide Toaster Oven Stainless Steel
Pair this with a good sheet pan and you basically have a second oven. I bake cookies in it at 10pm without waking up the house with the wall oven's loud fan. Quiet and precise.
KitchenAid Digital Countertop Oven with Air Fry - KCO124BM
Try flipping it up against the wall when you're done. That flip-up design gave me back counter space I didn't know I was missing. Reheats leftover pizza better than any microwave I've owned.
Ninja, Foodi™ Digital Air Fry Oven, 8-in-1, Flip-Away, Silver
Switch to this from a basic toaster if you want one appliance that does toast, bagels, and roasted veggies. Fits neatly in my studio kitchen and the interior light actually lets you see your food. Small detail that matters more than you'd think.
COSORI Smart Air Fryer Toaster Oven
Sheet Pans and Trays Sized for Countertop Ovens
Regular baking sheets don't fit in toaster ovens, and I ruined a good pan learning that the hard way. These are the exact sizes that slide right in.
Grab a couple of these because you'll use them constantly. They fit perfectly in most toaster ovens and don't warp at high temps. I've had mine for three years and they still lay flat.
Nordic Ware Baking Sheets
Use this for anything gooey or saucy. The raised edges keep melted cheese and marinara from dripping onto the heating element, which is a cleanup nightmare I only needed once.
Cuisinart AMB-TOBCS Toaster Oven Baking Pan, Silver
Keep this on top of your toaster oven as a landing pad. I pull hot trays out and set them right on it. Doubles as a cutting board when I'm slicing that pizza I just made.
Breville BOV650CB Bamboo Cutting Board for Smart Oven
Perfect if you're baking for one or two. I make single-serve brownies in these on weeknights without committing to a full batch. Less waste, less guilt, more brownies.
Customer reviews for Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non
Snag the set instead of buying pieces separately. The rack elevates bacon so grease drips down, and the tray catches everything. Sunday morning bacon went from messy to manageable.
Toaster Oven Tray and Rack Set P&P CHEF Stainless
Try these for roasting vegetables in small batches. They fit standard toaster ovens and the two-pack means one can be in the dishwasher while the other is in use. Rotation solved.
Checkered Chef Quarter Sheet Pan and Rack Set.长22
Ditch nonstick coatings if they sketch you out. This is plain stainless, cleans up easily, and won't flake weird stuff into your food after six months of use. Still looks new after heavy rotation.
TeamFar Stainless Steel Toaster Oven Pan
Toss your full-size muffin tin and get this instead. Six mini muffins fit in a countertop oven perfectly. My kids think it's fun to make tiny cupcakes, so everyone wins.
Calphalon Classic Nonstick 2-Pc. Fry Pan Set
Air Fryer Baskets and Accessories That Actually Fit
Half the air fryer accessories on the market are sized for full standalone units. I bought three that didn't fit before finding these.
Keep this next to your toaster oven for small jobs. When I just want six chicken nuggets for a snack, pulling out the big unit feels ridiculous. This handles it in eight minutes flat.
Customer reviews for DASH Tasti-Crisp™ Electric Air Fryer
Grab the whole kit so you're not hunting for individual pieces later. The silicone mat alone saved me from scrubbing baked-on cheese off my basket. Worth it for that piece alone.
BISNIE Air Fryer Accessories Set, BPA Free
Try this if you already own an Instant Pot and don't want another appliance. It turns your pressure cooker into an air fryer without taking up any new counter real estate. Genius for small kitchens.
Instant Pot 6 Quart Air Fryer Lid with Roast, Bake
Use this when you're cooking for just yourself. It heats up in under three minutes and makes frozen spring rolls taste like they came from a restaurant. My post-work snack routine changed completely.
Philips Essential XL 6.2L Digital Air Fryer with Fry Basket
Perfect for a family of four who eats a lot of frozen foods. The basket is big enough for a full bag of fries without crowding, so everything actually gets crispy instead of steaming in a pile.
Ninja 5.5-Quart Air Fryer Max XL, AF161 in Black and Silver
Swap your deep fryer for this if you're trying to eat less oil but still want fried chicken that crunches. I did a side-by-side test and honestly couldn't tell the difference. My cardiologist would be proud.
GoWISE USA GW22956 7-Quart Electric Air Fryer
Snag this as a starter air fryer if you're not sure you'll use one regularly. It's affordable enough that you won't feel bad if it just sits there, but I promise it won't. Mine runs daily.
Chefman Turbofry Air Fryer with Basket Divider, 8 Qt Capacity
Pair this with the included recipe book if you're new to air frying. The presets actually work well, which is rare. I made salmon in it on a Tuesday and my wife thought I'd ordered delivery.
Customer reviews for NuWave Brio 6-Quart Digital Air Fryer
Pizza Stones and Pizza Gear for Small Ovens
Making pizza in a toaster oven sounded silly until I tried it. Now I make better pizza at home than most delivery places around me.
Use this on the lowest rack position for the crispiest crust. My homemade margherita went from floppy to legitimately crispy in one try. It's sized exactly for countertop ovens, no trimming needed.
Pizzacraft ThermaBond Mini Pizza Stones - Set of 4, Natural
Grab a peel so you stop burning your forearms reaching into a hot oven with oven mitts. I have a small scar from before I bought this. Learn from my mistakes.
Chef Pomodoro 14-inch Bamboo Pizza Peel
Try the rectangular shape if your toaster oven is wider than it is deep. Covers more surface area than a round stone and fits snugly on the rack. Better heat distribution means fewer soggy spots.
Honey Can Do Old Stone Oven Pizza Stone, 8.5", Set of 2
Keep these in your freezer for spontaneous pizza nights. Thaw one out, stretch it, top it, and you're eating in 20 minutes. Way faster than ordering and honestly tastier with a good stone.
Tyson Bonici Pizza Dough Balls 26.25lbs (PACK OF 1)
Ditch those flimsy cutters that make you saw back and forth. This one rolls through crust, cheese, and toppings in one clean pass. Sounds minor but it makes the whole experience feel more legit.
KitchenAid Stainless Steel Pizza Cutter Wheel with Finger
Perfect for personal-sized deep dish if you're into that Chicago style. Season it once and it's basically nonstick forever. Fits in most toaster ovens and gives you that buttery crust edge.
Customer reviews for Lodge Cast Iron Pizza Pan Round
Switch from a stone to steel if you want even faster heat transfer. My cook time dropped by about two minutes per pizza, and the bottom char is exactly what I want. Serious upgrade.
Pizza Steel for Oven, 16 Inch, 1/4 Inch Thick, Gray Steel
Snag this if you hate washing sharp metal wheels around your kids' stuff in the sink. The blade covers and it stores flat in a drawer. Small kitchen friendly and actually cuts well.
Epicurean Pizza Cutter Series - Natural/Slate
Bagel and Toast Upgrades for Mornings
I used to microwave leftover bagels like some kind of animal. These turned my mornings from sad to genuinely something I look forward to.
Toss these in your toaster oven at 375 for five minutes with butter and they come out better than any diner. Stock up because they freeze well and thaw fast. Weekday breakfast solved.
Thomas' Original English Muffins, 6 count, 13 oz
Try this if you want toast that actually fills you up until lunch. Most bread leaves me hungry by 10am. Two slices of this toasted with peanut butter and I'm good until noon easily.
Dave's Killer Bread 21 Whole Grains and Seeds Organic
Keep the brick, skip the tub. It spreads better on a warm bagel and tastes richer. I did a blind test with my roommate and we both picked the brick every time. The tub version is watery.
Philadelphia Original Brick Cream Cheese
Use this on hot toast straight from the toaster oven and watch it melt into the bread instantly. Regular butter tastes flat after you try this. Worth the extra dollar, I promise you that.
Kerrygold Grass-Fed Salted Pure Irish Butter, 8 oz
Grab a jar and put it on cream cheese toast, avocado toast, scrambled eggs, literally anything. I go through one every three weeks. My plain bagels suddenly taste like I bought them from a New York deli.
Trader Joe's Everything But The Bagel Sesame Seasoning
Toss a naan in your toaster oven with garlic butter for two minutes. Instant side bread for any meal. I stopped buying garlic bread entirely because this is faster, fresher, and doesn't come frozen.
Stonefire Original Naan Dippers, 7.05 oz
Perfect for anyone who wants French toast without the effort. Toast it plain in the toaster oven and it already tastes slightly sweet and buttery. My Saturday mornings got way better with this.
Nature's Own Perfectly Crafted Brioche Style Bread Loaf
Snag these for the freezer as your emergency breakfast backup. They crisp up beautifully in a toaster oven from frozen in about six minutes. Not artisan, but reliable and exactly what you need at 6am.
Lender's Original Plain Bagels, 6 count
Reheating Leftovers Without Ruining Them
The microwave turns last night's dinner into rubber. I started reheating everything in the toaster oven and the difference is embarrassing. Why did I wait so long.
Wrap leftover burritos loosely in foil and reheat at 350 for 12 minutes. The tortilla stays soft, the inside gets hot, nothing is soggy. Changed my entire relationship with leftovers.
Reynolds Wrap Standard Aluminum Foil, 12", 200 Sq Ft ,1 Ct
Use this under anything cheesy so it doesn't weld itself to your tray. Learned that lesson reheating lasagna. This parchment is unbleached and works up to 450 degrees without burning.
If You Care, Parchment Baking Paper, Unbleached, 70 Sq Ft
Keep a small Pyrex for reheating soups and stews in the toaster oven instead of the microwave. It heats more evenly and the flavors actually taste refreshed, not just warm. Huge difference with chili.
Pyrex 232 2-Quart Glass Baking Dish & 232-PC Red Lid
Toss this on your tray before reheating anything breaded. Chicken tenders, fish sticks, egg rolls - they all re-crisp on this mat instead of getting soggy on bare metal. Nonstick and reusable.
OXO Good Grips Silicone Pastry Mat,Tan,One Size
Grab these because they go from fridge to toaster oven tray without needing to transfer food to another dish. The clear lids let you see what's inside so you actually eat your leftovers before they go bad.
Rubbermaid Brilliance Plastic Food Storage Container
Try reheating pizza in this inside your toaster oven. The crust gets crispy on the bottom while the cheese melts on top. It's the closest thing to fresh pizza you'll get from a leftover slice.
Lodge, Cast Iron Skillet, 8" seasoned, No secondary attribute
Pair these with your toaster oven because the opening is small and regular mitts are too bulky. These are thinner but still heat-resistant, so you can actually grip a small tray without fumbling.
Cuisinart Silicone Oven Mitts
Use this to check that reheated chicken actually hit 165 inside. Nobody wants food poisoning from Tuesday's leftovers. Takes two seconds and gives you peace of mind. I check everything now.
ThermoPro TP03 Digital Instant Read Meat Thermometer
Countertop Organization for Small Kitchens
My toaster oven took up half my counter until I figured out how to organize around it. These solved the space problem without making my kitchen look like a storage unit.
Toss this above your toaster oven to create a second shelf. I store my baking trays and cutting board on top now. Vertical space is free real estate that most people completely ignore.
SimpleHouseware Kitchen Cabinet & Counter Organizer
Swap your bulky knife block for this and free up six inches of counter next to your toaster oven. Everything slides into a drawer neatly. My counter went from cluttered to actually usable.
Joseph Joseph DrawerStore Compact Cutlery Organizer
Keep spices and oils on this next to your toaster oven so you're not digging through cabinets every time you cook. One spin and I can grab garlic powder, olive oil, or salt instantly.
Copco Non-Skid Pantry Cabinet Lazy Susan Turntable
Use a couple of these inside your cabinet to group toaster oven accessories together. Trays, racks, and thermometer all in one bin. No more rummaging through a pile of random kitchen stuff.
mDesign Plastic Kitchen Pantry Storage Organizer Bin
Grab these to mount a small shelf or hook strip on the wall behind your toaster oven. I hung my oven mitts and timer right there. Everything within arm's reach without taking up counter space.
How to Use Command™ Strips for Hanging Pictures
Try this in the drawer closest to your toaster oven. It adjusts to fit and keeps your parchment paper, foil, and silicone mats separated. Finding what I need takes three seconds instead of thirty.
Royal Craft Wood Luxury Bamboo Kitchen Drawer Organizer
Keep this near your toaster oven because you'll constantly need to blot grease off trays and wipe crumbs. The weighted base means you can tear one-handed, which matters when your other hand is holding a hot tray.
OXO, Stainless Steel Steady Paper Towel Holder
Perfect if you have floor space but no counter space. My toaster oven sits on the middle shelf with ingredients above and trays below. Turned an empty wall into a full cooking station.
Customer reviews for VASAGLE 6-Tier Bakers Racks
Cleaning a Toaster Oven Without Losing Your Mind
Burnt cheese smoke at 7am is a special kind of misery. I let my toaster oven get disgusting once and now I clean it properly. These make it painless.
Sprinkle this on a damp sponge and scrub your toaster oven tray. Baked-on grease that I thought was permanent came off in under a minute. This stuff is almost unsettling in how well it works.
Bar Keeper's Friend
Use the non-scratch version so you don't gouge up your oven's interior coating. Regular steel wool left marks on my first toaster oven that collected grime forever after. Learn from that.
Scotch-Brite, Cleaning Sponges, Blue
Fill this with vinegar and water, run it in your toaster oven at 300 for ten minutes, and the steam loosens everything. Wipe it out with a paper towel. Weirdly satisfying every single time.
INSTRUCTIONS
Grab this for scrubbing your pizza stone or cast iron pan without soap. The stiff bristles get into the porous surface and knock out stuck bits. My pizza stone looks almost new after every use.
Full Circle Tenacious C Cast Iron Brush and Scraper
Spray the exterior of your toaster oven with this after cooking. Fingerprints and grease splatters wipe right off and it smells like actual grapefruit, not chemicals. Makes the whole kitchen smell good.
method All-Purpose Cleaning Wipes, Pink Grapefruit
Try the small detail brush for getting crumbs out of the toaster oven's crumb tray track. That little groove collects so much debris and a regular sponge can't reach it. This brush nails it.
OXO GG DEEP CLEAN BRUSH SET - ORANGE
Keep these under the sink if you have a stainless steel toaster oven. One wipe after cooking and the front looks showroom clean. Guests have commented on how new my appliances look, which is funny because they're not.
Weiman Stainless Steel Cleaner & Polish Spray
Make a paste with water and spread it inside your toaster oven overnight. Wipe it out the next morning and everything comes off without any harsh fumes. Cheap, effective, and you probably already own it.
ARM & HAMMER, Baking Soda, 1 lb Box
Small Kitchen Appliances That Pair Well With a Toaster Oven
Once I committed to countertop cooking, I realized a few other small appliances filled in the gaps. Now my big oven is basically decorative.
Pair this with your toaster oven and you can cook almost any dinner without touching the stove or big oven. Rice in the Instant Pot, protein in the toaster oven. Weeknight dinners take 30 minutes total.
Customer reviews for Instant Pot 6Qt Duo Plus
Grab this for smoothies and sauces while your toaster oven handles the main dish. It blends frozen fruit in seconds and rinses clean under the faucet. Morning routine cut in half.
nutribullet Pro 900 W 9-Piece Blender, Black, 9 Count
Toss this on the counter next to your toaster oven for weekend breakfasts. Makes one perfect waffle in three minutes. My kids line up and I just keep feeding batter in. Assembly line breakfast.
Dash Mini Waffle Maker, 4-Inch Nonstick
Use this to boil water for oatmeal, tea, or pour-over coffee while your bagel toasts in the oven. Both finish at roughly the same time. Breakfast choreography at its finest.
Hamilton Beach, Electric Tea and Water Kettle, 1.7L, Silver
Try this for paninis and grilled sandwiches that your toaster oven can't press flat. The plates are removable and dishwasher safe, which is the only reason I actually use it regularly.
Cuisinart, Griddler Indoor Grill, GR-4NNAS, Stainless Steel
Keep rice going in this while your toaster oven roasts vegetables or chicken. Set it and forget it. I stopped watching pots of rice on the stove and my kitchen cleanup dropped dramatically.
BLACK+DECKER Rice cookers (4)
Perfect for anyone who needs coffee ready the moment their toast pops out. One button, one minute, one perfect cup. My morning used to take 25 minutes. Now it's 12.
Nespresso Vertuo Next Coffee and Espresso Machine
Snag this for making soup right in the pot. Roast vegetables in the toaster oven, dump them in a pot with broth, blend in 30 seconds. Restaurant-quality butternut squash soup on a random Wednesday.
MuellerLiving Ultra-Stick Immersion Hand Blender