Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

I Nailed the Cold Girl Makeup Look With Just These Products

Purple Star emoji 42 items
You know that effortless, just-stepped-out-of-a-ski-lodge flush that somehow looks expensive? I spent way too long watching tutorials and buying the wrong products before landing on a routine that actually pulls it off. This is for anyone who wants t...
Sections
7
 
 
 
 
 
 

Dewy Skin Base That Looks Like Real Skin

Foundation used to sit on my dry patches like paint on drywall. These gave me that lit-from-within thing without looking like I tried at all.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Swap out your heavy foundation for this. I was the person with cakey winter skin until a friend handed me her bottle at brunch. Now strangers ask about my skincare routine instead of my makeup.
ILIA Super Serum Skin Tint SPF 40
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Dab this on your cheekbones before anything else. For anyone who looks washed out under fluorescent office lights, this gives you that just-came-back-from-vacation glow without any shimmer chunks.
Saie Glowy Super Gel 15ml
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Keep this in your bag for low-effort days. My coworker thought I wasn't wearing makeup when I had this on, which is literally the whole point. Sheer enough that matching your shade isn't stressful.
SunnyDays SPF30 Tinted Sunscreen Foundation
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try this if you hate the feeling of foundation but still want some evening out. Feels like putting on moisturizer and nothing else. Grabbed it on a whim and haven't touched my old foundation since October.
Rare Beauty Positive Light Tinted Moisturizer Broad
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use this on days you need slightly more coverage but still want to look like a human, not a mannequin. Sat beautifully over my flaky forehead patches, which is saying something.
Revealer Skin-Improving Foundation SPF 25
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Bring this back into your rotation if you ditched it years ago. The reformulated version is genuinely different. Blends with fingers in about ten seconds, perfect for the person who does makeup in the car.
Laura Mercier Tinted Moisturizer Natural Skin Perfector LM

Flush and Blush for That Just-Came-Inside-From-the-Cold Look

The whole cold girl thing lives or dies on blush placement. I looked like a clown for two weeks before figuring out these shades and where to put them.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use the tiniest dot. I mean it. First time I squeezed out a normal amount and looked like I had a sunburn for six hours. Once you figure out the dosage, nothing else compares for that natural flush.
Beli Rare Beauty Mini Soft Pinch Liquid Blush
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Toss this in your coat pocket for touch-ups. Taps on with fingers and melts right into skin. For anyone who finds powder blush looks dusty on them, this fixed that problem completely.
25+ Merit Flush Balm Cream blush for sale
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Grab this shade specifically. It's that perfect cold-weather pink that works on a ridiculous range of skin tones. Doubles as a lip color when you're running late, which for me is always.
Tower 28 Beauty BeachPlease Luminous Tinted Balm 4.5 oz
placeholder
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Pricey, yes. But swipe it once across each cheek and blend with your fingers for about three seconds. Done. Looks like you just walked in from a crisp morning hike. Worth every cent if you hate fussing.
WESTMAN ATELIER Baby Cheeks Blush Stick - poppet
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try this if you want one product for lips and cheeks that doesn't look like craft paint. The color is subtle enough that you can build it up or leave it sheer. Threw out two other multisticks after finding this one.
MILK MAKEUP Lip + Cheek Cream Blush Stick - perk
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Pair the cream side with the powder for blush that actually lasts through a full workday. Before this combo, my flush disappeared by lunch. Now it still looks fresh at 6 PM.
Patrick Ta MAJOR HEADLINES DOUBLE-TAKE CREME

Brow Products That Frame Your Face Without Looking Drawn On

Cold girl brows are groomed but never Instagram-blocky. Took me a while to stop overworking them and just let the hair do its thing.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Swipe this through your brows and walk away. Literally the easiest brow product I've ever used. For anyone who wants fuller-looking brows without a fifteen-minute routine, start here.
Glossier Boy Brow Murah & Lengkap
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Keep this as your go-to if your brows are sparse in spots. The tiny fibers fill in gaps without looking like you drew them on with a marker. My sister stole mine twice before buying her own.
Benefit Cosmetics Gimme Brow + Volumizing Eyebrow Gel
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use a tiny amount to brush brows upward for that fluffy laminated look. First time I tried it I used too much and my brows were crunchy. Small amount, big payoff. Lasts all day without flaking.
Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Freeze Wax
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Grab this if you want hold without any stiffness. Your brows still feel like brows, not shellacked caterpillars. The tinted version adds just enough color to skip a pencil entirely.
Air Brow Fluff & Hold Treatment Gel
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try the shape and set method with this wax-gel hybrid. Works especially well if you have thick brows that go rogue by noon. Keeps everything in place through wind, hats, scarves, all of it.
REFY Brow Sculpt Shape and Hold Gel with Lamination
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Switch to this from your old brow gel and notice the difference immediately. Holds like wax but applies like gel. No white cast, no crunch. Took me embarrassingly long to find a brow product this simple.
PATRICK TA Major Brow Lamination Gel / clear brow setter

Lip Products for That Bitten, Just-Drank-Hot-Cocoa Mouth

Nobody in a cold girl photo is wearing matte liquid lipstick. The vibe is soft, slightly flushed, like you've been sipping something warm. These nail it.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Bring back this classic if you haven't tried it since your mom's bathroom counter. Builds from a sheer berry tint to something deeper. Looks different on everyone, which is honestly part of the fun.
Clinique Official Almost Lipstick | Lip balm - Black Honey
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Wear this when you want color that adjusts to your natural lip shade. Sounds gimmicky but it genuinely works. My lips looked naturally flushed instead of like I applied something. The balm texture is chef's kiss.
Dior Addict Lip Glow Balm - 012 Rosewood
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Snag this before it sells out again. Gives that your-lips-but-warmer effect with actual hydration underneath. Applied it at 8 AM and still had color at lunch without reapplying. For anyone with perpetually dry lips.
Rhode Peptide Lip Tint - Toast di Skinjuicery Shop
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Toss your sticky glosses and use this instead. Feels like a treatment, looks like a stain, and the purple-pink tone gives that just-ate-a-popsicle tint. Perfect for people who hate the feeling of lipstick.
Tower 28 Beauty LipSoftie Hydrating Tinted Lip Treatment
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try this for a barely-there wash of color with serious shine. Not goopy, not sticky, just wet-looking lips that photograph really well. Became my default for running errands and still wanting to look put together.
MERIT Shade Slick Tinted Lip Oil in AU NATUREL . ...
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Keep one of these at your desk and one in your bag. The tint is so subtle it basically just makes you look healthy. Saved my lips during a February where the wind was personally attacking my face.
Sugar Lip Treatment - Rosé

Highlighter and Glow Without Looking Like a Disco Ball

Strategic shine is the difference between cold girl and going-to-a-rave. Learned that the hard way when I blinded my coworker with a powder highlight in a meeting.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use this as a blush-highlight hybrid on the high points of your cheeks. One product, two jobs. For anyone trying to keep their routine under five minutes, this cuts a whole step.
Saie Dew Blush Liquid Cheek Blush
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Dab the smallest amount on your inner eye corners and cupid's bow. That's it. Resist the urge to put it everywhere. This is how you get that I'm-well-rested glow even when you slept four hours.
RMS Beauty Living Luminizer
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Swipe once down the bridge of your nose and blend the edges. Looks like your skin is just naturally catching light. No glitter particles, no chunky shimmer. Just skin that looks expensive.
WESTMAN ATELIER Lit Up Highlight Stick
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Pair this with your tinted moisturizer or use it alone on good skin days. Blurs pores and adds luminosity without any actual shimmer. The reason half the internet looks airbrushed in selfies.
Charlotte Tilbury Flawless Filter | Price in Egypt
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try the stick format if you're clumsy with liquid highlighters. Twist up, swipe on cheekbones, blend with fingers. Done in seconds. The champagne tone works on so many skin tones it's almost suspicious.
nars copacabana products for sale
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Grab this if you want soft-focus skin without looking matte or powdery. Sets everything down while keeping that dewy finish alive. Solved my problem of glow turning into grease by 3 PM.
DANESSA MYRICKS YUMMY SKIN BLURRING Balm Powder

Mascara That Opens Up Your Eyes Without Looking Heavy

One coat max. Maybe two if you're feeling bold. The cold girl eye is wide-awake and defined but never overdone. Clumpy spider lashes ruin the whole thing.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use one coat and stop. The wand does the work for you. For anyone whose lashes point straight down and refuse to cooperate, this held a curl through an entire eight-hour shift for me.
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara & Tinted
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Grab the mini size first to test it. The tiny brush gets every single lash including those stubborn inner corner ones. Looks like you have naturally long lashes instead of wearing mascara. That's the goal.
Clinique Lash Power Flutter-to-full Mascara Full Size NIB
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Switch to this if your current mascara flakes onto your under-eyes by afternoon. Clean formula that doesn't irritate sensitive eyes. My contacts stopped getting cloudy, which I didn't realize was a mascara problem.
Kosas The Big Clean Volumizing + Lash Care Mascara
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try this for the most natural-looking lash definition. One thin coat separates and lengthens without any clumping. Washes off easily too, so you're not scrubbing your eyes raw every night.
Ilia Limitless Lash Lengthening Mascara - Full Size Original
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Splurge on this when you want that soft, feathery French girl lash. Never clumps, never flakes, applies evenly every single time. Worth it if you're tired of mascara roulette with drugstore tubes.
le volume de chanel volume mascara
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use the curved wand to press lashes up from the root. The lift lasts all day without a curler. Replaced my eyelash curler entirely, which means one less thing I lose in my bathroom drawer.
Lancôme Idôle Lash Lifting Volumizing Mascara, Black

Setting Products That Lock Everything In Without Killing the Dewiness

Biggest mistake I made early on was powdering everything down and losing that fresh finish. These keep makeup in place while letting your skin still look like skin.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Mist this from arm's length after everything's done. Locks makeup in without making your face feel coated. Wore this through a snowy walk and dinner afterward. Everything stayed exactly where I put it.
25+ Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray for sale
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use this as your last skincare step before makeup. Creates a hydrated base that makes everything sit better and last longer. For anyone whose tinted moisturizer pills up, this underneath fixed it for me.
The Dewy Skin Cream
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Tap the smallest amount only on your T-zone. Nowhere else. Keeps oil at bay in the spots that get shiny while leaving your cheeks dewy. Learned this trick from a makeup artist at a wedding.
Hourglass Veil Translucent Setting Powder Murah
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Smooth this on before your skin tint and watch everything grip to your face. My makeup used to slide off by lunch in heated offices. This primer ended that entirely. Tacky going on, invisible once set.
Milk Makeup Batch Code & Expiration Date
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Keep this for nights out when you need everything to survive hours of activity. A few spritzes and your blush, highlight, everything stays put. Danced for three hours and my face still looked intentional.
Urban Decay Setting Spray All Nighter Terlengkap
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Dust a whisper of this on oily zones only. Seriously, less is more. Too much and you lose the whole dewy vibe. Just enough takes the shine off your nose without turning you into a matte painting.
Ultra-Blur Talc-Free Translucent Loose Setting Powder