Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Quit Lash Extensions and My Natural Lashes Look Even Better Now
42
items Spending $200 every three weeks on fills while watching my real lashes thin out was a special kind of torture. When I finally ripped the band-aid off and stopped getting extensions, I panicked at how short and sparse everything looked. Took me about ...
Sections
7
Lash Serums That Actually Regrow Sparse Lashes
Mascaras That Fake the Extension Look
Lash Primers That Double Your Mascara Results
Eyelash Curlers That Replace Extension Lift
Eye Treatments That Heal Post-Extension Damage
Lash-Friendly Makeup Removers That Won't Undo Your Progress
Lash Serums That Actually Regrow Sparse Lashes
After extensions, my lash line had visible gaps. Like, I could count individual lashes. These serums filled everything back in within a couple months and I stopped feeling like I needed to hide behind sunglasses.
Grab this one first. My lashes were basically stubble after two years of extensions. Eight weeks in, I had baby lashes sprouting in every gap. Apply it at night right on the lash line and be patient.
GRANDE Cosmetics GrandeLASH-MD Lash Enhancing Serum
Try this if you want something plant-based and gentle. I used it on my lower lashes specifically because they were practically invisible. By month two, I actually had a bottom lash line again.
GRO Lash Serum Changed My Lashes in 4 Weeks
Pricey, yes, but I noticed my lashes getting denser faster than with anything else. For anyone whose lashes snapped off at the root from heavy extension glue, this one repairs that damage.
Augustinus Bader The Eyebrow and Lash Enhancing Serum
Keep this around as a budget backup. I started here when I wasn't sure serums even worked. Three weeks in, my roommate asked if I was wearing falsies. I was not.
Rapidlash Eyelash Enhancing Serum 3ml
Use this if your lashes are fragile and break when you rub your eyes. It strengthened mine enough that I stopped finding tiny lashes on my pillowcase every morning.
Beli Shiseido Full Lash Serum
Swap to this once your lashes are growing but still feel thin and wispy. It plumped each individual lash so they looked fuller even without mascara. Wish I'd started it sooner.
An honest review of Revitalash Advanced Eyelash
Mascaras That Fake the Extension Look
The first time I put on mascara post-extensions, I cried a little. Nothing looked right. These formulas finally gave me that fanned-out, fluffy look I was paying a tech $200 for.
Get this if you miss that wispy separated look extensions give. The skinny wand fans each lash out individually. People at work didn't even notice I'd stopped getting fills.
Lash Idôle Mascara | Lancôme ≡ SEPHORA
Try this for the fluffy volume that makes your eyes pop in photos. One coat looks natural, two coats look like you just left the lash salon. No clumping either.
Rare Beauty Perfect Strokes Universal Volumizing Mascara
Toss this in your bag if your lashes are still on the shorter side. The hemp-derived formula grabs every tiny lash and makes it visible. My sparse corners finally looked full.
Milk Makeup KUSH High Volume Mascara Review
Pair this with a good primer and you'll forget extensions existed. I layer two coats on the outer corners for that cat-eye fan effect. Holds a curl all day without flaking.
Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara & Eyeliner Duo
Snag the Major Headlines mascara for days you want drama without falsies. The brush deposits a lot of product so start light. One coat on my top lashes replaced my strip lashes completely.
Patrick TA Major Headlines Double-Take Creme & Powder
Use this on days you want the “I woke up with great lashes” look. Clean formula, no irritation on my sensitive post-extension lash line. It lengthens without making things spidery.
Ilia Limitless Lash Lengthening Mascara - Full Size Original
Lash Primers That Double Your Mascara Results
I never used lash primer before quitting extensions. Honestly felt silly buying one. Then I tried it once and realized I'd been doing mascara wrong my entire life.
Wear this under any mascara and watch the difference. My lashes went from “fine I guess” to “wait, are those real?” in one swipe. It also conditions while you wear it.
Cils Booster XL Vitamin-Infused Mascara Primer
Grab this if your mascara flakes or smudges by noon. It locks everything in place. I went from raccoon eyes by 3pm to perfect lashes at happy hour.
Too Faced Better Than Sex Foreplay Lash Lifting
Try this when you want your lashes to look borderline fake. It adds thickness to each lash before you even touch mascara. My friend accused me of wearing falsies at brunch.
Maximizer 3D Triple Volume Plumping Lash Primer
Keep this at your desk for midday touch-ups. It's white so you need mascara over it, but it builds a base that makes thin lashes look twice as thick. Affordable too.
tarte Opening Act Lash Primer - White
Use this if your lashes are straight and refuse to hold a curl. It grips and holds them up all day. Finally stopped looking like my lashes were pointing straight down.
White Mascara Primer Vegan | Colored Lash Base Clean Beauty No Makeup Look Editorial Makeup
Snag this for lazy mornings when mascara feels like too much effort. The tint is subtle enough to wear alone but still defines your lash line. Perfect for weekends.
They're Real! Tinted Lash Primer - Benefit Cosmetics
Eyelash Curlers That Replace Extension Lift
Flat lashes after extensions are so demoralizing. Mine pointed straight down like they were actively trying to hide. The right curler changed everything and I'm not being dramatic.
Bring this everywhere. The curved shape fits eyes that other curlers pinch or miss. I have smaller, flatter eyes and this was the first curler that grabbed every single lash.
ec. Relevee Lash Curler Surratt' Beauty ExplicitCloset
Get this if you've never found a curler that works. It's the one everyone recommends for a reason. My lashes went from droopy to lifted in one squeeze, no crimping.
Eyelash Curler
Try this for wider eyes. The broader opening catches outer corner lashes that most curlers skip. Those outer lashes are exactly what give you that extension-like fan shape.
Kevyn Aucoin The Eyelash Curler
Use this if you're gentle and nervous about curlers. The spring is soft, the pad is cushioned. After extensions made my lashes fragile, I needed something that wouldn't yank them out.
Laura Mercier Artist Eyelash Curler
Swap your drugstore curler for this. The difference is wild. It opens wide enough to get right at the root, which is where you actually need the curl to start.
Tweezerman ProMaster Lash Curler
Pair this with a heated technique. I warm mine with my blow dryer for five seconds and the curl lasts literally all day. No more lashes falling flat by lunch.
Manual Eyelash Curler – Stainless Steel, Slim Design, Natural Lift Makeup Tool
Eye Treatments That Heal Post-Extension Damage
Nobody warns you that extensions can irritate your lash line and the skin around your eyes. Mine was red, dry, and kind of puffy for weeks after I stopped. These calmed everything down.
Dab this around your eyes morning and night. The skin along my lash line was dull and irritated from years of glue. This brightened everything up within a week.
Drunk Elephant C-Tango Multivitamin Eye Cream 15ml
Use this if your under-eye area is dry and flaky from removal solvents. Rich but not greasy, it sank right in. My skin stopped peeling around my eyes after three days.
Beli KIEHL'S Creamy Avocado Eye Treatment
Try this for mornings when your eyes look tired and sad without extensions to open them up. The subtle brightening effect makes your eyes look awake even bare-faced.
Summer Fridays Light Aura Vitamin C + Peptide Eye Cream
Bring this into your nighttime routine. After extensions, the skin around my eyes aged about five years. This plumped and smoothed things out so I stopped looking exhausted.
explicictcloset.TATCHA The Silk Peony Melting Eye Cream
Snag this if you notice fine lines you swear weren't there before extensions. The firming effect is real. I saw tighter skin around my eyes within two weeks of daily use.
Fresh Black Tea Firming Eye Serum 2 ml
Grab this for events when you need your eyes to look their best fast. Tightens and smooths in about two minutes. I used it the first time I went out without extensions and felt confident.
Instant FIRMx Eye Temporary Eye Tightener Easy-Wear Formula
Lash-Friendly Makeup Removers That Won't Undo Your Progress
I made the mistake of using harsh removers early on and watched my baby lashes fall right out. Switching to gentle formulas was the single most important thing I did for regrowth.
Soak a cotton pad and press it on your lashes for ten seconds before wiping. No rubbing. I lost so many regrowth lashes by scrubbing with regular remover. This dissolves everything gently.
Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micellar Water 500ml – 2 Pack
Use this for waterproof mascara days. Shake it up, press, wait, wipe. My lashes stayed intact even when I removed heavy eye looks. Anything else pulled them right out.
Bi-Facil Double Action Eye Makeup Remover
Try melting this between your fingers and pressing it over closed eyes. Mascara slides off without any tugging. My lash tech actually recommended this for extension aftercare originally.
Clinique Take the Day Off Cleansing Balm Rating
Swap to this if your eyes are sensitive to micellar water. The balm texture means zero friction on your lash line. Smells like fresh herbs and dissolves even stubborn liner.
Green Clean Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm
Pour a pump into dry hands and massage over your eyes. Everything melts. I went from losing 3-4 lashes per removal to losing none. Worth every penny during the regrowth phase.
TATCHA Pure One Step Camellia Cleansing Oil Murah
Keep this on your nightstand for nights you're too tired to wash your face. Soaked a pad, held it on my eyes for 15 seconds, and everything came off. No lash casualties.
Koh Gen Do Cleansing Spa Water Refill 450ml x2 Facial
Supplements and Tools for Lash Health From the Inside Out
My aesthetician told me lash growth starts internally and I rolled my eyes. Then I added a few supplements and noticed my lashes growing in thicker and darker. She was annoyingly right.
Toss a scoop in your coffee every morning. I started this for my skin but noticed my lashes and brows filling in faster too. Four months in, my lashes were visibly thicker.
Vital Protein Collagen Peptides Murah
Try this if your lashes and hair both thinned from stress or extensions. The biotin and ashwagandha combo worked faster than biotin alone. My lashes looked healthier within six weeks.
Moon Juice SuperHair hair nutrition
Use this for the long game. It's pricey and takes 3 months to really kick in, but my lash regrowth accelerated noticeably. For anyone whose lashes just stopped growing back.
3-Pack Nutrafol Women's Balance Supplements | Hair Growth for Women (360 Caps) | Fastest shipping
Grab this if you want something specifically formulated for lashes, not just hair. I noticed less lash fallout within the first month. The capsules are small and easy to take.
Hair Growth Supplements | Topical + Ingestible
Pair these with your serum routine. The omega fatty acids support the follicle health that makes serums work better. Think of it as fertilizer for whatever you're applying topically.
Briogeo B. Well Vegan Omega 3, 6, 9 + Biotin Supplements
Dab a tiny amount along your lash line at night before your lash serum. Hydrated skin holds onto lashes better. My lash tech told me dehydration was half the reason my natural lashes were so brittle.
Vital Skin-Strengthening Hyaluronic Acid Super Serum