Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Makeup I Wear to Look Like Me But Slightly Better

Purple Star emoji 54 items
If you keep buying makeup that looks incredible in the store and then makes you look like a completely different person in the bathroom mirror, this list is for you. I spent years overbuying bold products I never reached for because they felt like co...
Sections
9
 
 
 
 
 
 

Skin That Looks Like Skin But Smoother

Foundation used to sit on my face like a mask. I could literally see where my skin ended and the product began. These let my freckles and texture show through while evening things out just enough.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Swap this in for your heavy foundation and watch people ask if you just got back from vacation. Barely feels like anything on your skin but photographs like a dream. For anyone who hates the feeling of wearing foundation but still wants to look polis...
ILIA Super Serum Skin Tint SPF 40 - Foundation
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try this if your skin leans dry and every other lightweight base clings to flaky patches. I put this on with my fingers in about 30 seconds and it genuinely looks like I just have really good skin. Wish someone had told me about it three years ago.
Revealer Skin-Improving Foundation SPF 25
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Grab this for mornings when even a skin tint feels like too much. It's sunscreen that happens to blur everything slightly. Perfect if you're the person who wants one product and then wants to walk out the door.
SunnyDays SPF30 Tinted Sunscreen Foundation
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use this on days when your skin is already behaving and just needs a tiny bit of help. The dewiness is real without looking greasy. I wear this to brunch and people think I'm just well-rested, which is a lie, but I'll take it.
READY STOCK Saie Slip Tint Dewy Tinted Moisturizer SPF
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Keep one of these in your bag for adding a little warmth after you've been stuck indoors all week. Blends with fingers in seconds. For anyone whose natural complexion goes a little flat under fluorescent office lighting.
Beli Rare Beauty Warm Wishes Effortless Bronzer Stick
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Dab this under your eyes and on any redness spots and that's it. Covers my dark circles without that thick crease situation I used to get by noon. Stock up before winter when the under-eye bags really come out to play.
LAURA MERCIER Real Flawless Weightless Perfecting Concealer

Blush That Mimics an Actual Flush

I used to skip blush entirely because every shade made me look like a clown. Turns out I was just using the wrong formulas. These actually look like blood rushing to your cheeks, not paint sitting on top.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use literally one tiny dot. I'm serious, one dot. The first time I used this I squeezed out way too much and looked sunburned. But once you get the amount right, it's the most natural flush you'll ever fake. Perfect for fair-to-medium skin that shows...
Soft Pinch Liquid Blush | Long-Lasting Dewy & Matte Blushes
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try this on your cheeks, lips, and eyelids when you want to look put together using exactly one product. The shade Tenderly is what my cheeks actually look like after a glass of wine. For the minimalist who refuses to own 40 separate products.
ILIA Beauty Multi-Stick, A Fine Romance (5 g)
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Swipe this on and blend with your fingers while you're still half asleep. The texture is so creamy it basically melts into skin. I grabbed this before a wedding and three people asked what blush I was wearing.
WESTMAN ATELIER Baby Cheeks Blush Stick
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Keep this in your pocket for a midday refresh. It's a balm so it doesn't dry down powdery or weird. Great if you run warm and want something that adds color without layering on more product.
Tower 28 Beauty BeachPlease Luminous Tinted Balm 4.5 oz
placeholder
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Toss this in your gym bag. Seriously, after a workout when your face is already flushed, just add a tiny bit to even out the color. For the girl who gets ready in the locker room and still wants to look alive at dinner after.
Cream Blush Stick | Natural Cheek + Lip Tint | Cream Eye Color | Botanical Multi Stick | Mineral Makeup | Pick Your Shade Lip Stick
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Pair this with bare skin or just a tint and it looks like you naturally have the prettiest rosy cheeks. The formula is bouncy and blends without streaking. I went through two tubes last winter because it was the only thing making me look awake.
ready stock saie dew blush liquid cheek blush

Brows That Still Look Like Your Brows

My brow journey was rough. I went through a phase where they looked drawn on with a Sharpie. These products fill in sparse spots without turning your brows into two identical rectangles on your forehead.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Grab this if your brows have decent shape but just need a little more oomph. It's basically hair gel for your eyebrows. I've been using the brown shade since 2019 and nothing has replaced it.
Glossier Boy Brow Murah & Lengkap
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use the tapered brush to catch those tiny hairs at the front of your brows that never cooperate. Adds volume without looking crunchy or stiff. For anyone with naturally sparse brows who just wants them to look fuller, not fake.
Benefit Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel Shade 03
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try this on days when your brows are being unruly and you just need them to stay put. It holds without getting that weird white cast some gels leave behind. My brow hairs finally stay brushed up instead of flopping down by lunch.
Air Brow Fluff & Hold Treatment Gel
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Keep this for filling in any patchy gaps. The triangular tip lets you draw individual hair-like strokes that don't look like you colored them in. I over-plucked in 2015 and this pencil is the only reason you'd never know.
Beli Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Definer
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Snag this if you want that feathery laminated brow look without actually getting them laminated. Holds all day and washes out easily. Perfect for thick brows that need direction, not more color.
Beli Rare Beauty Brow Harmony Flexible Lifting Gel
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Switch to this from your current brow gel if you want that soap-brow hold without the flaking. Sets your arches in place and keeps them there through humidity, sweat, the whole thing. Wish I'd found this before summer last year.
REFY Brow Sculpt Shape and Hold Gel with Lamination

Mascara That Opens Your Eyes Without the Drama

I don't want spider lashes. I don't want clumps. I want to look like I just have naturally long lashes and maybe got a full night's sleep. These deliver exactly that.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use this when you want your lashes to look like they grew overnight. No clumping, no smudging, just longer lashes that still look real. For contact lens wearers who are tired of flaky formulas irritating their eyes by 2pm.
Clinique Lash Power Flutter-to-full Mascara Full Size NIB
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Grab this if you want length without volume. One coat is the sweet spot for a natural look. Two coats and you're entering date-night territory, so adjust accordingly. It's at Sephora now and the price point makes it easy to always have a backup.
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try this if every mascara you've owned has smudged under your eyes by noon. Clean formula, no raccoon eyes, and it comes off with warm water. I've repurchased this four times, which says everything.
Ilia Limitless Lash Lengthening Mascara - Full Size Original
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Keep this as your everyday mascara. It builds gradually so you control how much you want. One coat for Monday morning, two for Friday night. The brush separates every single lash, which my clump-prone lashes desperately needed.
Kosas The Big Clean Mascara Longwear Fluffy Lashes
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Pair this with a lash curler and your eyes will look twice as open. The wand is thin enough to catch those tiny inner corner lashes most brushes miss. For hooded eyes that need every millimeter of lift.
Lancôme Idôle Lash Lifting Volumizing Mascara, Black
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Snag this if your lashes point straight down no matter what you do. The hook-shaped brush grabs and curls as you apply. I stopped using my eyelash curler entirely after switching to this, which saved me two minutes every morning.
Benefit Roller Lash Curling Mascara

Lips That Look Like You Just Bit Them

Lipstick used to feel like a commitment I wasn't ready for. Everything was too bold or too sticky. These give that just-ate-a-popsicle tint that fades naturally instead of leaving a harsh line.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Wear this and watch it adjust to your natural lip color. It looks dark in the tube but goes on as a sheer berry tint that's different on everyone. My mom wears it, I wear it, my roommate wears it. It just works on everybody.
Clinique Almost Lipstick in Black Honey
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try the shade Rosewood if you want your lips to look flushed and healthy without any obvious color. It reacts to your lip's pH so it's slightly different every time. For the person who wants one lip product and nothing else.
25+ Dior Addict Lip Glow for sale | Updated Oct 2026
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use this when you want gloss without the sticky hair-catching nightmare. It's lightweight, slightly tinted, and smells like vanilla. Perfect for windy days when you still want something on your lips but don't want to deal with the mess.
Tower 28 Beauty ShineOn Lip Jelly Lip Gloss
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Grab the shade Dip and thank me later. It's a lip oil that gives a wet, plush look without feeling goopy. I put this on during my commute and it lasts through my morning coffee, which is the only test that matters.
.explicitcloset.KOSAS Wet Lip Oil Gloss
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Keep this in your coat pocket for a quick swipe before walking into anywhere. The pigment is subtle enough that you don't need a mirror. For the person who wants effortless color but also can't be bothered to reapply every hour.
Shade Slick - MERIT Tinted Lip Oil
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Toss your old sticky glosses and switch to this. It hydrates like a balm but shines like a gloss. My lips were peeling all last February and this was the only thing that looked good AND fixed the problem at the same time.
Saie Glossybounce™ High-Shine Hydrating Lip Gloss Oil

Highlighter That Looks Like Natural Light Hit You Perfectly

Glitter highlight is not my thing. I tried it once and looked like a disco ball at the grocery store. These give that lit-from-within glow, like sunlight is just naturally catching your cheekbones.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Dab a tiny amount on your cheekbones, brow bone, and cupid's bow. It's a cream so it melts into skin instead of sitting on top like glitter. I've had mine for months because a little goes an absurdly long way.
RMS Beauty Living Luminizer - Living Luminize
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try this mixed into your moisturizer on no-makeup days. It gives your whole face a subtle glow without any visible shimmer particles. For anyone who wants to look dewy but draws the line at sparkle.
READY STOCK SAIE Glowy Super Gel Lightweight Dewy
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use one drop blended across your cheekbones. Seriously, one drop. The shade Mesmerize is perfect for medium skin tones and looks like your skin is just naturally reflective. Grabbed this on a whim and now it's a permanent fixture.
Beli Rare Beauty Positive Light Liquid Luminizer
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Keep this for days when you want a slightly more polished glow. The powder is finely milled enough that it doesn't emphasize texture. For anyone with oily skin who finds cream highlighters slide off by midday.
ILIA BEAUTY DAYLITE HIGHLIGHTING POWDER
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Swipe this along your cheekbone and tap to blend. The finish is somewhere between dewy and satin, which is that sweet spot where you glow but don't look sweaty. Worth every penny if you've been disappointed by drugstore highlighters.
WESTMAN ATELIER Lit Up Highlight Stick
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Wear this alone or under foundation when you want that real-life Instagram filter effect. My skin looked tired and dull all through January until I started using this as a primer. People started asking if I changed my skincare routine. I didn't.
Charlotte Tilbury Hollywood Flawless Filter, 3 Fair Rating

Eye Color That Barely Whispers

Smoky eyes are gorgeous on other people. On me they look like I lost a fight. These shadows add just enough depth and definition to make my eyes pop without anyone being able to pinpoint what I did differently.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Sweep this across your lid with your finger for a warm, subtle wash of color. It's the shade equivalent of your eyelid but slightly more interesting. For anyone who wants to wear eyeshadow but panics at the thought of blending three colors.
BOBBI BROWN LUXE eyeshadow moonstone / heat ray
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Grab the shade Au Naturel and just smudge it on. No brushes needed, no technique required. It stays put all day without creasing, which is a miracle for my oily lids. I keep one at my desk for quick touch-ups.
Beli Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Shadow Matte
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try this if you have 10 seconds. That's genuinely all it takes. One swipe, blend with your finger, done. The shade Globe gives a champagne shimmer that makes brown eyes look warmer. I wore this to every event last fall.
Kosas 10-Second Liquid Eyeshadow - Globe
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use this for a soft matte wash when shimmer isn't your thing. It dries down without creasing and looks like you put in effort even though you didn't. Perfect for job interviews where you want polished but not obvious.
ILIA Beauty Liquid Powder Matte Eye Tint, Adobe (3,50 ml)
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Keep these in your bag for travel. Three complementary shades that are foolproof. The formula is creamy enough to apply with fingers and buildable from barely-there to slightly more dramatic. Saved me so much packing space on my last trip.
Westman Atelier Eye Pods Cream Eye Shadow
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Dip your finger in, tap it on your lid, and look instantly more awake. The shade Oyster Pearl is that perfect neutral that catches light without screaming shimmer. I discovered this after wasting money on palettes I used maybe twice.
Charlotte Tilbury Eyes To Mesmerise Eyeshadow

Setting and Prepping Without the Cakey Finish

Nothing ruins a natural makeup look faster than powder that makes you look like a porcelain doll in the worst way. These set everything in place while still letting your skin look like actual skin underneath.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Smooth this on before anything else and watch your makeup just glide. It blurs pores without filling them with silicone gunk. For anyone with textured skin who's been burned by primers that made things worse. Wish I'd tried this years ago.
TATCHA - The Silk Canvas Filter Finish Protective Primer
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Dust the tiniest amount in your T-zone and leave the rest of your face alone. The key to natural-looking powder is using way less than you think you need. I learned that after looking chalky in approximately 47 photos.
Laura Mercier Translucent Loose Setting Powder Ultra Blur
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Grab this if you want your makeup to last through a full workday without touching up. It's so finely milled it practically disappears. For the person who gets shiny by noon but doesn't want to look matte and flat.
Hourglass Veil Translucent Setting Powder Murah
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use this as your last skincare step before makeup. It keeps everything hydrated underneath so nothing clings to dry patches. My foundation used to separate by 3pm until I started prepping with this. Problem solved.
Tower 28 SOS daily barrier Recovery Cream 55ml tower28
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try this on days when your makeup needs to survive humidity, commuting, or just existing for more than four hours. It grips everything in place without feeling tacky. Pair it with a light skin tint and you're set until evening.
Hydro Grip Hydrating Face Primer
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Spritz this as your final step. Two to three pumps, arm's length away. It locks everything without adding dewiness or matteness. Just keeps your face looking exactly how you set it up. I bring the travel size literally everywhere now.
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray 15

Tools That Make the Whole No-Makeup Look Easier

Half the battle with natural makeup is application. Brushes that deposit too much product or sponges that absorb everything ruined so many looks for me. These tools finally let me apply less and blend more.

 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Dampen this until it doubles in size, then bounce your skin tint on. The wet sponge sheers everything out so you never accidentally apply too much. For anyone who's been using it dry and wondering why their base looks heavy. Wet it. Trust me.
Beauty Blender
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Use this for blush and bronzer when you want the softest, most diffused application possible. The bristles are so fluffy they basically force you to go light-handed. I stopped over-applying blush the day I switched to this brush.
Sephora Collection Professional Pro Bronzer Brush 80
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Grab this tiny brush for pressing powder only where you need it. Under eyes, around the nose, maybe your chin. Nowhere else. Targeted powder application changed my whole approach. No more all-over dustings that make me look flat.
Real Techniques 1413 setting brush
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Curl your lashes before mascara and skip the false lash conversation entirely. This one fits the shape of most eye curves without pinching. I've tried five different curlers and kept coming back to this one every time.
Tweezerman ProCurl Eyelash Curler (Rose Gold)
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Try this for precise concealer placement instead of smearing it everywhere with your fingers. Tap it on, then blend the edges. My under-eye concealer finally stopped migrating into my fine lines once I switched to this brush.
SEPHORA COLLECTION Makeup Match Concealer Brush
 
Tessa Willow profile picture
Snag this if the Tweezerman doesn't fit your eye shape. It's slightly wider and works better for flatter eye curves. Finding the right curler for your specific eye shape makes a bigger difference than any mascara ever will. Took me years to figure th...
Shiseido eyelash curler 100% ORIGINAL !!!