Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Best NYC Pizza Staten Island
10
items Staten Island is home to some of the absolute best pizza in all of New York City — and that's saying something! VFC's Travels was born and raised in Staten Island, so this list is deeply personal. From classic coal-fired pies to thin-crust brick-oven...
Map
The absolute best pizza on Staten Island — and VFC's Travels has tried them all! Bari's Pizza Pasta has been serving up legendary, coal-fired pies for decades. The crust is perfectly charred, the sauce is rich and flavorful, and the cheese is applied...
Bari's Pizza Pasta
A Staten Island pizza gem located in Midland Beach! Nunzio's Pizzeria Restaurant is known for its unique, delicious pies with perfectly balanced sauce and fresh toppings. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, and the pizza is consistently outstanding...
Nunzio's Pizzeria Restaurant
Lee's Tavern is a legendary Staten Island pizza institution! Famous for its incredibly thin, brick-oven pizza with a uniquely crispy crust and exceptional sauce, Lee's Tavern has been a Staten Island staple for generations. The atmosphere is classic ...
Lee's Tavern
Brother's Pizzeria is a Staten Island classic known for its exceptional cheese pizza! The quality of the mozzarella and the perfectly seasoned sauce make this one of the most distinctive pies on the island. A neighborhood favorite that has earned its...
Brother's Pizzeria
ZZ'S PIZZA is a hidden gem on Staten Island! Known for their incredibly flavorful pies with perfectly balanced sauce and premium toppings, ZZ'S brings a unique approach to Staten Island pizza. The quality and consistency here are outstanding — this i...
ZZ'S PIZZA - 14 Photos & 12 Reviews - Yelp
Pier 76 serves up some of the best thin-crust pizza on Staten Island! Located right on the water, the combination of incredible pizza and stunning waterfront views makes this a truly special dining experience. The crust is perfectly crispy, the sauce...
Pier 76
Tony's Brick Oven is a Staten Island pizza legend! Widely considered one of the very best on the island, Tony's delivers consistently incredible pizza with a perfectly charred brick-oven crust, rich tomato sauce, and premium toppings. Whether you're ...
Tony's Brick Oven
One of Staten Island's most beloved and long-standing pizzerias! This classic neighborhood spot has been serving up outstanding New York-style pizza for decades. The sauce, the cheese, the crust — everything is made with care and tradition. A true St...
Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern
Seppe Pizza Bar brings a modern, upscale approach to Staten Island pizza! Known for their creative pies with premium toppings and a beautifully crafted crust, Seppe elevates the pizza experience to a whole new level. The atmosphere is stylish and inv...
Seppe Pizza Bar
Domenico's Pizzeria is a Staten Island treasure! Famous for their incredible vodka pie — a rich, creamy tomato-vodka sauce with perfectly melted cheese on a beautifully crafted crust. This is one of those pizzas that will have you thinking about it f...
Domenico's Pizzeria - Staten Island