Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

The Ultimate Guide to Mystery, Crime & Thriller Books

Purple Star emoji 16 items
As a lifelong fan who devours every twist and turn, I've curated this ultimate guide to the most captivating mystery, crime, and thriller books. Whether you're a seasoned detective fiction aficionado or new to the genre, this list is perfect for find...
Sections
4
 
 
 
 

The Classic Whodunit

From charming cozy reads to intricate police procedurals, these are the books where the joy is in racing the protagonist to uncover the truth. If you love a good intellectual challenge and a truly satisfying reveal, your next favorite detective story...

 
Ali Finley profile picture
 I adore this series! The characters are utterly charming and hilarious, defying all stereotypes of aging. The mystery itself is cleverly plotted with fantastic red herrings, but it's the witty banter and unexpected heart that truly make this book a c...
The Thursday Murder Club Mystery
placeholder
 
Ali Finley profile picture
This book grabbed me from the brilliant premise and never let go! I loved the dual timelines and piecing together Frances's lifelong investigation alongside Annie's present-day sleuthing. It's a true puzzle box with a wonderfully quirky cast of chara...
How to Solve Your Own Murder
placeholder
 
Ali Finley profile picture
Anthony Horowitz is a genius at crafting meta-mysteries, and 'Marble Hall Murders' is a brilliant example. The book-within-a-book structure is incredibly clever, offering two compelling mysteries to solve simultaneously. It's a masterclass in fair-pl...
Marble Hall Murders
placeholder

Psychological Twists & Gripping Suspense

Prepare to have your mind messed with! This section is dedicated to the psychological thriller, where the true terror often lies within the characters' own minds, their darkest secrets, or the chilling unreliability of their narratives. If you crave ...

 
Ali Finley profile picture
Just released - July 2025! Shari Lapena excels at crafting domestic thrillers that are impossible to put down, and 'She Didn't See It Coming' is a prime example. I was captivated by the sheer number of twists and turns, constantly wondering who was l...
She Didn't See It Coming by Shari Lapena
placeholder
 
Ali Finley profile picture
Freida McFadden is a master of the page-turner, and 'The Perfect Son' is no exception. The suspense is relentless as you're plunged into Jennifer's agonizing dilemma. I was constantly questioning Ethan's true nature and the lengths a mother would go ...
The Perfect Son by Freida McFadden
placeholder
 
Ali Finley profile picture
NEW READ! Ruth Ware is an expert at creating atmospheric, claustrophobic suspense, and her new release 'The Woman in Suite 11' delivers perfectly. The isolated setting and the creeping sense of dread kept me on edge from page one. I loved trying to f...
The Woman in Suite 11
placeholder
 
Ali Finley profile picture
Lisa Jewell masterfully crafts a chilling tale of obsession and psychological manipulation here. The way Josie slowly invades Alix's life is genuinely unsettling, and the 'podcast within a book' format makes it feel incredibly real and immersive. It'...
None of This Is True by Lisa Jewell
placeholder
 
Ali Finley profile picture
This book is a non-stop thrill ride of deception! I was completely captivated by Evie's cleverness and the constant cat-and-mouse game she plays. Every chapter throws a new twist, making it impossible to put down. If you love a protagonist who's alwa...
First Lie Wins by Ashley Elston
placeholder
 
Ali Finley profile picture
This book perfectly blends psychological suspense with a wonderfully creepy, isolated atmosphere. I loved the constant sense of unease and the feeling that something was just off. Jeneva Rose builds tension expertly, making you suspicious of everyone...
You Shouldn't Have Come Here by Jeneva Rose
placeholder

Crime and Action Thrillers

For readers who crave their crime fiction with an edge, this section plunges into the dark heart of the genre. Here, you'll find no-holds-barred narratives featuring morally ambiguous characters, intense criminal underworlds, and relentless action.

 
Ali Finley profile picture
Candice Fox delivers a relentless, adrenaline-fueled ride with 'The Chase.' I was completely gripped by the high-stakes manhunt and the morally grey characters. The plot is incredibly propulsive, and the tension never lets up, making it a truly gritt...
The Chase by Candice Fox
placeholder
 
Ali Finley profile picture
For lovers of The Lincoln Lawyer! Michael Connelly remains unparalleled in his ability to craft compelling procedurals, and 'Nightshade' is no exception. I loved the fresh setting of Catalina Island and Renée Ballard's determination to uncover the tr...
Nightshade: A Novel
 
Ali Finley profile picture
S.A. Cosby is a literary force, and 'King of Ashes' is a testament to his raw talent. I was completely engrossed by the complex family dynamics and the visceral portrayal of crime and desperation in the rural South. It's a powerful, gritty, and emoti...
King of Ashes by S.A. Cosby
placeholder

Chilling Crime & Unsettling Killers

From meticulous, sadistic criminals to haunting cold cases and disturbing family secrets, these books explore the darkest facets of human nature and crime, leaving you with an undeniable shiver down your spine.

 
Ali Finley profile picture
This book grabbed me from page one with its heart-stopping premise! I was completely captivated by Anne's impossible choice in the operating room and the escalating tension as she navigates both a deeply personal vendetta and a treacherous investigat...
The Surgeon by Leslie Wolfe
placeholder
 
Ali Finley profile picture
Lucy Foley excels at creating perfectly atmospheric and unsettling mysteries, and 'The Guest List' is a prime example. The isolated setting combined with a cast of flawed, secretive characters creates an incredible sense of tension. I loved trying to...
The Guest List by Lucy Foley
placeholder
 
Ali Finley profile picture
Freida McFadden absolutely masterminds a twisted, unsettling narrative with 'The Teacher.' The shifts in perspective kept me constantly disoriented and suspicious of everyone. It's a fantastic exploration of manipulative power dynamics and dark hidde...
The Teacher by Freida McFadden
placeholder
 
Ali Finley profile picture
John Marrs excels at crafting deeply disturbing and endlessly twisted thrillers, and 'Keep It in the Family' is a prime example. The premise alone is chilling, but the way the story unfolds, revealing layer after layer of a truly dark family history,...
Keep It in the Family by John Marrs
placeholder