Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Baby Registry Must-Haves for First Time Moms (What I’m Actually Using)
59
items I spent MONTHS researching what’s actually worth adding to a baby registry — and this list is everything I chose that I actually use (plus a few must-haves I didn’t want to forget). My baby is 11 months at the time of curating this list as a first ti...
Sections
9
🍼 Feeding Must-Haves
☁️ Sleep Essentials
👶🏻 Babywearing Favorites
🫧 Bath + Care Essentials
🧺 Diapering Must-Haves
🚗 On-the-Go Essentials
🍼 Feeding Must-Haves
Feeding your baby is one of the biggest parts of those early days, so I wanted to make sure I had everything that would make it easier, more comfortable, and less stressful. These are the feeding essentials I added to my registry after tons of resear...
This is one of those underrated registry items I kept seeing moms recommend — it’s perfect for catching letdown or collecting extra milk without having to fully pump. I love that it’s wearable and super discreet, so you can move around while using it...
haakaa Shell Wearable Silicone Breast Pump - 2.5oz: BPA-Free, Single Pump System
Use code 1046 for 10% off! This was a must-add for me after hearing so many moms rave about it — it gives way more support than a regular pillow and helps keep baby in the perfect position during feeds. I love that it wraps around you and stays in pl...
Super Deluxe Oat Nursing Pillow with 100% Organic Cotton Cover
This is one of those long-term investment pieces I felt really good adding — it grows with your baby into toddler and even kid years, so you’re not constantly replacing high chairs. It’s super sturdy, aesthetically simple, and designed to support pro...
Tripp Trapp® High Chair² with cushion & tray
I added this as a more space-saving, travel-friendly option for feeding — it clips right onto a table, which is perfect for smaller spaces or bringing with you when you’re out. I kept seeing parents recommend this for restaurants and visiting family ...
The Hook-On Chair
I thought this was such a cute and practical addition for when baby starts solids — it has everything you need to get started in one set, which makes things way less overwhelming. I love that it’s designed to help encourage independence with self-fee...
AEIOU Future Foodie Gift Set - Clay | Babylist Shop
I added these because I kept seeing them recommended as a more natural, anti-colic bottle option — the silicone pouch design helps reduce air intake, which can make a big difference for gassy or fussy babies. I also love that they’re soft and flexibl...
Boon NURSH Silicone Pouch Bottles - Speckle, 4 Oz | Babylist Shop
These were a lifesaver in the early days — they really helped with leaky breasts, especially in between feeds or overnight. I love that they’re organic and reusable, so they feel safe on sensitive skin and are way more sustainable than disposable opt...
KeaBabies 14pk Washable Nursing Pads, Organic Reusable Breast Pads for Breastfeeding, Nipple Pads, Breastfeeding Essentials (Bare Beige, Large 5")
You can never have too many burp cloths, and these were an easy yes for me — they’re super soft, absorbent, and actually hold up to all the spit-up moments. I love that they’re organic, so they feel gentle on baby’s skin (and mine too).
The size is ...
KeaBabies 5pk Urban Baby Burp Cloths, Organic Burping Cloth for Babies, Burp Rags for Baby Girls, Boys (Purest)
I added these as a more eco-friendly and reusable option for milk storage — I love that they’re silicone instead of disposable, which makes them feel safer and less wasteful. The fact that they’re leak-proof and self-standing is such a game changer t...
JellyRuru 7PCS Reusable Silicone Breastmilk Bags
I love this nursing cover for on-the-go feeds 🤍 the structured/wired neckline lets me actually see baby while nursing, which makes such a difference. The muslin fabric is super breathable, so baby doesn’t get overheated, and it gives just the right ...
2 Pack Muslin Nursing Cover, 100% Cotton
These are one of my favorite baby feeding tools for starting solids 🥄 The soft silicone is super gentle on baby’s gums, and the design makes it easy for little hands to hold if you’re doing baby-led weaning. I love using these for purees, yogurt, an...
mushie Silicone Baby Spoons 2 Pack
Okay I didn’t think I needed this at first… but it quickly became a MUST once we started solids 😂 This little food catcher saves so much mess by catching everything that would’ve ended up on the floor. It attaches right to our high chair and makes c...
Catchy Food Catcher for Stokke Tripp Trapp
☁️ Sleep Essentials
Sleep is one of the biggest adjustments with a newborn, so I really focused on adding items that would help create a safe, cozy, and calming sleep environment right from the start. These are the sleep essentials I chose based on what’s actually recom...
This was one of my top priority splurges — I really wanted a non-toxic, breathable mattress for peace of mind, especially for sleep. I kept coming back to this one because it’s made with organic materials and designed to allow airflow, which made me ...
Organic Breathable Ultra Baby Crib Mattress (2-Stage)
This is one of those newborn essentials I saw recommended everywhere — it helps baby feel secure and snug, which can make a big difference with sleep in those early weeks. I love that it’s 100% organic cotton, so it’s soft, breathable, and gentle on ...
Cream Organic Cotton Swaddle - Newborn | HALO
I didn’t end up getting this exact one since the version I chose is sold out now, but it’s super similar and has the same vibe — and I absolutely love this style. The natural materials and aesthetic are so beautiful, it feels more like part of your h...
Signature Nap & Pack (Natural Vegan) - Sale Bundle
We started using sleep bags around 3–4 months, and it was such an easy transition once baby was out of the swaddle stage. I love these because they keep baby warm and cozy without needing loose blankets, which just feels so much safer for sleep.
The...
Kyte Baby Sleep Bag Wearable Blanket 1.0 Tog - 6-18 Months - Cloud
This baby monitor gives me so much peace of mind 💤 The video quality is super clear (even at night), and the audio picks up even the smallest sounds. What I really love is that you can choose what works best for you — there’s a WiFi option if you wa...
Harbor Baby Monitor | Babylist Shop
These organic cotton bassinet sheets are such a staple for those early newborn days 🤍 The fabric is super soft and breathable, which makes me feel better about baby sleeping comfortably and safely. I love that this comes in a 2-pack — you will need ...
2-Pack Organic Cotton Bassinet Sheets Pecan
These muslin crib sheets are SO cute if you love that soft, boho neutral vibe ☀️ The cotton fabric is really lightweight and breathable, which is perfect for keeping baby comfy while they sleep. I also love that it comes in a 2-pack (because let’s be...
Blissful Diary Muslin Crib Sheets 2 Pack
👶🏻 Babywearing Favorites
Babywearing was something I knew I wanted to incorporate early on — it’s such a game changer for keeping baby close while still having your hands free. These are the carriers I added (and loved) based on comfort, ease of use, and real-life practicali...
I was literally obsessed with this carrier — I ended up getting it in three different colors because I loved it that much 😭🤎 It’s so much better than a traditional wrap carrier in my opinion — way easier to put on while still feeling super soft, co...
Willow - Aerial Newborn Buckle Wrap
This one was actually gifted to me as a hand-me-down by my sister-in-law, but I had it on my list anyway lol 😅🤎 it’s so cute. I love the linen fabric — it feels really high quality, breathable, and just has that elevated, neutral look I’m always dr...
The Monarch Carrier - Mocha Check
You can use my code ALLISONC for 16% off, which is such a nice bonus 👀
This is one of those items I added for later on when baby gets heavier — instead of putting pressure on your shoulders and back, it helps distribute the weight through your hips...
Tushbaby 2-in-1 Convertible Carrier
🫧 Bath + Care Essentials
Bath + care items were something I wanted to keep simple, gentle, and safe, especially for those early newborn days. These are the essentials I added to make bath time feel easy, calming, and not overwhelming — for both baby and me.
I focused on pro...
This is one of those simple but SO helpful bath time essentials — it keeps baby supported and slightly elevated, so you’re not struggling to hold them the entire time. I love that it makes bath time feel a lot more relaxed (and way less stressful, es...
Angelcare Baby Bath Support Gray for Infants
Makes bath time so much smoother (and tear-free) 🤍 This rinse cup is perfect for gently washing baby’s hair without water getting in their eyes. I love the soft, minimal design and easy grip—simple, functional, and way more aesthetic than your typic...
Bath Rinse Cup Shifting Sand One Size
A simple little safety upgrade that gives so much peace of mind 🤍 This soft spout cover helps protect baby from bumps during bath time while still keeping things minimal and aesthetic. Easy to slip on and off, and one of those small swaps that makes...
Spout Cover Natural One Size
The sweetest little post-bath essential 🤍 This organic cotton poncho towel is so soft, cozy, and gentle on baby’s skin—perfect for wrapping them up warm right after bath time. I love the hooded bear design (so cute) and how easy it is to throw on an...
mushie Poncho Towel for Toddlers (Fog)
Such a good, clean staple for bath time 🤍 This gentle 2-in-1 wash is made with non-toxic, plant-based ingredients that cleanse without drying out baby’s skin. I love that it’s fragrance-free, super hydrating, and safe for even the most sensitive or ...
Organic Baby Shampoo and Body Wash - Evereden
This bath kneeler pad makes baby bath time so much more comfortable 🙌 Instead of kneeling on a hard floor, you get nice cushioning for your knees (which you’ll definitely appreciate during those longer bath routines). It also helps you stay in a bet...
Baby Bath Kneeler & Elbow Rest Pad Set
These bath toys are so fun for keeping baby entertained during bath time 🐠 What I love most is that they’re designed to be mold-free, so you don’t have to worry about water getting trapped inside like with a lot of other bath toys. Super easy to cle...
Sealife Mold Free Bath Play Set
🧺 Diapering Must-Haves
Diapering is one of those everyday things you’ll be doing a lot, so I wanted a setup that felt practical, flexible, and as low-stress as possible. These are the essentials I added to cover both the early newborn stage and what works longer term.
In ...
This was one of those items I prioritized for a clean, non-toxic setup, especially since it’s something baby is in contact with every day. I love that it’s made with organic materials, which just gives that extra peace of mind during diaper changes.
...
Organic Cotton Changing Pad
You can use code ALLISONBABY20 for 20% off, which is such a good deal 👀
I added this as a more sustainable diapering option, and I love that it comes as a bundle so you’re not piecing everything together yourself. The inner + outer system makes it ...
Organic Cloth Diaper Bundle Starter
You can use code ALLISONBABY20 for 20% off, which makes this an even easier yes 👀
I love this as a low-commitment way to try cloth diapering without going all in right away. It gives you a feel for how everything works, which is so helpful if you’r...
Cloth Diapering Try-It Kit - Esembly Baby
Use code ALLISONBABY20 for 20% off! I added these for overnight protection once baby is sleeping longer stretches — they give that extra absorbency so you’re not dealing with leaks in the middle of the night (which no one wants 😅).
Even if you’re n...
Ultra-Absorbent Overnight Cloth Diaper Booster Insert - Esembly Baby
I added this as a really gentle, clean option for diaper rash, especially if you’re trying to avoid harsh ingredients. I love that it’s fragrance-free and zinc-based, so it’s effective but still feels safe for sensitive skin.
I personally don’t use ...
Diaper Rash Creams & Sprays - Babo Botanicals
I know a lot of people say to skip the wipe warmer, but if you’re planning to use reusable cloth wipes, this is honestly a must-have. It keeps them warm and ready to go, which just makes the whole process way more comfortable for baby.
I also really...
Munchkin Touch Free Baby Wipe Warmer with Nightlight: Polypropylene Material, 100 Maximum Capacity
These are an absolute must-have if you’re doing reusable cloth wipes and diapering — I use these constantly. They’re super soft, gentle on baby’s skin, and hold up really well after multiple washes, which is exactly what you need.
I love that they’r...
SmoothNovelty 48 Pcs Reusable Flannel Baby Wipes
This wipes concentrate is one of my favorite low-tox swaps 🌿 I love that I can make my own baby wipes at home with simple, clean ingredients — no hidden chemicals or fragrances. It’s super gentle on sensitive skin and way more eco-friendly than cons...
Juice Those Wipes - Natural Baby Wipes Solution
Okay this is one of those underrated cloth diaper essentials 🙌 it keeps everything contained while spraying diapers into the toilet (no splashing everywhere 😅). Makes cleanup so much quicker, cleaner, and honestly way less intimidating if you’re ne...
RinseWorks SprayMate Cloth Diaper Sprayer Shield
This is a MUST if you’re cloth diapering 🙌 it hooks right onto your toilet and makes rinsing diapers so much easier and more hygienic. Strong enough to get everything clean quickly, but still easy to control. Once you have this setup, cloth diaperin...
Purrfectzone Stainless Steel Bidet Sprayer Kit
This diaper pail is a favorite for a reason 🙌 the steel design actually locks in odors (way better than plastic ones I’ve tried), and you don’t need special bags which I love. It looks clean, works really well, and keeps the nursery from smelling li...
Ubbi Stainless Steel Diaper Pail - Ivory: Childproof Lid, Airtight Odor Control, Uses Standard Liners
🚗 On-the-Go Essentials
Everything I actually use to get out of the house with a baby — without the chaos 🚗✨
These are my go-to on-the-go essentials that make errands, walks, and travel feel way more manageable as a mom. From a reliable stroller to a safe car seat and a co...
This was definitely our biggest splurge, but honestly so worth it 💖 — especially if you’re thinking about convenience and long-term use. The electronic assist makes pushing the stroller feel so much easier (huge help on walks, hills, or longer outin...
Cybex eGazelle S Electronic Assist Stroller - Taupe Frame/Almond Beige Seat | Babylist Shop
This was one of those items I really wanted to feel extra confident about in terms of safety and comfort, and this one checked so many boxes. I love that it has the SensorSafe feature, which gives added peace of mind while driving.
The reclining fea...
Cybex Cloud G Lux SensorSafe Comfort Extend Reclining Infant Car Seat + Sunshade Bundle - Moon Black
I added this as the perfect newborn attachment for the stroller, especially for those early walks when baby isn’t ready for a regular seat yet. It creates a flat, cozy space that’s much more comfortable and supportive for newborns.
I also love how s...
Cybex eGazelle/Gazelle S Cot - Almond Beige | Babylist Shop
Perfect for creating a safe, cozy sleep space wherever you are—whether it’s at home, visiting family, or traveling. I love having a portable pack and play on hand for naps, bedtime, or even a secure play area during the day. It folds up easily, trave...
Dream On Me Zodiak Portable Playard with Carry Bag & Shoulder Strap, Beige, Unisex - Walmart.com
This portable changing pad is one of those things you don’t realize you need until you’re out and about 🙌 It folds up super compact but opens into a clean, waterproof space for diaper changes anywhere. I LOVE the built-in wipes pocket — it makes eve...
Tiny Twinkle Portable/Foldable Waterproof Diaper Changing Pad with Smart Wipes Pocket (Beige Checkers)
This stroller fan is a total lifesaver for keeping baby cool on walks ☀️ It clips right onto the stroller and has flexible legs so you can position it exactly where you need it. The airflow is surprisingly strong for how compact it is, and it makes a...
JISULIFE Large Bladeless Stroller Fan, 4000mAh
🧸 Play + Extras Worth Having
A little “nice to have” section for the extras that make playtime even sweeter (and easier) 🤍 Think aesthetic, non-toxic pieces that aren’t necessarily essential—but elevate your space, support development, and get used more than you’d expect. From ...
A cozy, aesthetic little spot for baby to relax, play, or gently bounce while staying close to you 🤍 I love that this one is made with organic cotton and keeps things simple—no lights, noise, or overstimulation—just natural movement and comfort. It’...
Baby Delight Alpine Deluxe Portable Bouncer - Oat: Detachable Toy Bar, Reclining Seat, Folds for Easy Transport
The cutest, coziest little space for tummy time, playtime, and all those early milestones 🤍 I love that it’s made with organic cotton and natural latex foam—so it’s soft yet supportive (perfect for rolling, crawling, and little tumbles). It’s comple...
Checker Toffee Organic Cotton Mat
A beautifully designed play gym for those early months when baby is learning to focus, reach, and explore 🤍 I love how intentional and low-stimulation it is—no flashy lights or noise, just simple, sensory-rich play. Perfect for tummy time and early ...
The Play Gym | Baby Activity & Tummy Time Mat - Lovevery
Perfect for those early newborn days when baby is just starting to see the world 🤍 High contrast black and white visuals help stimulate their developing vision and keep them engaged during tummy time or quiet play. I love using these for simple, int...
Black & White High Contrast Baby Flash Cards
This little activity toy is perfect for keeping baby entertained on the go ☁️ I love attaching it to the car seat so he can play with it during drives, and it’s also great for stroller walks. It has different textures for teething and sensory play, w...
Itzy Ritzy Bitzy Busy Ring Teething Activity Toy - Cloud - 4pc: BPA-Free, Sensory Development, Shapes and Colors
This milestone swaddle blanket is such a cute way to document baby’s growth month by month ☀️ I love the boho sun design — it’s super neutral and looks beautiful in photos. The fabric is soft enough to use as a regular swaddle or blanket, and it make...
Sweet Jojo Designs Boy or Girl Gender Neutral Unisex Milestone Swaddle Baby Blanket Boho Sun Orange and Taupe
These play kits are such a thoughtful way to support baby’s development at every stage 🧠 Each box is tailored to your baby’s age and comes with high-quality toys designed to encourage learning through play. I love that it takes the guesswork out of ...
The Play Kits by Lovevery | Montessori Toy Subscription Ages 0-5
🫶🏻For Mama
This section is all about taking care of you, mama 🤍 Postpartum recovery and feeding support don’t get talked about enough, but they make such a huge difference in those early days. I put together my go-to essentials for healing, comfort, and lactat...
This perineal spray was such a lifesaver during postpartum recovery 🙌 It gives instant cooling relief and helps soothe soreness in those first few weeks after birth. I love that it’s made with clean, gentle ingredients, so it doesn’t irritate sensit...
Earth Mama Herbal Perineal Spray for Pregnant Women and Postpartum, 4 fl oz
This milk maker kit is such a great support option if you’re breastfeeding or pumping 🤍 It includes a mix of lactation snacks and drinks designed to help support milk supply, which can be super helpful in those early postpartum days. I love that it’...
Boost your milk supply with our monthly delivery: 2 Milk to the Max Bars boxes, 2 Hydromom drink mix bags, and 1 Boobie Bears jar for energy and hydration.
These are such a great alternative to disposable postpartum diapers 🙌 I loved having these on hand for a more comfortable and less wasteful option during recovery. They’re super soft, stretchy, and actually feel like real underwear — not bulky or aw...
The Bikini Period. in SportyStretch™ For Heavy Flows
This portable bidet is a must-have for postpartum recovery 🙌 It’s basically a more convenient version of the hospital peri bottle, but way easier to use — especially when you’re not at home. It gives gentle, targeted relief and helps you stay clean ...
Portable Travel Bidet - Manual Squeeze, Leak-Proof, Extendable Nozzle (Pink)
🌱 Organic Clothing
Use code ALLISONCAROLS for 15% off! This organic cotton romper is one of those pieces you’ll keep reaching for 🤍 The fabric is super soft and breathable, which is perfect for baby’s sensitive skin. I love the 2-way zipper — it makes diaper changes s...
Oatmeal | Organic Zipper Romper
Use code ALLISONCAROLS for 15% off! This footie is such a cozy, everyday essential for baby 🤍 The organic cotton is super soft and gentle on sensitive skin, and the 2-way zipper makes diaper changes quick and easy (especially during nighttime). I lo...
Buttercream | Organic Zipper Footie