Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Chili Ingredients and Tools I Simmer All Day for That Lodge Smell
36
items You know that deep, smoky, stick-to-your-ribs chili smell that hits you when you walk into a cabin? I spent years chasing that with sad stovetop attempts that tasted flat and smelled like nothing. This is everything I use now, from the slow cooker to...
Sections
6
Slow Cookers That Actually Hold Up to a Full Day Simmer
Dried Chili Peppers and Spices That Build Real Depth
Canned Goods and Beans That Save Hours of Prep
Meat and Protein That Stand Up to Long Cooking
Toppings and Sides That Make Chili Night Feel Like an Event
Kitchen Tools That Make All-Day Cooking Actually Manageable
Slow Cookers That Actually Hold Up to a Full Day Simmer
My old slow cooker had a crack in the lid and the low setting was basically room temperature. Replacing it changed everything about how my chili turns out.
Grab this if you make chili for more than two people. I fit a triple batch in here and had leftovers for the whole week. The manual dial means no weird auto-shutoff ruining your 8-hour simmer.
Crock-Pot Manual 7-Quart Slow Cooker, Mussel Grey
Use this one if you leave for work and need it to switch to warm automatically. Before I had a programmable cooker, I came home to overcooked mush twice. Never again.
Hamilton Beach FlexCook 6 Quart Slow Cooker
Keep this around for nights when you forgot to start chili in the morning. Pressure cook setting gets you 80% of the way to all-day flavor in about 45 minutes. Saved my Sundays more than once.
Instant Pot Duo 6 Quart 7-in-1 Multi-Use Programmable
Switch to this if you want that deep browning on the meat before the long simmer. I sear everything right in the pot, then toss it in the oven at 275 for hours. The difference in flavor is wild.
Lodge Cast Iron 6 Quart Enameled Dutch Oven, Indigo
Try this if you're tired of setting a hot lid on your counter and burning the finish. The hinged lid stays attached. Small detail, but after scorching my countertop twice I was done.
Crock-Pot, Programmable 4.5-Qt Lift & Serve
Snag this for easier cleanup. The ceramic insert is nonstick and I don't have to soak it overnight anymore. For anyone who dreads the post-chili scrubbing, this fixes that completely.
GreenLife 6 Quart Non Stick Slow Cooker
Dried Chili Peppers and Spices That Build Real Depth
Chili powder from a generic shaker was my whole strategy for years and the flavor was always one-dimensional. Whole dried peppers and fresh-ground spices changed the entire profile.
Keep this as your base layer but don't rely on it alone. I use about 3 tablespoons per batch and then build on top of it with the real dried peppers. Alone it's fine, layered it's fantastic.
McCormick Chili Seasoning Mix, 1.25 oz Packet
Use a heavy hand with this one, like two full tablespoons. Before I started being generous with cumin my chili tasted like seasoned tomato soup. This is what gives it that earthy warmth.
McCormick Kosher Ground Cumin, 1.5 oz Bottle
Toss in a tablespoon if you want that smoky campfire note without actually smoking anything. My wife thought I'd added chipotle the first time. It's sneaky good.
McCormick® Smoked Paprika, 1.75 oz
Pair this with your smoked paprika for heat that builds slowly. Start with half a teaspoon if you're feeding kids. I learned the hard way that a full tablespoon will clear a room.
Simply Organic, Organic Cayenne Pepper, GMO Free
Crush this between your palms right over the pot. Dried oregano in chili sounds weird until you try it. A buddy from Texas taught me this trick and I haven't skipped it since.
Badia Oregano Whole Spice, 5.5 oz Bottle
Swap your table salt for this immediately. Coarse salt dissolves slowly during a long simmer and seasons more evenly. My chili stopped tasting weirdly salty in spots once I switched.
Morton Kosher Salt Flakes 3 lb.
Canned Goods and Beans That Save Hours of Prep
I used to soak dried beans overnight and half the time I'd forget and wake up to foam all over my counter. Good canned beans and tomatoes get the job done without the drama.
Grab two cans per batch. These hold their shape after 6 hours of simmering, which is rare. Other brands turned to mush on me by hour four.
Bush's Dark Red Kidney Beans, Canned Beans, 16 oz
Throw a can of these in alongside the kidneys for a creamier texture. They break down just enough to thicken the broth naturally. Learned this from a diner cook in New Mexico.
Bush's Best Pinto Beans, 16 oz - Case of 12
Use two cans of this instead of plain diced tomatoes. The green chilies add a background heat that's subtle but makes people ask what your secret ingredient is.
ROTEL Original Diced Tomatoes and Green Chilies, 10 oz
Stir in one whole small can at the beginning and let it caramelize with the meat. This is what gives chili that deep brick-red color. Without it, everything looks pale and watery.
Hunt's, Tomato Sauce, 15 oz can, Perfect for Chili & Soups
Pour in about a cup to keep things from getting too thick by hour six. Chicken broth works but beef broth adds another savory layer that ties everything together better.
Swanson Beef Stock, 32 oz Carton
Try half a jar stirred in during the last hour. Sounds lazy but it adds a complexity that would take five extra ingredients to replicate from scratch. A friend caught me doing this and I had to confess.
Green Mountain Gringo Medium Salsa 16oz
Meat and Protein That Stand Up to Long Cooking
Lean ground beef was my go-to and it always dried out into sad little pebbles by dinnertime. Fattier cuts and mixed proteins changed everything about the texture.
Get the 80/20, not the 90/10. You need that fat to keep things rich after 6 hours. I trim nothing, skim nothing. The fat is doing the heavy lifting for flavor.
Customer reviews for Great Value Beef Burgers
Brown half a pound of this with your beef and watch what happens. The fennel and herbs in Italian sausage give chili a warmth that straight beef can't touch. My dad thought I'd been cooking all weekend.
Great Value Mild Italian Smoked Sausages, 900 g
Dice these up small and toss them in during the last two hours. They add a salty, slightly spicy bite that reminds me of pizza in the best way. Kids especially go nuts for this addition.
HORMEL Turkey Pepperoni Slices, Pizza Topping
Chop four slices and render them first, then build your chili in the bacon fat. The smoky pork flavor gets into everything. Worth the extra five minutes of prep every single time.
Great Value Thick Sliced Hickory Smoked Bacon 16 oz
Swap these in if someone in your house won't eat red meat. Thighs hold up way better than breast in a slow cooker. They shred beautifully around hour five.
Great Value All Natural Boneless Skinless Chicken Thighs
Keep a bag of this in your freezer for lazy chili days. Dump in a cup and skip all the chopping. No shame in it. I use this every time I start a batch before 7 AM.
Great Value Seasoning Blend with Onions, Celery
Toppings and Sides That Make Chili Night Feel Like an Event
Plain chili in a bowl gets old fast. Setting out toppings bar-style turned a Tuesday dinner into something my family actually gets excited about.
Dollop this on top right before serving. It cuts through the heat and adds a cool creaminess that balances everything. My youngest won't eat chili without a mountain of this on top.
Daisy Pure and Natural Sour Cream, 16 oz (1 lb) Tub
Shred this yourself instead of buying pre-shredded. It melts way better because there's no anti-caking powder coating it. Takes two minutes and the difference is obvious.
Kraft Natural Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 16 oz Block
Crush a handful right into the bowl. The salty crunch against the soft chili is addictive. Frito pie vibes without the mess of actually making Frito pie. Everyone fights over the last bag.
Fritos Regular Corn Chips, 9.25 oz Single Bag
Bake a batch of these 20 minutes before dinner. Warm cornbread with butter next to a bowl of chili is the closest I get to feeling like I live in a mountain lodge. Costs about 75 cents a box.
Jiffy Cornbread Waffles -- so EASY!
Set the jar on the table for anyone who wants extra heat. These have a vinegary tang that fresh jalapenos don't, and they're already sliced. Perfect for the person who thinks your chili isn't spicy enough.
La Costeña Pickled Whole Jalapeno Peppers, 25.9 oz
Slice these thin and scatter them on top for a fresh bite. Raw green onion against slow-cooked chili is a contrast that wakes everything up. Takes 30 seconds and looks like you planned a whole presentation.
Fresh Whole Green Onion 1 Bunch, Fresh Produce
Kitchen Tools That Make All-Day Cooking Actually Manageable
Standing over a pot stirring every 20 minutes is not my idea of a relaxing day off. These tools let me start the chili and basically forget about it until the house smells amazing.
Plug your slow cooker into this and set it to shut off after your target time. Saved me from overcooking on days when I got stuck running errands longer than planned.
KitchenAid Slow Cooker 6-Quart with Glass Lid
Use a wooden spoon instead of metal so you don't scratch your slow cooker insert. This one has a comfortable handle for when you're stirring a heavy pot. Mine is stained permanently red and I consider that character.
OXO Good Grips Wooden Large Spoon
Portion out leftovers the same night. Chili freezes incredibly well and future-you will be grateful on a busy Wednesday. I keep four of these filled in my freezer at all times.
Rubbermaid, Food Storage Containers, 10 Piece Set, Red
Get a ladle with a pour spout so chili actually goes in the bowl instead of down the side. Sounds minor until you've cleaned dried chili off your counter for the tenth time.
OXO Good Grips 3-Piece Wooden Spoon Set
Measure your broth and tomato paste accurately instead of eyeballing. I used to wing it and every batch tasted different. Consistency started here.
Pyrex, Measuring Cup, 2-Cup, Glass with Red Graphics
Line your slow cooker with one of these before you start. When dinner's done, lift out the liner and toss it. Cleanup takes about 15 seconds. For anyone who hates scrubbing baked-on chili residue, this is the answer.
Reynolds Kitchens, Slow Cooker Liners, Fits 3-8 Qt, 21" Clear