Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Found a Pie Maker That Bakes Individual Pot Pies in 8 Minutes
42
items Weeknight dinners used to mean frozen pizza or sad leftovers reheated until they lost all dignity. Then I got a personal pie maker and suddenly I'm the person bringing homemade pot pies to work. This list is for anyone who wants real comfort food on ...
Sections
6
Pie Makers and Mini Bakers That Actually Deliver
Pie Crusts and Dough That Skip the Rolling Pin
Fillings and Proteins for Quick Pot Pies
Sauces and Seasonings That Make Fillings Taste Homemade
Tools That Make Pie Assembly Fast and Clean
Dessert Pies and Sweet Fillings Worth Trying
Pie Makers and Mini Bakers That Actually Deliver
Spent way too long reading reviews and returning gadgets before landing on these. Some pie makers are glorified paperweights. These ones actually seal, bake evenly, and pop out clean pies without a fight.
Grab this if you want pot pies, dessert pies, or even empanadas done in under 10 minutes. Before I had this, reheating leftover chicken meant microwaving it into rubber. Now I wrap it in dough and have a real meal. Perfect for anyone cooking for one ...
Pie Maker & Recipe Guide | How to Make Mini Pies - Dash
Use this when you're feeding more than just yourself. Makes two full pies at once, so date night dinners actually come out at the same time. Bought it after my single pie maker couldn't keep up when friends came over. The nonstick coating is legit.
Hamilton Beach Breakfast Maker
Switch to this if you're serious about crust quality. Deeper wells than most, so you can actually stuff the filling without it oozing everywhere. A coworker saw my lunch and asked if I ordered from a bakery.
Breville BPI640XL the Personal Pie - Pie maker
Hear me out. This tiny waffle maker doubles as a mini pie press if you use the right dough thickness. Keep it at your desk for afternoon snack emergencies. Costs less than two takeout lunches.
Nostalgia MyMini Personal electric waffle maker compact
Toss pie dough in here with a spoonful of apple filling and you get these bite-sized dessert pies that disappear at parties. My kids call them pie nuggets. Works for savory fillings too.
Dash Waffle Makers
Snag this if counter space is tight and you want one gadget that does pies, donuts, and waffles with swappable plates. Replaced three appliances in my tiny apartment kitchen. Cleanup takes maybe two minutes.
Holstein Housewares, Personal Waffle Maker
Try this for mini pies, cupcakes, and donut holes all from one machine. Got it for my daughter's birthday and ended up using it every single week after. The recipe book it comes with is actually useful, not just filler.
Babycakes Multi-Treat Maker
Pie Crusts and Dough That Skip the Rolling Pin
Rolling out dough from scratch on a Tuesday night is a fantasy. These pre-made options taste homemade enough that nobody asks questions, and they fit right into a pie maker without trimming.
Keep a box of these in the fridge at all times. Cut circles with a bowl, drop them in the pie maker, and you're halfway to dinner. Tastes way better than the frozen stuff and unrolls flat without cracking.
Pillsbury Premade Refrigerated Pie Crusts Two 14.1 oz
Use these when you want a slightly flakier, more buttery crust. Pop them out of the tin, let them thaw ten minutes, then cut to size. My neighbor thought I made the dough from scratch. Let her believe it.
Marie Callender's Deep Dish Pastry Pie Shells
Grab this if you read ingredient labels and don't want hydrogenated anything. Rolls out clean, bakes golden, and doesn't taste like cardboard health food. For the friend who brings organic wine to potlucks.
IMMACULATE BAKING COMPANY Pie Crust, 15 OZ
Wrap these around your filling instead of pie dough for a lighter, puffier crust. Game night crowd went through 16 mini pies in about 20 minutes. Way cheaper per pie than buying frozen pot pies.
Crescent Rolls in Doughs
Swap regular pie dough for puff pastry when you want that restaurant-level flaky top. Thaw it on the counter for 40 minutes, cut, fill, bake. The layers puff up beautifully even in a mini pie maker.
Pepperidge Farm Bulk Frozen Puff Pastry, 10” X 15” Sheets, 12.3 Ounces, Pack of 20
Toss one of these in the cart when you need backup crusts without spending much. They're sturdy enough to hold heavy fillings like beef stew. Not fancy, but reliable, and that's what weeknights need.
Great Value Deep Dish 9-inch Pie Crusts, 16 oz, 2 Pack
Try these for a slightly sweeter, softer wrap around savory fillings. The contrast between the buttery dough and a chicken pot pie filling is surprisingly good. Stock up because they sell out fast at my store.
Organic Crescent Rolls
Fillings and Proteins for Quick Pot Pies
The filling is where you make or break a pot pie. I used to overcomplicate it with raw ingredients and long cook times. These shortcuts taste like you spent an hour at the stove when you really spent five minutes.
Pour a splash of this into your filling mix and everything suddenly tastes richer. Went from dry, crumbly pot pies to ones with actual gravy inside. Keep two cartons in the pantry because you'll use it constantly.
Swanson Chicken Broth, 32 oz Carton
Drain this, mix with cream of chicken soup and frozen veggies, and you have pot pie filling in literally three minutes. For anyone who gets home at 6:30 and needs food on the table by 7.
Tyson White Premium Chunk Chicken Breast, 12.5 oz Can
Use this as your gravy base instead of making a roux from scratch. One can mixed with shredded chicken and peas fills about six mini pies. My grandmother would probably judge me but my family keeps asking for seconds.
Heart Healthy Cream of Chicken Soup
Switch to turkey when you want a lighter filling that still feels like comfort food. Mix it with a little cream cheese, diced celery, and a pinch of sage. Thanksgiving flavor any night of the week.
Customer reviews for Hormel Smoked Chunk Ham, 5 oz Can
Microwave this bag for four minutes and dump it straight into your filling. No chopping, no boiling, no scrubbing cutting boards. Perfect for the person who wants vegetables in their pie but not the prep work.
Birds Eye Steamfresh Mixed Vegetables
Grab this budget-friendly option when you're making a big batch of pies for meal prep. Tastes nearly identical to the name brand once it's mixed with seasoning and gravy. Your wallet will thank you.
Great Value Canned Chunk Chicken Breast 12.5 oz Pack
Sprinkle this into any pot pie filling and it immediately smells like Thanksgiving. Before I started using this, my pies tasted flat no matter what I added. A little goes a long way, so one jar lasts months.
McCormick Kosher Poultry Seasoning, 0.65 oz Bottle
Sauces and Seasonings That Make Fillings Taste Homemade
Plain chicken and vegetables in dough is just a sad pocket. These sauces and spices are what turn a five-minute assembly into something that tastes like it simmered all afternoon.
Swap this in for cream of chicken when you want a deeper, earthier gravy. Works especially well with beef filling. One can is the exact right amount for six mini pies without making them soggy.
Marry Me Chicken - Recipes
Toss a tablespoon of this into your chicken pot pie filling and watch people's faces light up. Ranch pot pies sound weird until you try them. My teenage son now requests these over actual dinner.
Hidden Valley Ranch Dips Mixes for Recipes
Use this when you want pot pies with actual personality. A few shakes turn basic chicken filling into something with a warm kick. For anyone who thinks comfort food and spice aren't mutually exclusive.
Tony Chachere's® Original Creole Seasoning, 8 oz
Stir a spoonful into your filling while it's warm and it melts into this creamy, rich sauce that holds everything together. Discovered this by accident when I was out of soup. Never went back.
Philadelphia Cream Cheese, 2 Blocks, for Recipes
Squeeze a thin line of this into beef or ham pie filling for a tangy bite that cuts through the richness. Sounds strange, but trust the process. My British friend said it reminded her of proper pub pies.
French's Kosher Classic Yellow Mustard, 20.0 oz Bottle
Pour this straight from the jar when you don't have time to mix cream soups with broth. It's already the perfect consistency for pie filling. Keep a jar in the back of the fridge for emergency pie nights.
Heinz HomeStyle Classic Chicken Gravy, 12 oz Jar
Sprinkle this on the inside of your crust before adding filling. It seasons every bite from the outside in. Picked up this trick from a YouTube comment and it honestly changed how my pies taste.
365 by Whole Foods Market Seasoning Salt, 2.96 OZ
Tools That Make Pie Assembly Fast and Clean
First few times I made mini pies, my counter looked like a flour bomb went off. These tools cut the mess in half and made the whole process actually enjoyable instead of a chore I dreaded.
Use the 3.5 inch cutter to stamp perfect dough circles that fit right into pie makers. Before this, I was using a drinking glass and tearing the dough every time. Clean edges seal way better too.
Wilton Animal Cookie Cutter Set, 50-Piece, Plastic
Roll your dough on this instead of flouring your entire counter. The measurement guides printed on it help you get even thickness. Rolls up for storage so it doesn't eat cabinet space.
OXO Good Grips Non-Slip Silicone Pastry Mat with Built-In
Grab this if you're working with homemade dough or puff pastry that needs evening out. Solid wood, no weird plastic handles that wobble. Feels like something your grandma would've owned.
Kitchenaid Durable Nonstick Rolling Pin in Red with Offset
Pack your mini pies in these for work lunches that make everyone in the break room jealous. Microwave safe, so reheating takes 90 seconds. Bought a 20 pack and use them constantly for meal prep Sundays.
Rubbermaid Takealongs Meal Prep
Lay these under your pie maker to catch drips and crumbs. Cleanup goes from five minutes of scrubbing to just tossing a sheet in the trash. Pre-cut sheets are worth the extra dollar over the roll.
Reynolds Kitchens Cookie Baking Sheets
Scoop filling with this for perfectly even portions every time. No more overstuffed pies that burst open or sad thin ones. Each scoop is exactly the right amount for one mini pie well.
OXO Good Grips 1055893 Medium Cookie Scoop
Mix and store leftover filling in these so you can make pies again tomorrow without any prep. Glass doesn't stain from turmeric or tomato like plastic does. Learned that lesson the expensive way.
Customer reviews for Pyrex Simply Store 2-Cup Glass
Dessert Pies and Sweet Fillings Worth Trying
Once you realize your pie maker does dessert too, weeknight treats become dangerously easy. These fillings go from jar to pie to mouth in about ten minutes. Willpower not included.
Spoon this into your pie maker with a cinnamon sugar dusted crust and you have mini apple pies that taste like fall. Brought these to a work potluck in October and left with an empty plate and three recipe requests.
Duncan Hines Comstock, Country Apple Pie Filling
Drop a tablespoon of this into pie dough, press it shut, and bake for six minutes. The chocolate melts into this gooey center that's basically a handheld lava cake. For the person with a sweet tooth and no patience.
Nutella, Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa, 13 oz Jar
Pair this with cream cheese inside a pie crust for a mini danish situation that works for breakfast or dessert. My morning routine went from granola bars to warm strawberry pies. No regrets.
Customer reviews for Smucker's Strawberry Jelly
Swirl peanut butter with a drizzle of honey inside pie dough for a protein-packed snack that kids demolish. Way more satisfying than PB&J and it takes the same amount of time to make.
Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, 16 oz Jar
Try this when you want something fruity but less sweet than apple. The blueberries hold their shape and don't turn into mush. Add a tiny squeeze of lemon juice and it tastes like a farmers market pie.
Lucky Leaf Premium Blueberry Fruit Filling and Topping
Toss a handful of these into your pie dough with mini marshmallows for s'mores pies that kids lose their minds over. Camping flavor without the campfire. Stock up before summer sleepovers.
Hershey's Milk Chocolate Baking Chips, Bag 11.5 oz
Mix this with lemon juice and a crumbled graham cracker for mini key lime pies that set up perfectly in the pie maker. Brought these to a barbecue and someone literally asked if I went to culinary school. I did not.
Eagle Brand