Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Found a Sandwich Press That Seals Edges and Makes Cheese Pockets
24
items If you've been smashing sad, leaky grilled cheeses in a flat panini press and watching all the good stuff ooze out the sides, I spent way too long testing deep-plate sandwich makers so you can skip straight to the ones that actually seal. This is for...
Sections
4
Deep Plate Sandwich Makers That Actually Seal
Breads That Seal and Crimp the Best
Cheeses That Melt Into Perfect Pockets
Fillings and Extras That Work Inside Sealed Sandwiches
Deep Plate Sandwich Makers That Actually Seal
I went through three flat presses before I figured out the problem wasn't my technique. It was the plates. These have deep pockets and ridged edges that crimp bread shut so melted cheese stays inside where it belongs.
Grab this if you're making breakfast sandwiches for two people every morning and can't afford to waste 20 minutes. It seals English muffins around egg and cheese in about five minutes flat. I was late to work three times before I got one of these.
Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker
Perfect for anyone in a tiny apartment with zero counter space. It folds shut, crimps the edges of regular sliced bread, and stores upright in a cabinet. My roommate thought I bought a waffle iron until she saw the sealed pockets come out.
Brentwood Nonstick Compact Dual Sandwich Maker
Swap out your old panini press for this. The angled plates push grease away and press bread edges together enough to keep fillings locked in. I used to wrap my sandwiches in foil to hold them together, which felt ridiculous.
Customer reviews for George Foreman 2-Serving Classic
Try this one if you want the deepest pockets on a budget. It turns two slices of regular bread into a sealed triangle stuffed with whatever you want. My kid calls them “pizza pockets” and honestly that tracks.
Holstein Housewares, 2-Sice Sandwich Griddle
Keep this at your desk if you're the person heating sad microwave lunches at work. It makes one perfect sealed round sandwich in under four minutes. Fits in a desk drawer. I've hidden mine from coworkers twice already.
Nostalgia, MyMini Sandwich Maker, 1200W, Mint Green
Use this when you're feeding more than just yourself. Two deep compartments, nonstick plates that actually release without tearing the bread. Took me one Sunday brunch to realize I should have bought this years ago.
Cuisinart Dual Sandwich WM-SW2N Electric Sandwich Grill
Breads That Seal and Crimp the Best
Not all bread works in a deep plate press. I ruined a beautiful sourdough loaf learning this. Softer, slightly thicker slices crimp way better and don't crack open when the lid closes.
This is the bread that changed everything for me. Soft enough to seal perfectly in a sandwich press, thick enough to hold a pile of fillings. If you've been using thin sandwich bread and wondering why it tears, switch to this immediately.
Sara Lee Artesano Brioche Bakery Bread
Grab a loaf of this if your kids are picky about crusts. It's soft, slightly sweet, and the edges crimp together like they were designed for a sandwich maker. Honestly the sealed edges taste better than the middle.
Nature's Own Butterbread, Non-GMO Bread
Slice these in half horizontally and press them. The sugar in the dough caramelizes against the hot plates and creates this crispy sealed edge that's borderline addictive. I discovered this by accident and now I buy two packs at a time.
King's Hawaiian Original Hawaiian Sweet Rolls 12 Count
Use this for bigger sandwiches when you want to really stuff the pocket. The slices are wide and sturdy enough to hold a thick layer of filling without blowing out. Learned the hard way that thin bread can't handle pulled pork.
Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Hearty White Bread, 24 oz Loaf
Toss a large tortilla in the press instead of bread sometime. Fold it over the filling, close the lid, and it seals into a crispy quesadilla pocket in two minutes. Game over for my takeout habit once I figured this out.
Mission Super Soft Flour Tortillas, Burrito Size, 16 Count
Perfect if you want a breakfast sandwich that seals around egg and cheese without getting soggy. The nooks and crannies grip the filling so nothing slides out. I make six on Sunday and freeze them for the week.
Customer reviews for Thomas' Original English Muffins
Cheeses That Melt Into Perfect Pockets
Some cheeses melt. Some cheeses just sit there and sweat. I tested more varieties than I'm proud of, and these are the ones that actually turn into gooey, stretchy pockets inside a sealed sandwich.
Slice this thick off the block instead of using pre-shredded. It melts slower and stays gooey instead of turning greasy. Pre-shredded has anti-caking powder that messes with the melt. I didn't know that until embarrassingly recently.
Tillamook Medium Cheddar Cheese Block, 16 oz
Ditch the plastic-wrapped singles and try real deli American cheese. It melts into this creamy, smooth layer that glues the sandwich together from the inside. Night and day difference from what I grew up eating.
Boar's Head American Cheese Nutrition Facts
Slice this into thick rounds for a pressed caprese sandwich. It gets stretchy and pulls apart in long strings when you bite in. Fair warning, you will burn the roof of your mouth because you won't wait long enough. Ask me how I know.
BelGioioso Fresh Mozzarella Log, Pre-Sliced Cheese, 16 oz
Pair this with leftover rotisserie chicken in a sealed press sandwich. The pepper jack gets melty with little pockets of spice. Perfect for anyone who thinks grilled cheese is boring but doesn't want to do a lot of work.
Sargento® Pepper Jack Sliced Cheese, 10 slices
Look, I know. But Velveeta melts like absolutely nothing else on earth. When you want a sealed sandwich where the cheese is basically a sauce, this is it. No shame. My fancy cheese friends quietly ask me to make them one.
Velveeta Slices Sharp Cheddar Cheese, 16 Count Pack
Use this when you want a grilled cheese that actually tastes like cheese and not just salt and oil. Sharp cheddar in a sealed pocket hits different because the flavor concentrates inside. Stock up before cold weather because this is peak soup-and-san...
Cabot Creamery Seriously Sharp Cheddar Cheese Block 8
Fillings and Extras That Work Inside Sealed Sandwiches
Once I got the seal right, I started experimenting with what goes inside. Some things work perfectly in a pressed pocket. Others turn into a watery mess. These are the winners after months of trial and a few spectacular failures.
Layer this with Swiss and a thin spread of mustard before pressing. The turkey doesn't release water like cheaper deli meat, so your bread stays crispy. I ruined two sandwiches with watery turkey before switching to this.
Hormel Natural Choice Applewood Smoked Turkey Deli
Spread a thin layer inside before pressing for a pizza pocket situation. Key word is THIN. I flooded my first attempt and spent 20 minutes cleaning marinara out of the press. A tablespoon per side is plenty, trust me.
Rao's Homemade Marinara Sauce, 24 oz
Drizzle a little inside a ham and cheese pocket right before closing the press. The heat blooms when it's sealed in with melted cheese. For anyone who puts hot sauce on everything but hasn't tried it in a pressed sandwich yet.
Huy Fong Sriracha Hot Chili Sauce
Swap this in for regular yellow mustard and the whole sandwich levels up. A thin layer on each slice before pressing keeps things from tasting flat. My partner was a yellow mustard loyalist for 30 years and converted after one bite.
Grey Poupon Dijon Mustard, 8 oz. Jar
Squeeze one of the single-serve cups into a sealed tortilla press with shredded cheese and leftover chicken. The guac stays creamy inside instead of browning because it's sealed away from air. Accidentally brilliant lunch hack.
WHOLLY Guacamole Minis Paste Classic 12oz 6 pack
Cook a few strips crispy, break them in half, and layer them inside before pressing. The sealed pocket keeps the bacon from falling out when you bite in, which solves the only problem bacon has ever had. Do this on a Saturday morning and thank me lat...
Oscar Mayer Naturally Hardwood Smoked Bacon