Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Found the Perfect Bagel Board Setup That Feeds 8 Guests
24
items You said yes to hosting brunch and now you're staring at your kitchen counter wondering how to feed eight people without losing your mind. If you've been cobbling together mismatched plates and hoping for the best, this is the spread setup I landed o...
Sections
6
Bagel Board and Serving Platters
Cream Cheese and Spreads
Lox and Smoked Fish
Bagels and Bread
Toppings Capers and Fresh Produce
Drinks and Finishing Touches
Bagel Board and Serving Platters
I used to pile everything on a cutting board from 2014 and wonder why it looked sad. These actually make the spread look like you planned it, even if you threw it together in 20 minutes.
Grab this if you want a board big enough to actually fit bagels, cream cheese, and lox without everything sliding off the edge. I arranged a full spread for eight on it and still had room for capers.
What Is Acacia Wood Furniture? Pros, Cons, and Durability
Use this as the anchor next to your board for sliced tomatoes and onions. Before I had a proper platter I was using a dinner plate, and guests kept knocking things off. Never again.
Libbey Serving Platters and Trays for Dining & Entertaining
Keep these for your capers, everything bagel seasoning, and diced red onion. They're the right size so you're not putting six capers in a giant bowl and calling it a day.
The Pioneer Woman Floral Bursts Serving Bowl Set, 3 Piece
Try setting this in the center of the table so guests can spin and grab what they need. Saved me from playing waitress and passing things around for 45 minutes straight.
MAINSTAYS 14” inch Eco-Bamboo Lazy Susan Organizer
Cream Cheese and Spreads
One plain brick of cream cheese on a plate is a cry for help. I started offering a few different flavors and suddenly people acted like I was running a restaurant.
Swap the generic stuff for this. I did a side-by-side once and three people at the table noticed the difference without me saying a word. It spreads cleaner on warm bagels too.
Philadelphia Cream Cheese, 2 Blocks, for Recipes
Pair this with everything bagels specifically. My brother-in-law, who eats like a picky 7-year-old, went back for seconds when I set this one out.
Philadelphia Chive and Onion Cream Cheese Spread 15.5
Get this for the friend in every group who's dairy-free. Last time I forgot, she just sat there eating plain bagels and I felt terrible. Problem solved.
Kite Hill Almond Milk Cream Cheese Spread
Toss this on the board as a wildcard option. Not everyone wants cream cheese at 10 AM, and the hummus crowd will quietly thank you for thinking of them.
Sabra Classic Original Fresh Hummus Dip
Lox and Smoked Fish
Cheap smoked salmon tastes like wet cardboard. I learned this the hard way at a brunch where nobody touched the fish. These are the ones people actually eat.
Drape this across the board in loose folds so it looks effortless. One package covers about four guests, so grab two if you're feeding eight. Worth every penny over the budget stuff.
Customer reviews for Latitude 45 Cold Smoked Atlantic Salmon
Snag this for anyone in the group who grew up eating herring at family gatherings. My dad's face lit up when he saw it on the table. Instant nostalgia move.
Vita Classic Herring in Wine Sauce, 2 lb., Gluten-Free
Keep a backup pouch of this in your fridge. I ran out of lox halfway through brunch once and had to pretend the board was supposed to look empty. Never making that mistake again.
SeaBear Ready To Eat Smoked Sockeye Salmon
Try this if you want something slightly different from salmon. Flake it onto the board in chunks. My neighbor who fishes every weekend said it tasted better than what he catches.
Ducktrap River of Maine Smoked Trout Fillets
Bagels and Bread
Store-brand bagels from the bread aisle are fine for a Tuesday morning. But when you've got guests, the bagel quality is the difference between compliments and polite silence.
Slice these in half, toast lightly, and fan them across the board. They hold up under a mountain of cream cheese and lox without falling apart, which sounds basic but matters.
Thomas' Plain Bagels, 6 count, 18 oz
Bring two bags because these disappear first. Every. Single. Time. I once bought one bag thinking it was enough and watched them vanish in eight minutes flat.
Thomas' Everything Bagels, 6 count, 18 oz
Use these for the person at brunch who asks if you have anything with whole grains. Seedy, dense, actually tastes good. Covers that base without you needing a specialty store run.
Dave's Killer Bread Epic Everything Bagels
Toss a handful of these in a small bowl on the side for anyone who wants the crunch without committing to a full bagel. Great for the late arrivals who just want to graze.
York Style Bagel Crisps
Toppings Capers and Fresh Produce
The toppings are where you go from basic to looking like you actually know what you're doing. Red onion, tomato, capers. Simple stuff that makes the whole board pop.
Drain these well and put them in the smallest bowl you own. A little goes a long way, and guests who know bagel boards will notice you picked the good small ones, not the giant mushy kind.
Mezzetta Imported Non-Pareil Capers, 4 fl oz Jar
Slice these thick, about a quarter inch, so they don't slide off the bagel. I used to cut them thin and they'd flop everywhere. Thick slices changed the whole experience.
Panko-Crusted Beefsteak Tomatoes + Cilantro Garlic Pesto
Cut paper-thin rings and soak them in ice water for ten minutes before serving. Takes the harsh bite out completely. Learned this trick from my aunt and now I can't skip it.
Fresh Whole Red Onion, Each
Squeeze a few wedges over the lox right before guests arrive. It brightens everything up and makes the salmon taste like you ordered it from a deli. Takes five seconds.
Benefits of Lemon Water: Vitamin C, Weight Loss
Drinks and Finishing Touches
Nobody talks about what to drink with a bagel board, but showing up with good coffee and something sparkling makes the whole thing feel intentional instead of thrown together.
Brew a full pot of this about 15 minutes before people arrive so the smell hits them at the door. Dark roast pairs perfectly with smoked fish. My friend called it restaurant-level, and she's hard to impress.
Starbucks at Home, Ground Coffee, 12 oz
Set a few of these out on ice for anyone who doesn't drink coffee or mimosas. The fizz is aggressive in the best way and it cleanses your palate between bites of everything.
Good news for fans of the mineral water brand, Topo Chico.
Keep a small dish of this near the bagels for the person who just wants butter. Sounds boring, but this butter on a warm everything bagel is honestly hard to beat.
Kerrygold Grass-Fed Salted Pure Irish Butter, 8 oz
Pour this into a glass pitcher so it looks fancy. Works for guests who don't drink alcohol, kids, or anyone who just wants something bubbly at 10 AM without the wine headache later.
Martinelli's Sparkling Apple Cider, 4pk, 25.4 fl oz Glass Bottle