Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Made French Onion Soup That Rivals My Favorite Bistro
48
items You keep ordering French onion soup at restaurants because yours never tastes right. The broth is flat, the cheese doesn't pull, and the bread turns to mush. I spent two years tweaking my recipe and testing every pot, ladle, and cheese grater until m...
Sections
8
Dutch Ovens and Pots for Caramelizing Onions Low and Slow
Broiler-Safe Bowls and Crocks That Won't Crack
Gruyere and Cheeses That Actually Pull in Long Strings
Bread That Holds Up Under Broth Without Turning to Mush
Beef Broth and Stock That Tastes Like It Simmered for Hours
Knives and Tools for Slicing Onions Without Crying
Dutch Ovens and Pots for Caramelizing Onions Low and Slow
Caramelizing onions used to mean scorching them in a thin pan while I scrolled my phone. Switching to a heavy Dutch oven changed everything. The onions go golden and jammy without babysitting.
Grab this if you've ever burned onions in a flimsy stockpot. The heavy bottom distributes heat so evenly I can walk away for ten minutes and come back to perfect caramel, not charcoal.
Lodge Cast Iron 6 Quart Enameled Dutch Oven, Indigo
Use this when you're making a double batch for a dinner party. I hosted eight people last January and had enough soup to send leftovers home. The wide base means more onion surface area touching heat.
Crock-Pot Artisan 7-Quart Cast Iron Dutch Oven
Perfect for anyone who wants Lodge quality but catches it at a lower price. My sister bought this one and her French onion soup is annoyingly close to mine now.
Tramontina 6.5 Qt Enameled Round Cast Iron Dutch Oven
Snag this if you care about how your pot looks on the table. I bring mine straight from the stove to the dinner table and it photographs like something from a cookbook.
The Pioneer Woman Timeless Beauty Cast Iron 5-Quart
Try this if you prefer stainless steel over enamel. The fond that builds on the bottom of this pot makes the richest broth I've ever tasted. Deglaze with wine and just watch.
Customer reviews for Cuisinart Chef'S Classic Enameled
For anyone just starting out who doesn't want to spend a lot on their first real pot. I gave this to my college-age nephew and he texted me a photo of his first batch. Proud moment.
Mainstays, 5 Quart Pre-Seasoned Black Cast Iron Dutch
Broiler-Safe Bowls and Crocks That Won't Crack
I cracked a regular ceramic bowl under the broiler my first attempt. Soup everywhere, cheese on the oven floor. Never again. These crocks handle 500 degrees without flinching.
Keep these stocked before soup season hits. The handles make it easy to pull a bubbling, molten bowl from the oven without third-degree burns. I own six and use them all winter.
Soup Bowls with Handles, 20 oz French Onion
Grab these if you want a classic look with those tall sides that keep cheese from sliding off. The white porcelain makes that golden Gruyere crust look absolutely ridiculous in photos.
Soup Bowls with Handle, 15 Oz Ceramic French Onion
Splurge on these if you're the type who wants matching everything. I bought two in Marseille blue and now every bowl of soup feels like a special occasion instead of a Tuesday.
Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Soup Bowl, 20 oz., Marseille
Perfect for anyone feeding a crowd. I did a French onion soup bar for New Year's and these held up beautifully. Six bowls, six happy people, zero cracks under the broiler.
Bruntmor Set of 4 French Onion Soup Bowls with Lids
Use this if you want something heavier that stays hot longer. My soup was still steaming twenty minutes after I pulled it out. Great for slow eaters who hate lukewarm broth.
Staub Ceramic 4.75" Small Universal Bowl - White
Try this one if you like a more rustic, hand-thrown look. It sits wider than most crocks so you get more cheese surface area. And honestly, more cheese surface area is the whole point.
Pair Of World Market Big Stoneware Soup Crocks
Gruyere and Cheeses That Actually Pull in Long Strings
Cheap Swiss from a deli pack will melt but it won't give you those dramatic cheese pulls. I tested five different cheeses before landing on the combination that stretches, browns, and tastes nutty instead of bland.
This is the one. Slice it thick, layer it generously, and broil until it bubbles. The first time I pulled a spoon through this and got a two-foot cheese string I actually laughed out loud.
Cheese Block Great Value
Pair this with Gruyere for a milder, sweeter layer underneath. My French friend told me this combination is what her grandmother used. I stopped questioning it after the first bite.
President Imported Emmental Swiss Cheese
Keep this in the fridge for weeknight versions when you don't feel like grating a whole block. Not as complex as Gruyere but it melts beautifully and my kids prefer it.
Sargento® Swiss Sliced Cheese, 11 slices
Try this if you want something between grocery store Swiss and fancy Gruyere. It browns nicely under the broiler and has a slightly nutty flavor that doesn't disappear into the broth.
President Imported Emmental Swiss Cheese
Swap this in for a creamier, gooier melt. I did a half Gruyere, half Fontina batch last month and my husband said it was the best one I'd ever made. I wrote it down immediately.
BelGioioso Fontina Cheese Wedge 8oz
Toss a thin layer of this under the Gruyere for a sharper bite. Sounds weird for French onion soup but trust me. A chef friend suggested it and I haven't gone back.
Sharp White Cheddar Cheese Portions
Bread That Holds Up Under Broth Without Turning to Mush
Regular sandwich bread dissolves in hot broth like a wet napkin. You need something dense and crusty that soaks up liquid but still has structure when you bite into it.
Slice this about an inch thick and toast it before floating it on the soup. It soaks up broth on the bottom but stays crusty on top under the cheese. Exactly what you want.
Pepperidge Farm Shop All Bread Bakery & Bread Selection
Grab this from the bakery section and bake it right before assembling. The crust shatters when you bite through the cheese layer. My neighbor asked for my recipe and this bread was the first thing I told her about.
French Baguette: Take & Bake Twin Pack
Perfect if you're making soup tonight and need bread now. It's dense enough to hold up and cheap enough that you won't feel bad about using half a loaf for four bowls.
Marketside, Enriched French Bread, Loaf, 16 oz, Shelf Stable
Try these if you want individual rounds that fit perfectly inside a soup crock. One roll per bowl, no trimming, no waste. I discovered this shortcut by accident and it's my go-to now.
Schar Sourdough Ciabatta Rolls, Artisan Style Bread
Use this in a pinch when you're out of French bread. Toast it twice so it's almost crouton-firm. Not traditional but it works better than you'd expect. My backup plan every time.
Dave's Killer Bread® White Bread Done Right Thin Sliced
Hear me out. Tear one of these in half, toast it, and float it on the soup. The soft interior absorbs broth like a sponge and the outside crisps under the broiler. Weird but wonderful.
Sister Schubert's Dinner Yeast Rolls 13 Oz, 10 Count
Beef Broth and Stock That Tastes Like It Simmered for Hours
Watery broth ruins everything. I tried making my own stock from scratch but honestly, a really good boxed broth with a few tweaks gets me 90% of the way there on a weeknight.
This is my base every single time. It has that deep, roasted flavor that cheap broth just doesn't have. I add a splash of soy sauce and suddenly it tastes like I simmered bones all day.
EWG's Food Scores
Swap this in if Swanson is sold out. It's slightly lighter but takes seasoning really well. I reduce it by about a third before adding it to the onions and the flavor concentrates beautifully.
Kitchen Basics Stock Beef Unsalted, 32 Fl Oz
Keep a jar of this in your fridge at all times. When your broth needs more punch, one spoonful fixes everything. I've been using this for three years and my soup has never tasted thin since.
Better Than Bouillon Roasted Beef Base, Shelf-Stable 8 oz
Try this if you want a cleaner ingredient list. It's rich without being greasy and the color is this gorgeous deep amber that makes the final soup look professional.
Pacific Foods Organic Beef Bone Broth, 32 oz Carton
Grab this for a bolder, more concentrated flavor. I use it when I'm making soup for guests who like things really savory. One friend called it restaurant-quality and I just smiled.
College Inn Bold Stock, Tender Beef
Use this when you need a full 32 ounces and don't want to open two cans. The box pours cleanly and the flavor is solid. Not the fanciest option but reliable every single time.
Rachael Ray Stock-in-a-box All Natural Beef
Knives and Tools for Slicing Onions Without Crying
I used to cry so hard while slicing onions that I'd have to take breaks. A sharp knife and a few tricks cut the tears down to almost nothing. Almost.
A sharp knife crushes fewer onion cells, which means fewer tears. This one stays sharp forever and costs less than dinner for two. I've had mine for four years and it still slices paper-thin.
Victorinox Fibrox Pro Chef's Knife, 8-Inch Chef's
Grab this if you need a full set and want a dedicated paring knife for shallots alongside the chef's knife for onions. Color-coded handles mean my kids can actually help without grabbing the wrong blade.
Cuisinart, Kitchen Knife Set, 12-Piece
Use this under your onions so they don't slide around. The rubber feet grip the counter and the juice groove catches all that onion liquid. My old board was a slip-and-slide disaster.
OXO Good Grips Large Plastic Utility Cutting Board, White
Try this for perfectly uniform onion slices that caramelize evenly. Before this, half my onions were paper-thin and half were chunks. Now every slice is identical and they all hit golden at the same time.
Mueller Austria Mandoline Slicer for Kitchen
Perfect for anyone who hates knife work or gets emotional around onions. Seal the onion inside, press down, done. My mom has arthritis and this is the only reason she still makes soup.
Customer reviews for Progressive Prepworks Onion Chopper
Keep a dedicated board for onions so your fruit doesn't taste like allium the next morning. I learned this the hard way when my kids complained their apple slices tasted like soup.
GORILLA GRIP, Cutting Board, Oversized
Wine and Seasonings That Make the Broth Taste Complex
Plain broth plus onions is fine. But a splash of dry white wine and the right herbs turn fine into something you close your eyes while eating. That's the goal.
Pour half a cup into the pot after the onions caramelize. The acidity cuts through all that richness and adds a brightness you can't get any other way. Drink the rest while you wait for it to simmer.
Barefoot Cellars Pinot Grigio White Wine - 1.5L Bottle
Toss a few pinches in while the broth simmers. Thyme and onion soup are best friends. I tried making it without thyme once and it tasted like something was missing the entire time.
THYME LEAVES WHOLE 400G
Drop two of these in and fish them out before serving. They add this subtle, earthy warmth that rounds everything out. Forgetting to remove them is a choking hazard though, so set a reminder.
McCormick, Bay Leaves, 0.12 oz Bottle
Use this instead of table salt. The bigger crystals dissolve slower so you can actually taste as you go without accidentally over-salting. I ruined an entire pot once with fine salt. Never again.
Morton Kosher Salt Flakes 3 lb.
Snag this for a few dashes right at the end. It adds umami depth that makes people ask what your secret ingredient is. I never tell them. Until now, I guess.
French's Worcestershire Sauce
Start your onions in a generous knob of this. Regular butter works but this one has a richer, almost nutty flavor that gives the onions a head start on tasting incredible. Worth every penny.
Kerrygold Grass-Fed Salted Pure Irish Butter, 8 oz
Ladles, Graters, and Finishing Tools
The small stuff matters more than you think. A bad ladle splashes broth everywhere and a dull grater turns cheese into crumbles instead of those long shreds that melt into strings.
This ladle pours clean without dribbling down the side. Sounds minor until you've mopped up broth puddles from your counter for the tenth time. The hook on the handle rests on the pot rim perfectly.
OXO Good Grips Brushed Stainless Steel Ladle
Use this for finely grating a little Gruyere right on top after broiling. It melts instantly and adds one more layer of cheese flavor. My secret finishing move that took me way too long to figure out.
Microplane Premium Classic Zester Grater - White
Grab this for shredding the main cheese layer. The large holes give you those thick shreds that melt into gooey, stretchy strings instead of disappearing into the broth. Big shreds, big pulls.
KitchenAid Gourmet Box Grater with Detachable
Keep one of these by the stove for stirring onions. Metal scrapes enamel and silicone feels weird. Wood is the right tool here. These have a comfortable grip for the 45 minutes of occasional stirring.
OXO Good Grips 3‑Piece Wooden Utensil Set
Try this for scraping up all the caramelized bits stuck to the bottom of the pot. Those brown bits are pure flavor and leaving them behind is basically throwing away the best part of the soup.
Farberware Professional Silicone Kitchen Spatula Set
Wear these when pulling 500-degree crocks from under the broiler. I grabbed a bowl with a thin towel once and felt the heat through immediately. These are thick, long, and actually protective. Don't skip this.
How should I wash mini oven mitts with silicone grips?