Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Replaced Boxed Mac and Cheese and My Kids Never Asked Back
35
items If your family demolishes a box of neon orange mac and cheese every week and you secretly feel guilty about it, this is everything I use to make the from-scratch version that actually converted my household. Took me about six failed batches to nail i...
Sections
7
The Cheese Trio That Makes It Taste Like a Restaurant
Pasta Shapes That Actually Hold the Sauce
Building the Sauce Without It Breaking on You
The Crunchy Topping That Seals the Deal
Tools That Actually Make the Process Easier
Extras That Take It From Good to Ridiculous
The Cheese Trio That Makes It Taste Like a Restaurant
I spent way too long using just cheddar and wondering why it tasted flat. The day I started blending three cheeses together, my husband put his fork down and said ‘what did you do differently.’ That was the turning point.
Grab this for the backbone of the whole dish. Before I switched to Tillamook, my mac tasted like cafeteria food. This one melts smooth and has actual bite. Perfect for anyone who's been settling for pre-shredded bags.
Tillamook Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese Block 2 lb aged 15
Toss a few ounces of this in and the sauce gets this creamy, slightly nutty thing going on. I never knew fontina existed until a friend who worked in catering told me. Now I can't make a batch without it.
Belgioioso Fontina Cheese Wedge, 5OZ, 12 Pack
Use this if your mac always tastes one-dimensional. The smokiness hits different when it melts into the other two cheeses. My neighbor literally texted me at 10pm asking what brand I used after dinner at our place.
Customer reviews for Dutchmark Smoked Gouda Cheese 7
Snag one of these and stir a couple tablespoons into your cheese sauce right at the end. It makes the texture almost velvety. For anyone whose sauce keeps breaking or getting grainy, this is the fix nobody talks about.
Great Value Cream Cheese Brick, 8 oz Block, 2 Pack
Keep this on hand for the breadcrumb topping. I sprinkle it on before broiling and it gets this golden crust that makes people think you ordered from somewhere. Stock up because you'll start putting it on everything.
Great Value Parmesan Finely Shredded Cheese, 6 oz Bag
Pasta Shapes That Actually Hold the Sauce
Elbow macaroni is fine but it doesn't grab sauce the way other shapes do. I switched shapes once on a whim and the leftover sauce at the bottom of the dish basically disappeared. Never went back.
Try this corkscrew shape and watch how much cheese gets trapped in every twist. My kids used to leave puddles of sauce on their plates with elbows. With cavatappi, they scrape the bowl clean.
Barilla, Cellentani Pasta, 16 oz, Kosher Certified
Use rigatoni when you want big, hearty bites that stand up to a thick sauce. For anyone making mac and cheese for a crowd or a potluck, this is the shape that looks impressive without extra effort.
De Cecco Rigatoni no.24 Pasta, 16 oz
Keep these around for the nights when you want classic comfort food vibes. The large size holds more sauce than the skinny elbows. My go-to when I'm feeding just the family on a Wednesday.
Great Value Elbows, 16 oz
Grab a box of these if you like your mac and cheese to have some texture. The ridges and curves catch cheese in places you didn't know pasta could. I made this for my sister and she asked me three times what shape it was.
Barilla, Cellentani Pasta, 16 oz, Kosher Certified
Swap in shells when you want every single bite to be a little cheese cup. For the person who always complains the cheese ratio isn't right, shells solve that problem permanently. Wish I'd figured this out years ago.
Mueller's Vegan Large Sea Shells Pasta
Building the Sauce Without It Breaking on You
My cheese sauce used to split every third attempt and I'd stand there whisking furiously, cursing at the stove. These are the ingredients that finally made it foolproof.
Start your roux with this and you'll notice the difference before you even add cheese. Regular butter works but Kerrygold has this richness that makes the base taste like you know what you're doing. Worth every penny.
Kerrygold Grass-Fed Pure Irish Unsalted Butter, 8 Oz
Keep this stocked for your roux. Two tablespoons is all it takes. If your sauce has ever been thin and soupy, you probably skipped this step. Learned that the hard way my first three tries.
Gold Medal All Purpose Flour, Baking Flour, 5 lb Bag
Use whole milk, not 2%. I tried cutting corners with skim once and the sauce tasted like disappointment. Whole milk gives you that creamy body. For anyone on the fence, just trust me on this one.
Great Value Whole Vitamin D Milk, Gallon
Toss half a teaspoon into your sauce and it won't taste like mustard, it just makes the cheese pop. My mom taught me this trick and I thought she was messing with me until I tried it. Total difference.
McCormick Kosher Ground Mustard, 1.75 oz Bottle
Switch from black pepper to white pepper in cheese sauce. It blends in without those dark specks and has a slightly different heat. For anyone whose kids pick out ‘the black dots,’ this solves that argument forever.
McCormick, Ground White Pepper (Pack of 6)
The Crunchy Topping That Seals the Deal
Baked mac and cheese without a crispy top is just pasta in sauce. I spent a while figuring out the right crunch-to-cheese ratio. These are the things that give it that golden crust people fight over.
Grab these for a quick, reliable crunch layer. Mix them with melted butter and parmesan, spread on top, and broil for three minutes. My brother-in-law now judges all mac and cheese by whether it has this topping.
4C Plain Bread Crumbs, 15 oz Canister
Try panko when you want a lighter, crispier texture than regular breadcrumbs. They puff up under the broiler and get this airy crunch. For anyone who thinks their baked mac looks boring on top, panko fixes that instantly.
Great Value Plain Panko Bread Crumbs, 8 oz
Crush a sleeve of these into your topping mix and prepare for people to lose their minds. The buttery flavor adds something breadcrumbs can't. I started doing this after Thanksgiving one year and now it's non-negotiable.
Are Ritz Crackers Healthy? What a Dietitian Wants You
Use melted unsalted butter to bind your crumb topping. Salted butter made my crust too salty the first time. For anyone who over-seasons accidentally, unsalted gives you control. Drizzle it over the crumbs before broiling.
Great Value Sweet Cream Unsalted Butter, 16 oz, 4 Sticks
Toss a generous handful into your breadcrumb mixture. It browns up fast and adds a salty, sharp bite to every crunchy piece. Keep this in the fridge because you'll reach for it every time you bake anything with a topping.
Kraft Natural Grated Parmesan Cheese Shaker, 8 oz Bottle
Tools That Actually Make the Process Easier
I used to make this in the wrong pots with the wrong whisks and wondered why it took forever and came out lumpy. These are the specific things that cut my prep time and frustration in half.
Use a saucepan this size for the cheese sauce. Anything smaller and you're splattering cheese everywhere. Anything bigger and the roux spreads too thin. I went through two wrong pans before landing on this one.
Farberware, Saucepan, 3qt, Stainless Steel with Lid
Grab a proper whisk and stop stirring your roux with a spoon. A whisk breaks up lumps before they form. For anyone whose sauce always has weird clumps in it, this is the cheapest fix you'll ever make.
Durable stainless steel wire whip for select KitchenAid® tilt-head stand mixers
Bake your mac in this and it heats evenly without burning the edges. I used a metal pan for years and the corners always got dry and crusty in a bad way. Glass changed everything. It also looks nice enough to bring straight to the table.
Pyrex Deep 9" x 13" Bakeware Dish with Sage Lid
Keep a set of these near the stove. Eyeballing flour and milk ratios is how cheese sauce goes wrong. I measured properly exactly once, realized how off my guesses had been, and never went back to winging it.
Spring Chef, Stainless Steel Measuring Cups
Use the large holes to shred your own cheese blocks. Pre-shredded bags have anti-caking powder that makes sauce gritty. Takes five extra minutes but the texture difference is so obvious you'll be annoyed nobody told you sooner.
OXO Good Grips Box Grater
Extras That Take It From Good to Ridiculous
Once I nailed the base recipe, I started experimenting with add-ins. Some were disasters. These are the ones that made the cut and now rotate through our weekly dinners depending on everyone's mood.
Toss a handful on top right after it comes out of the oven. The salty crunch with the creamy cheese is absurd. For anyone feeding teenagers, bacon bits are the difference between 'it's fine' and ‘can you make this again tomorrow.’
Hormel, Real Bacon Bits, 3 oz Plastic Jar, Salad Topping
Drizzle this on your portion if you like a little kick. It cuts through the richness without overpowering the cheese. My wife puts it on hers, the kids don't, everybody's happy. Keep a bottle in the fridge at all times.
Frank's RedHot, Hot Sauce, 23 fl oz, Cayenne Pepper
Stir a small squeeze into the sauce while it's still on the stove. Sounds weird but it brightens everything up. A chef friend told me this and I argued with him for ten minutes before trying it. He was right.
French's, Classic Yellow Mustard, 400 ml
Sneak these in if you want to feel slightly less guilty about eating a pound of cheese. Steam them, chop them small, fold them in. For parents trying to get vegetables into mac and cheese without a revolt, small pieces are the key.
Great Value Frozen Broccoli Florets Steamable Bag, 12 oz
Pour a drained can into the sauce for a Southwestern twist. The mild heat and tomato acidity balance out all that cheese. Perfect for the nights when regular mac feels too heavy and you want something with a little attitude.
RO*TEL Fire Roasted Diced Tomatoes and Green Chilies
Storing and Reheating Without Ruining It
Leftover mac and cheese is either amazing or a dried-out brick. I threw away so many sad containers before figuring out how to store and reheat it properly. These help.
Portion leftovers into these right after dinner. The seal is actually airtight so your mac doesn't dry out overnight. For anyone who's opened a container the next day to find a cheese fossil, these are the upgrade you need.
Rubbermaid Brilliance 2-Pack | Food storage containers for
Cover your baking dish tightly with foil when reheating in the oven. It traps steam and keeps everything moist. I used to reheat uncovered and the top turned into a cheese cracker. Not the good kind.
REYNOLDS WRAP, Aluminum Foil, Heavy Duty
Use this to wrap individual portions before freezing. It sticks to itself and keeps air out better than regular plastic wrap. For anyone who meal preps mac and cheese for the week, this keeps each serving tasting fresh.
The Difference Between Glad Press'n Seal and Glad ClingWrap
Splash a little milk into your leftover mac before microwaving. The sauce re-emulsifies and gets creamy again instead of clumping up. My roommate in college taught me this and it genuinely changed how I think about leftovers.
Great Value Whole Vitamin D Milk, Gallon
Keep a small baking dish for reheating single servings in the oven. Microwaving works but oven reheating brings back the crispy top. For the person who refuses to eat soggy leftovers, ten minutes at 350 in this dish solves it.
Nordicware Nonstick Compact Ovenware 5 Pc Bake Set