Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Restaurants in Town - New Paltz, NY
16
items My favorite places to eat in New Paltz, NY as a local. Located approximately 1.5 hours north of New York City
Map
Sections
4
Coffee and More
Fancier
Casual/Pub Food
Unique New Paltz
Coffee and More
While fairly new Underground has become very popular for their coffee bar feel. The all day breakfast is great but don’t miss out on all the flavor in the lunch menu! The outdoor patio is great for summer and inside has a perfect moody coffee house f...
Underground Coffee and Ales
Grab and go coffee, pastries and a small kitchen menu this is one of my favorite weekend spots. There is outdoor seating in front and back perfect for people watching. The kitchen closes daily at 1. Grab a coffee before exploring the rest of Water St...
Mudd Puddle Coffee Roasters
The Bakery is a New Paltz classic. I have been coming here since I was a kid for sweet treats! Now I enjoy the lattes as well.
The Bakery
Fancier
Upscale jazz bar with great food and even better vibes! There are outdoor fire pits and blankets available on the back porch as well. Great venue to enjoy a band and a cocktail
The Lemon Squeeze: Home
Incredibly charming Irish pub just outside of the main area of New Paltz, NY. Exceptional food and service. If Garvin is in the house, he will be sure to treat you like family
Garvan's Gastropub
A cute French restaurant. Charming inside and out. A perfect place for a celebration1
Runa Bistro
Casual/Pub Food
Authentic food for a great price! The chicken enchiladas are my favorite, but you can’t go wrong with tacos. Split a pitcher of margs with your friends for the perfect start to any evening.
Los Jalapeños New Paltz
This is a New Paltz classic. Traditional pub food and a club like experience after hours on weekends. The new england clam chowder is the best I have ever had
P&G’s
While fairly new, this has quickly become a favorite. Casual and lively atmosphere with great food! In the warmer weather, the patio is one of the best in town.
Sideshow Kitchen & Bar
One of my favorites. Lola's is casual and perfect for a first date. The chicken waldorf salad is my favorite
Lola's Cafe
I love Main Course! I always order a build your own salad, but they have great menu and take away items to. This restaurant very clearly captures the New Paltz vibe
Main Course Restaurant + Market
Very cute spot in Water Street market. I order the bird and enjoy the people watching in the warmer months
Grazery
Owned by the same people as Garvan's, Maggie Mae's is a casual dinning location with beautiful views of the New Paltz Golf Course.
Maggie Mae's
Unique New Paltz
A New Paltz classic with good food and good vibes! Live music and drag shows on the weekends, and a pool hall attached this is the place to be
Bacchus Restaurant, Brewery & Billiards
B Side has my favorite brunch in town. They serve breakfast all day and grill items. There is a funky vibe inside that perfectly encapsulates New Paltz
B-Side Grill
Incredible views at this one of a kind restaurant. Serving Cajun classics with a twist, the patio view is breathtaking. There is limited seating indoors so be sure to call and make a reservation!
The Parish