Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Mascara Wars: Drugstore Darlings vs Luxury Legends

Purple Star emoji 42 items
Ready for the ultimate lash battle? 👁️✨ We’re putting affordable drugstore mascaras head-to-head with luxe, high-end legends to see which formulas truly deliver on length, volume, and staying power. Will the budget-friendly picks surprise you, or do...
Sections
8
 
 
 
 
 
 

Low End- Length

Affordable mascaras that lengthen and define lashes for a natural, fluttery look without the high price.

 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Top drugstore pick
L'Oreal Paris Telescopic Lengthening Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
3 Bucks! Super Cheap
Mascara - Waterproof, Lengthening & Volumizing
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Flutter‑worthy results
Shop Black | Lengthening Mascara by ColourPop®
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Hidden gem
Lash Stiletto® Ultimate Length Washable Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Dramatic length and separation
Lash Princess False Lash Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Great lift and defined appearance
Revlon Super Length Mascara, Blackest Black
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Rubber bristles
Lash Blast Volume Mascara

Low End - Volume

Budget-friendly mascaras that boost lash fullness and thickness for bold, noticeable volume without splurging.

 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Builds volume without clumping
L'Oreal Voluminous Mascara Review // The Drugstore Mascara Pros Love
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
A viral hit that offers both length and volume
Lash Sensational Sky High® Washable Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Frequently called a dupe for high-end forms
L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Hourglass silicone brush for bold volume
Lash It Loud Volumizing Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Multi-tasking formula
Highly Rated Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Dramatic volume
So Fierce Big Bad Lash Mascara

Low End- Waterproof

Affordable mascaras that resist smudging and stay put through sweat, tears, and humidity without breaking the bank.

 
Anna Reiss profile picture
A cult favorite for bold, falsie-like lashes
lash princess false lash effect mascara waterproof
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
TikTok-famed mascara
Lash Sensational Sky High® Waterproof Mascara Makeup
placeholder
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
A super budget-friendly option
Mega Length Waterproof Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Stands up well to moisture
Worth the Hype Waterproof Mascara | NYX Professional Makeup
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Waterproof!
L'Oreal Paris Telescopic Waterproof Mascara

Low End- Fiber

Budget-friendly mascaras with tiny fibers that add extra length and volume for a fuller lash look without the high price.

 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Stays put with minimal fallout
Illegal Length Fiber Extension Washable Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Noticeable length and a nice definition for the price
Fiber Lash Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Thickening fiber stretch
9 Colors 3d Fiber Mascara

High End - Length

Luxurious formulas that deliver dramatic, sky-high lash length with rich pigments and long-lasting wear.

 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Creating a faux‑extension effect
is the hourglass tubing mascara really worth it? im really sick of washing ...
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
A clean-beauty favorite
Limitless Lash Mascara - Best Clean Lengthening ...
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Precise coating
Lash Idôle Lash Lift Mascara - Lifting & Volumizing - Lancôme
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Long lashes with minimal fallout
LE VOLUME DE CHANEL Mascara 10 - Noir
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
A red‑carpet staple
Dior Mascaras - Luxury Lash Curling, Defining, Plumping, Priming
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
A high-glamour choice
Vast Lash Mascara

High End - Volume

Premium mascaras that deliver intense, full-bodied volume with smooth application and long-lasting impact.

 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Lightweight and weightless
Lash Slick
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Cross‑conic wand
L'Oreal Paris Paradise Big Deal Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Thickening formula
Voluminous Original Washable Mascara - L'Oréal Paris
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Ideal for those with sensitive eyes
Lash Blast Clean Volume Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Praised by makeup artists
On The Rise Volume Liftscara | NYX Professional Makeup

High End- Fiber

Sophisticated mascaras infused with lengthening fibers for dramatic lash extension and lightweight, buildable volume.

 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Extend each lash like mini extensions.
PRO Plus Fiber Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
93% of users reported extreme instant volume
MAXIMIST® Phyto-Fiber Volumizing Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Delivers tube-like lash separation
mascara volume effet faux cils - YSL Beauty
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Intense volume plus lash conditioning
Vegan KUSH Mascara for High Volume Lashes
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Plush, fiber-infused formula for serious volume delivery
GIVENCHY NOIR COUTURE VOLUME MASCARA #1 BLACK TAFFETA 8G / ...

High End- Waterproof

Luxurious, long-wearing formulas that deliver smudge-proof, water-resistant lashes with effortless elegance and all-day hold.

 
Anna Reiss profile picture
A beloved runway staple that thickens
Diorshow Lash Extension Volume Waterproof Mascara
placeholder
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Long-wear favorite.
BADgal BANG! Waterproof Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Hydrating and voluminous
Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Adds intense volume and thickness
Lash Clash Extreme Volume Waterproof Mascara
 
Anna Reiss profile picture
Precise wand and conditioning white tea extract
Lash Idôle 24H Waterproof Mascara Glossy Black – Lancôme