Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Found Lip Liners That Replace Lipstick Completely
20
items Spending $30 on lipstick only to have it feather, fade, or look nothing like the tube is a special kind of frustrating. If you've got a drawer full of lip products that never quite match what you pictured, this is the lineup I landed on after years o...
Sections
5
Everyday Nude Lip Liners That Actually Match Real Skin Tones
Deep Berry and Mauve Lip Liners for Date Nights
Warm Brown Lip Liners That Work as Full Coverage Color
Pink and Rose Lip Liners for Quick No-Mirror Application
Clear and Universal Lip Liners to Prevent Feathering
Everyday Nude Lip Liners That Actually Match Real Skin Tones
Finding a nude that doesn't make you look washed out or weirdly concealer-lipped took me an embarrassing number of tries. These four finally nailed it.
Grab this if every nude lip liner you've tried pulls too pink or too brown. Wore it to three back-to-back Zoom meetings and a coworker asked what lipstick I had on. It's just liner. That's it.
NYX Professional Makeup, Slim Lip Pencil
Use this on days when you want your lips to look polished but not like you tried. Survived a four-hour brunch with mimosas and only needed one touch-up. Great for anyone who hates reapplying.
Revlon ColorStay Longwear Lip Liner Pencil
Perfect for darker skin tones that get ghostly with most nude liners. My friend grabbed one after seeing mine and texted me ‘WHERE HAS THIS BEEN’ the same night.
Customer reviews for Milani Color Statement Lip Liner
Snag this if you're on a tight budget but still want clean lip edges. The built-in blending brush actually works, which shocked me. Fill in your whole lip and skip the lipstick entirely.
e.l.f. Cream Glide Lip Liner, Mauve Aside, 0.03oz
Deep Berry and Mauve Lip Liners for Date Nights
Before these, my go-to move was dark lipstick that bled everywhere by the second drink. Liners solved the bleeding problem and the color payoff is unreal.
Pair this with literally nothing else. The matte finish looks intentional, not dry. Wore it to a wedding last fall and three people asked for the shade name before the ceremony even started.
NYX Professional Makeup Suede Matte Lip Liner
Try this when you want that deep 90s lip without looking like a costume. Stays put through dinner, doesn't transfer onto wine glasses, and the price point means you won't cry if you lose it in your bag.
Revlon ColorStay Longwear Lip Liner Pencil, 665 Plum, 0.01 oz
Keep this in your clutch for nights out. Applied it in an Uber with no mirror once and it still looked sharp. For anyone who wants bold color but zero maintenance.
Maybelline Color Sensational Shaping Lip Liner, Red
Toss out whatever expensive berry liner disappointed you last. This $1 pencil outperformed a $24 one I bought at a department store. Not exaggerating, the staying power is ridiculous.
Wet n Wild Color Icon Lip Liner, Brandy Wine
Warm Brown Lip Liners That Work as Full Coverage Color
Brown lip liner had a chokehold on the 90s and honestly it was right. Getting the exact warm tone without going muddy was the hard part.
Use this if you want that soft brown-pink your lips naturally wish they were. Fills in smoothly without tugging. Add a dab of clear gloss and people will think you spent 20 minutes on your lips.
NYX Professional Makeup, Slim Lip Pencil
Grab this warm cinnamon shade before fall hits. Looked incredible with a simple white tee and gold hoops. For anyone who wants the brown lip trend without looking like they're trying too hard.
Revlon, Longwear Lip Liner Pencil, 635 Sienna, 0.01 oz
Switch to this if you've been buying high-end brown liners and feeling ripped off. Creamy formula, zero skipping, and it sharpens clean every time. My most-replaced pencil in the last two years.
Brown University
Ditch that orangey brown liner that never blended right. This one leans warm without crossing into terracotta territory. Wore it on a hike date and it lasted through trail mix and two water bottles.
Jordana Easyliner Lips 25 Rose Crh by Jordana Cosmetics
Pink and Rose Lip Liners for Quick No-Mirror Application
Some mornings I have 45 seconds for lips. These go on clean even when I'm applying them at a red light. Not proud of it, but the results speak for themselves.
Try this dusty rose if every pink liner you own is too Barbie. Blends into a natural flush that works on rushed mornings. Tossed my pink lipstick collection after finding this, no regrets.
NYX Professional Makeup, Slim Lip Pencil
Keep one of these at your desk and one in your car. The slight shimmer catches light without looking frosty. For anyone who wants a put-together lip in under 30 seconds flat.
Rimmel, Lasting Finish 1000 Kisses Lip Liner, Tiramisu
Swap this in when you want color that reads cheerful, not childish. Wore it to a baby shower and it photographed perfectly in every single picture. Stayed on through cake, which is the real test.
Milani Color Statement Lip Liner, Pretty Pink, Long-Wearing
Get this muted pink if bright pinks wash you out. The formula doesn't dry your lips the way most matte liners do. Survived a 10-hour workday without flaking, and I talk a lot.
COVERGIRL Exhibitionist Lip Liner, 215 Rosewood
Clear and Universal Lip Liners to Prevent Feathering
Learned this trick embarrassingly late. A clear or universal liner around any color keeps everything inside the lines. Would have saved me years of lipstick bleeding into my foundation.
Use this around any bold color to keep it locked in place. Drew it just outside my lip line before a plum liner and the edges stayed razor sharp for six hours. Wish someone told me about this sooner.
NYX Professional Makeup, Slim Lip Pencil
Grab this universal pink-nude for when you can't decide on a shade. Works under literally every lip color I own. It's the only liner I've hit pan on twice, which says everything.
Rimmel, Exaggerate Full Colour Lip Liner
Try the retractable tip if you hate sharpening pencils. This warm neutral acts like an invisible fence for lipstick. Applied it before a red lip at New Year's and not a single smudge by midnight.
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Coffee, 0.006 oz
Snag this gel formula if regular pencil liners skip on your lips. Glides on like butter and sets in place within a minute. For anyone whose lipstick migrates north into fine lines around the mouth.
wet n wild Lip Liner Gone Burgundy Perfect Pout Matte Gel