Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Tried 35 Waterproof Eyeliners So You Don't Have To, These Survived
35
items Raccoon eyes at the pool, liner sliding down your face by 2pm, that crusty smudge after a single eye rub. If you've cycled through a dozen “waterproof” liners that lied to your face, I spent an entire summer testing these in pools, saunas, and Housto...
Sections
7
Waterproof Pencil Eyeliners That Actually Lock In
Smudge-Proof Liquid Liners for Precise Wings
Gel Pot Eyeliners That Won't Dry Out Fast
Waterproof Eyeliners for Sensitive or Watery Eyes
Long-Wear Colored Eyeliners That Don't Fade
Setting Products That Make Any Liner More Waterproof
Waterproof Pencil Eyeliners That Actually Lock In
Pencil liners were always my weakness because they'd smear within an hour. These five stayed sharp through a full beach day and a sweaty outdoor wedding.
Grab this if you're tired of sharpening every five minutes. Applied it before a pool party at noon and it was still crisp at sunset. For anyone who wants pencil ease without the smudge drama.
NYX Professional Makeup, Epic Wear Liner Sticks
Keep one of these in every bag you own. Drew a wing with it before a rainy concert and it looked the same six hours later. Perfect for people who touch their eyes constantly.
Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner Pencil matic Waterproof NEW
Swap out whatever dried-up pencil you're using right now. This glides on creamy then sets like cement. Wore it through a spin class and my towel came away clean.
Maybelline Tattoo Studio Gel Pencil
Use this when you need your waterline lined and staying that way. Most pencils disappear from my waterline in twenty minutes. This one held through allergy season tears.
L'Oreal Paris Infallible Pro Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner
Try this if gel intimidates you but pencils keep failing. It has that smooth gel feel in pencil form. Survived a crying-at-a-wedding situation without a single streak on my cheeks.
Physicians Formula Eye Booster™ Lash 2-in-1 Boosting
Smudge-Proof Liquid Liners for Precise Wings
Nothing ruins a morning faster than redoing a wing three times because the formula feathered. These dried fast and stayed razor sharp all day.
Snag this before your next vacation. The felt tip is thin enough for a baby wing and it survived snorkeling in Mexico. Ideal for beginners who want a forgiving tip.
Maybelline Liquid Eyeliner for Precise Eye Makeup
Pair this with a steady hand and you'll get the sharpest wing of your life. Wore it through a 14-hour travel day including a nap on the plane. Zero transfer on my pillow.
NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner
Get this if you want drugstore price with high-end staying power. Applied it at 6am for a music festival and it was still perfect when I finally washed my face at midnight.
e.l.f. Cosmetics Intense Ink Eyeliner Blackest Black
Bring this one back into your rotation if you wrote it off years ago. The reformulated version is seriously budge-proof. Tested it in a steam room and it didn't flinch.
ColorStay™ Liquid Eyeliner
Toss a couple in your cart because at this price you can stash them everywhere. The tip stays pointed for weeks and the formula held through a humid July barbecue without feathering once.
essence Stay & Play Gel Eyeliner Pencil, 03 Silky Nude
Gel Pot Eyeliners That Won't Dry Out Fast
I used to avoid gel pots because they'd turn into hockey pucks after two weeks. These stayed usable for months and the payoff was worth the extra step of grabbing a brush.
Use this with a thin angled brush and you'll wonder why you ever bothered with anything else. It set in about ten seconds and survived a full day at a water park with my kids.
Maybelline, EyeStudio Lasting Drama Gel Liner, Brown
Switch to this if gel pots feel like too much work. It gives you that intense gel look in a twist-up format. Stayed on my lids through a double shift at work without creasing.
L.A. Girl Glide Eye .. Liner Pencil 363 Royal .. Blue
Grab the darkest shade for a smoked-out liner look that refuses to move. Wore it to a friend's outdoor pool party and came home with it still intact. Great for people who like a softer line.
e.l.f. Lock on Liner and Brow Cream, Light Brown, 0.19 oz
Keep this in your gym bag. Applied it before a hot yoga class just to test it, and honestly it looked better after than before. The warmth almost melted it into a smoother line.
Milani Stay Put Waterproof Eye Liner Pencil
Try this if every liner you've owned starts flaking by lunchtime. It dries matte and flat, no peeling or crumbling. Survived a full day of ugly-crying during a movie marathon.
Wet n Wild MegaLiner, Lightweight Liquid Eyeliner, Black
Waterproof Eyeliners for Sensitive or Watery Eyes
My left eye waters nonstop, especially in wind or cold air. Most liners surrender immediately. These actually stayed on through tearing, rubbing, and allergy season.
Use this if your eyes react to everything. Hypoallergenic and it didn't budge when my allergies had me dabbing tissues at my eyes every ten minutes last spring.
Almay All-Day Intense Gel Eyeliner 140 Deep Chestnut
Bring this along if contacts make your eyes water constantly. Soft enough to line the waterline without irritation, and it held through an eight-hour shift under fluorescent lights.
Neutrogena Smokey Kohl Water-Resistant Eyeliner, Jet Black
Snag this for a gentle formula that doesn't sting watery eyes. Drew a thin line before a windy rooftop dinner and it was still there when I checked three hours later.
Physicians Formula Eye Definer Felt Tip Eyeliner
Swap your current pencil for this if harsh formulas make your lids itch. The jojoba oil keeps it comfortable and it lasted through a tearful goodbye at the airport without a smear.
Burts Bees Nourishing Eyeliner, Soft Black - 0.04 Ounce
Get the self-sharpening tip version and save yourself the hassle. Wore it through a windy fall hike where my eyes were streaming the whole time. Came back looking like I just applied it.
CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner: Midnight Blue #220
Long-Wear Colored Eyeliners That Don't Fade
Black gets boring sometimes. I wanted color that would actually last instead of fading into a weird ghost line by mid-afternoon. These delivered real pigment that stayed vivid.
Grab the sapphire blue before your next festival. I wore it poolside for four hours and the color looked freshly applied when I finally toweled off. For anyone bored of black.
NYX Vivid Brights Liner - Petal
Try the burgundy shade if you want something different but still wearable for work. Applied it on a rainy Monday morning and it was still glossy and sharp at happy hour.
Revlon SO FIERCE Vinyl Eyeliner, 865 Powerful Plum 01oz
Use this when you want your eyes to pop in photos. The green shade survived a sweaty outdoor birthday party and three rounds of hugs from people who kept saying my eyes looked amazing.
L.A. Girls Shockwave Neon Liner, Vivid
Pair the navy shade with neutral eyeshadow for a subtle twist. Held up through a beach bonfire where smoke and salt air usually destroy everything on my face within an hour.
Milani Supreme Kohl Kajal Eyeliner Pencil
Toss the olive shade in your bag for an everyday color that isn't boring. Tested it through a rainstorm when I forgot my umbrella and it stayed exactly where I put it.
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner
Setting Products That Make Any Liner More Waterproof
Sometimes your favorite liner needs backup. These setting sprays and primers turned my regular liners into waterproof warriors, which saved me from replacing products I already loved.
Spritz this over your finished eye look and let it dry for thirty seconds. Turned my non-waterproof liner into something that survived a humid July cookout. Stock up before summer hits.
NYX Professional Makeup Matte Finish Setting Spray
Keep this at arm's reach when you're done with your makeup. Two sprays and my liner held through a sweaty dance floor until 2am. Wish I'd found this before I ruined my look at prom.
Make It Last Original - Natural Finish Setting Spray
Dab a tiny bit on your lids before lining. It gives the liner something to grip onto and I noticed a huge difference in how long my wings lasted during outdoor events.
e.l.f. Cosmetics Power Grip Primer
Use this as a mid-day refresh when your liner starts looking tired. A quick mist brought everything back to life during a long outdoor graduation ceremony in direct sunlight.
Hard Candy Sheer Envy Perfecting Primer, Smoothing
Grab this budget option if you want setting spray performance without spending much. Locked my liner down through a pool day where I fully submerged my face multiple times. Still there.
wet n wild Photo Focus Natural Finish Setting Spray
Makeup Removers That Actually Get Waterproof Liner Off
The flip side of great waterproof liner is that it fights you at the end of the night. I was scrubbing my eyes raw until I found removers that dissolved everything without a battle.
Soak a cotton pad, press it on your closed eye for five seconds, and the liner slides right off. No rubbing, no redness. Saved my under-eye area from looking like I'd been in a fight.
Garnier, SkinActive Micellar Cleansing Water, 13.5 fl oz
Keep this on your nightstand so you never fall asleep with liner on again. One swipe and even the most stubborn gel liner dissolved. Perfect for lazy nights when double cleansing sounds exhausting.
Neutrogena Oil Free Eye Makeup Remover 112ml
Bring this into your routine if micellar water has failed you before. It handled every waterproof liner on this list without stinging. Worth every penny for contact lens wearers.
SENSIBIO H2O 100ML (Package Random Delivery)
Switch to this if your current remover leaves a greasy film. It breaks down waterproof formulas cleanly and my eyes never felt irritated after. Found it after three duds in a row.
Simple Kind to Skin Eye Makeup Remover Dual Effect 3.38
Try the old-school method your grandma swore by. Massage a small amount over your eyes and waterproof liner melts off like nothing. Bonus, your skin feels soft instead of stripped and tight afterward.
POND'S, Cold Cream Cleanser, 6.1 oz