Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Tried 30 Clean Mascaras and These Actually Gave Me Volume
42
items Sensitive eyes, contact lenses, and a low tolerance for anything that smells like a department store perfume counter. That was me, standing in the beauty aisle squinting at ingredient lists for the hundredth time. If you've ever had a mascara make yo...
Sections
6
Clean Mascaras That Actually Build Volume
Fragrance-Free Eye Primers and Bases
Sensitive-Eye Friendly Eyeliners
Gentle Eye Makeup Removers That Actually Work
Under-Eye Care for Mascara-Weary Skin
Setting Sprays and Finishing Touches for Sensitive Skin
Clean Mascaras That Actually Build Volume
Every clean mascara I tried before these gave me the look of someone who forgot to finish getting ready. These ones layer without clumping and don't contain the stuff that makes my eyes revolt.
Grab this if your lashes are short and stubborn. Mine went from invisible to ‘wait, are those extensions?’ after two coats. Zero fragrance, zero irritation.
Before Dawn Limitless Lash Lengthening Mascara - ILIA
Use this on days you want drama without the crunchy feeling. My lashes stayed soft enough to touch and didn't flake onto my cheeks by 3pm. Perfect for contact lens wearers.
Kosas The Big Clean Longwear Volumizing Lash Care
Switched to this from a conventional mascara and honestly couldn't tell the difference in volume. The brush grabs every tiny lash. Wore it to a wedding and got compliments at hour nine.
Rare Beauty Perfect Strokes Universal Volumizing Mascara
Try this if you want a no-fuss everyday mascara that doesn't try too hard. One coat for Monday morning, two coats for Friday night. Removes easily without scrubbing your eyes raw.
Saie Mascara 101 with Beeswax
Keep this in your bag for the person who reacts to literally everything. Formulated for sensitive skin and it actually performs. My eyes didn't water once, which felt like a miracle.
Tower 28 MakeWaves Lengthening Mascara
Splurge on this when you're tired of replacing cheap mascaras every six weeks. The formula stays wet longer so you can build without rushing. Feels like nothing on your lashes.
WESTMAN ATELIER Eye Love You Mascara, Clean Black
Toss your waterproof mascara and get this instead. It holds through sweat and humidity but slides off with warm water. Found this right before a beach vacation and it saved me from raccoon eyes.
MERIT Clean Lash Lengthening Tubing Mascara
Fragrance-Free Eye Primers and Bases
Mascara was only half my problem. My eyeshadow was creasing by lunch and most primers had fragrance that made my eyelids puffy. These solved both issues.
Pair this with any shadow and watch it stay put through a 12-hour shift. My oily lids used to eat eyeshadow for breakfast. Not anymore.
Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Eye Primer w/ Hyaluronic Acid
Dab a tiny bit on each lid before anything else. Bought my first tube three years ago and haven't gone a day without it. Keeps shadow from settling into creases.
PHOTO FINISH LID PRIMER LIGHT
Get the original formula if you have normal to dry lids. It's been around forever for a reason. One tube lasts about five months for me, so the price per use is basically nothing.
Urban Decay Mini Original Eyeshadow Primer Potion
Try this if other primers feel heavy or sticky. Goes on like a thin moisturizer and dries down fast. My shadow looked freshly applied after a red-eye flight.
Always an Optimist Weightless Eye Primer
Use this specifically if you have deep skin tones. It doesn't leave a white cast and actually grips pigment. Discovered it after years of shadows looking ashy on me.
NARS Pro-Prime Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base
Bring this along for midday touch-ups around the eye area. Works on the T-zone too. Threw it in my purse on a humid August day and it literally rescued my whole face.
Lancome Prep & Matte Refreshing Mattifying
Swap to this from drugstore primers if you've been disappointed. Night and day difference in how long glitter shadows stay where you put them. No migration, no fallout.
Too Faced Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eyeshadow Primer
Sensitive-Eye Friendly Eyeliners
After solving the mascara problem I realized my eyeliner was the other culprit behind my itchy, watery eyes. These are the ones that line cleanly without any reaction.
Grab this for brows AND a subtle upper lash line. The thin tip lets you fake fuller brows hair by hair. Fragrance-free and my sensitive skin didn't flinch.
Brow Pop Clean Dual-Action Defining Eyebrow Pencil
Get this if you've been scared of liquid liner because every one you've tried smudged or burned. Precise tip, stays dark, and washes off without an oil-based remover.
Clean Line Liquid Liner
Use the darker shades to tight-line your upper waterline. Creamy enough to not tug but firm enough to stay sharp. My eyes are reactive and this didn't cause a single problem.
Lip Liner + Eyeliner + Cheek Pencil - Tower 28 Beauty
Try the deeper shades as a smudgy eyeliner. Sounds weird but it works beautifully for a soft smoky look. The formula is clean and the price point doesn't hurt.
Humble Kind Words Matte Lip Liner - Rare Beauty
Keep this as your travel liner. Twist-up so there's no sharpener to lose. Wore it in four countries last summer and it performed in every climate from dry desert to tropical humidity.
Dark Chocolate Quickliner For Eyes Eyeliner - Clinique
Pair this with your clean mascara for a pulled-together look in under two minutes. Holds brows without that weird crunchy shellac feeling. Looks natural even when you go heavy-handed.
Saie Beauty Brow Butter Styling and Volumizing Eyebrow Gel
Snag this for the smoothest application I've experienced. Glides on without dragging or skipping. Set it with a matching shadow and it won't budge through a full workday.
Black Gel Eyeliner Pencil: Organic Vegan Formula, Precision Fine Tip | Smooth Glide, Long-Lasting Wear | Sensitive Eye Safe
Gentle Eye Makeup Removers That Actually Work
Clean mascara is great but some of these formulas grip. I ruined a pillowcase and lost a few lashes before finding removers that dissolve everything without burning.
Pour this on a cotton pad and hold it against your eye for ten seconds. Everything melts off. Bought it on a whim years ago and now I panic if I run out.
Bioderma Sensibio H2O Micellar Water 500ml – 2 Pack | French Pharmacy Cleanser for Sensitive Skin | Ships from Paris
Use this as your first cleanse on heavy makeup days. Smells faintly like herbs, dissolves mascara on contact. Rinses clean without leaving an oily film.
Green Clean Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm
Toss your makeup wipes and switch to this. One jar lasts months. Even tubing mascara surrenders immediately. Fragrance-free and dermatologist tested, which my reactive skin appreciates.
Take The Day Off Cleansing Balm Makeup Remover
Warm a small scoop between your palms and press it onto closed eyes. Waterproof liner, mascara, all of it gone. Skin feels soft after, not stripped.
Bedazzled Drunk Elephant Makeup Melting Butter Cleanser
Spritz this after removing makeup to calm any redness. Keeps in the fridge for an extra soothing effect. My eyes felt less puffy on mornings after late-night makeup removal.
SOS Rescue Spray
Pair this as your second cleanse after a balm. Gets any residue your first cleanser missed. Won't dry out the delicate skin around your eyes like foaming cleansers did to me.
Youth To The People Superfood Cleanser
Pump twice, massage over dry skin, and watch mascara dissolve in real time. Rinses without leaving residue. Worth every penny if you wear heavy eye makeup regularly.
Tatcha Pure One Step Camellia Cleansing Oil
Under-Eye Care for Mascara-Weary Skin
All that rubbing and removing takes a toll. The skin under my eyes started looking thin and dark. These products reversed the damage and now my under-eyes don't give away my age or my sleep schedule.
Dab this on before bed and wake up with hydrated under-eyes instead of crepe paper. A little pot lasts forever because you only need a grain-of-rice amount. Fragrance-free.
Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado - Kiehl's Since 1851
Grab this if concealer always creases on you. It smooths the surface so makeup sits flat. My under-eye area went from looking tired to looking like I slept eight hours, even when I didn't.
Banana Bright+ Eye Crème - Vitamin C Eye Cream
Use this in the morning under SPF. Brightened my dark circles noticeably after about three weeks. Doesn't sting, which is rare for vitamin C products around the eye area.
Drunk Elephant – C-Tango™ Vitamin C Eye Cream
Try this if you want a subtle brightening effect without committing to a heavy cream. Lightweight, absorbs fast, layers well under makeup. My concealer actually blended better on top of it.
Summer Fridays Light Aura Vitamin C + Peptide Eye Cream
Warm it between your ring fingers and press gently around the orbital bone. Feels like silk, not kidding. Perfect for anyone whose eye area gets dry and flaky in cold weather.
TATCHA the Silk Peony Melting Under Eye Cream
Keep this in the fridge and apply after a bad night's sleep. The cooling effect reduces puffiness fast. Brought it on a work trip and it saved me from looking like I cried on the plane.
Fresh Black Tea Firming and De-Puffing Eye Cream
Slather this on before bed when your under-eyes feel especially tired. Wake up looking refreshed instead of puffy. The texture is thick but it absorbs overnight. Stock up before winter dries out your whole face.
Pure mulberry silk eye sleeping mask Long fibre 22 momme 6A grade
Setting Sprays and Finishing Touches for Sensitive Skin
Found out the hard way that most setting sprays contain alcohol and fragrance that undid all my careful product choices. These lock everything in without triggering a reaction.
Hold it about eight inches from your face and spray in an X pattern. Keeps mascara and everything else locked in without feeling like hairspray on your skin. Alcohol-free.
Mini Always an Optimist 4-in-1 Mist
Spritz this when your face feels dry midday. It refreshes without disturbing your mascara or eye makeup. Smells like nothing, which is exactly what I want near my eyes.
Hydro Grip Setting + Refreshing Spray - MILK MAKEUP
Toss this in your desk drawer for afternoon SOS moments. Calms irritation and gives a dewy reset. My coworker borrowed it once and immediately ordered her own.
SOS Save.Our.Skin Daily Rescue Facial Spray
Use sparingly over finished makeup for a natural glow that photographs well. A little goes a long way. Wore this to family photos and my skin looked lit from within instead of shiny.
Luminous Dewy Skin Mist
Dab a tiny bit on your cheekbones and brow bone after setting spray. Catches light without glitter particles falling into your eyes. Clean ingredients, sensitive-skin approved.
Saie Glowy Super Gel Lightweight Illuminating Serum
Bring this on flights or to dry offices. Mists fine enough that it won't smear your eye makeup. My skin stopped feeling tight and angry during winter after I started carrying this everywhere.
Clinique Moisture Surge Face Spray Thirsty Skin Relief
Shake it, close your eyes, spray. The mist is super fine and it tightens pores slightly while setting makeup. Discovered it at a friend's house, tried it once, and ordered my own that night.
Caudalie Beauty Elixir Prep, Set Makeup, Glow Face Mist