Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Lip Colors I Switch To Every Autumn That Pull Any Outfit Together
30
items Summer lip colors start looking wrong the second September hits. If you've ever stood in front of a mirror thinking your whole look feels off but couldn't pinpoint why, it's probably your lip shade. I spent years cycling through random fall shades be...
Sections
6
Warm Berry Shades for Cool Weather Days
Muted Mauves That Go With Literally Everything
Brick and Terracotta Reds for a Warm Fall Palette
Deep Plum Shades for When You Want Drama
Nude-But-Better Shades That Actually Suit Fall
Long-Lasting Lip Liners That Hold Everything in Place
Warm Berry Shades for Cool Weather Days
The first time I wore a berry lip with a cream sweater, someone stopped me on the street to ask what shade it was. Before that I was stuck in the pink-or-red binary and everything looked flat.
Swap out your summer coral for this the second October hits. It reads deep berry without going full goth. Wore it to a work dinner with a navy blazer and my boss literally asked if I got a makeover.
MAC Matte Lipstick Chili Orange Red Hot
Try this if you always feel like dark lips look too harsh on you. It's berry but leans warm, so it works on days when you're just in jeans and a flannel. Blot it once for a stained look.
Nars Powermatte Lipstick American Woman
Dab a tiny bit on your lips over balm for the laziest berry tint that still looks intentional. Perfect for anyone who wants a fall lip but hates the feeling of actual lipstick. Found this trick by accident.
Rare Beauty - Grateful Soft Pinch Liquid Blush
Keep this in your bag for when you need to go from daytime to dinner. One swipe and suddenly your whole outfit looks like you planned it. The formula stays put through wine, which matters.
PAT McGRATH LABS - Omi MatteTrance Lipstick
Grab this before it sells out again every fall. It adjusts to your natural tone so it never looks wrong. I've worn it with everything from a white tee to a cocktail dress and it just works.
Clinique Different Lipstick Ripe Raisin #13 & Black Lily #64 Mini Set Discontinued
Muted Mauves That Go With Literally Everything
I used to skip mauve because I thought it was boring. Then I realized boring is actually the point. These are the shades that make you look polished without trying, even on days when you rolled out of bed ten minutes ago.
Use this on mornings when you have zero time but need to look human. It's the shade that makes people think you slept eight hours even when you got four. Stock up, it goes fast in fall.
25+ Charlotte Tilbury Matte Revolution Lipstick Pillow Talk
Layer this over any mauve lipstick when you want a little shine without looking like 2005. Works especially well if you're the person who finds matte lips drying but still wants a fall vibe.
Bling Fenty Beauty Lip Gloss
Toss this in your coat pocket for reapplying on the go. The color is subtle enough that you don't need a mirror. For anyone who hates maintaining lipstick throughout the day but still wants color.
ILIA - Lullaby Balmy Tint Hydrating Lip Balm
Pair this with a chunky knit and messy bun for that effortless fall look that actually takes effort to achieve with other products. It's sheer enough to apply blind and pigmented enough to matter.
Tower 28 Lip Jelly Pistachio 1.34 ml
Switch to this from your summer nude. It's warmer and dustier, which sounds weird but reads as cozy. Wore it every day for two weeks straight last October and nobody got tired of seeing it.
Kosas Weightless Lip Color Lipstick, Undone, 4 g
Brick and Terracotta Reds for a Warm Fall Palette
Regular red lipstick in autumn can look like you're heading to a holiday party too early. These brick and terracotta tones sit right in that sweet spot between summer red and winter burgundy.
Wear this with a camel coat and watch how many compliments roll in. It's the exact shade of a terracotta pot, which sounds odd until you see it on. Warm undertones will especially love this one.
MAC Matye Lipstick Marrakesh 646 Clay Red Long Lasting
Try this if straight-up matte lips make your mouth feel like sandpaper by noon. It has enough slip to feel comfortable but enough pigment to look like a real lipstick. Lasts through coffee.
Nars Afterglow Sensual Shine Lipstick - Idolized
Get this for days when you want color but not commitment. It wears down evenly instead of leaving that awful ring around your lip line. Perfect for the person who always wipes off lipstick by lunchtime.
Merit Signature Lip Lightweight Lipstick Millennial
Splurge on this one and keep it for special occasions. The texture feels like butter and the shade is this complex burnt sienna that photographs incredibly. Worth it before holiday events start piling up.
Lip Suede Matte Lipstick in Le Rouge by Westman Atelier
Grab this if you want something between red and brown without looking muddy. It builds from sheer to full coverage so you control the intensity. Wore it to Thanksgiving last year and my aunt wanted the exact name.
Bobbi Brown Crushed Lip Color Cranberry Swatch
Deep Plum Shades for When You Want Drama
Sometimes a Tuesday needs a dramatic lip. I pull these out when the outfit is simple but I want the whole look to feel like a statement. A dark plum with a plain black turtleneck hits different.
Wear this when you want people to notice your lips first. It's deep plum with a slight shimmer that catches light without looking frosty. Pair it with minimal eye makeup or the whole thing gets overwhelming.
Urban Decay VICE LIQUID LIPSTICK BLACKMAIL 5.3ml
Use this for evening plans that start straight after work. One layer takes you from office-appropriate to dinner-ready. The formula doesn't feather, which matters a lot with shades this dark.
Pat McGrath Labs MatteTrance Lipstick Flesh 3 • Price »
Snag this for under ten bucks and prepare to be confused about why you ever spent more on a plum lip. It dries down completely and survives meals. For anyone building a fall lip collection on a budget.
Sephora Collection Cream Lip Stain 14 Blackberry Sorbet
Despite the name this pulls way more plum than red on most skin tones. Shake it well before applying. I learned the hard way that skipping that step gives you patchy results.
Too Faced Melted Matte Liquified Longwear Liquid Lipstick
Keep this for when you want plum but softer. It's the shade you wear to meet someone's parents for the first time. Polished, a little dramatic, but not intimidating. The packaging feels fancy too.
Lancôme Rose
Nude-But-Better Shades That Actually Suit Fall
Your summer nude probably washes you out once the light changes in October. Took me years to realize that fall nudes need to be warmer and slightly deeper than what I wore in July.
Wear this when you want your lips to look like your lips but richer. It's the shade I reach for on days when I want the outfit to do the talking but my face still needs to look finished.
Velvet Ribbon - Lisa Eldridge
Try this if every nude lipstick you've bought makes you look like a corpse. It has enough warmth to read as alive but enough neutrality to go with any fall color palette. Finally solved my nude lip problem.
Yves Saint Laurent Rouge Pur Couture The Slim Matte
Pair this with a smoky eye for an effortless contrast. The formula is dry in a good way, like it grips your lips without feeling sticky. For anyone who finds creamy lipsticks too slippery.
MAKEUP BY MARIO Ultra Suede Lipstick (1 each) Delivery
Grab this shade if you tend toward cooler undertones and most fall nudes pull too orange on you. It sits right in that sweet spot of pink-brown-nude that actually flatters instead of clashing.
Rose Inc Satin Lip Color Rich Refillable Lipstick
Splurge on this for the shade and stay for the packaging. Every time I pull it out of my bag someone asks about it. The color is a warm taupe nude that makes teeth look whiter, which is a nice bonus.
204 Peggy Taupe, Rouge De Beauté Brillant
Long-Lasting Lip Liners That Hold Everything in Place
No fall lip color survives without a good liner underneath. I skipped this step for years and wondered why my lipstick migrated to my chin by 3pm. These changed everything about how my lip color wears.
Use this under literally any shade on this list. It's that versatile neutral that somehow works with berry, plum, mauve, and nude. Buy two because you will lose one in a coat pocket eventually.
25+ Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat Pillow Talk for sale
Keep this as your ride-or-die fall liner. It's been around forever because it genuinely works with almost every autumn shade. Fill in your whole lip before applying color and watch how much longer everything lasts.
25+ Mac Spice Lip Liner 90s for sale | Updated Oct 2026
Switch to this from your summer liner. The dusty rose tone prevents dark lipsticks from looking too stark at the edges. For anyone who struggles with making bold lip colors look natural.
Nars Lip Pencil Dolce Vita
Toss your old dried-out liners and get this instead. It glides on without tugging and creates a barrier that keeps liquid lipsticks from bleeding. Wish I'd found it before ruining three good lipsticks with feathering.
Makeup by Mario Ultra Suede Sculpting Lip Pencil
Try using this as a full lip color on lazy days. The formula is pigmented enough to wear alone and the pointed tip gives you clean edges without needing a brush. Saves time on rushed mornings.
PATRICK TA Monochrome Moment Precision Lip Crayon