Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Lip Colors I Wear Specifically Because They Make My Teeth Look Whiter
27
items Spent years wondering why some lipsticks made my smile look dull and others made it pop — turns out it all comes down to undertone. If you've ever put on a lip color and immediately thought your teeth looked yellow, this list is for you. Took a lot o...
Sections
9
Berry Shades That Cancel Out Yellow Tones
Cool-Toned Reds That Do All the Work
Mauve and Dusty Rose Shades for Everyday
Plum Lip Colors for a Dramatic Teeth-Brightening Effect
Pink Lip Products With Blue Undertones
Wine and Burgundy Shades for Fall and Winter
Berry Shades That Cancel Out Yellow Tones
Berries were the first colors where I noticed the difference — put one on before a dinner and my friend literally asked if I'd whitened my teeth. Nope, just the right undertone doing its thing.
Swap your usual mauve for this — it's a blue-toned berry that made my coffee-stained teeth look two shades brighter in photos. For anyone who drinks three cups a day and refuses to give it up.
Mac Flat Out Fabulous Lipstick
Wear this to any event where you'll be photographed smiling. The cool plum undertone does something almost sneaky to make your teeth pop. Grabbed it before a wedding and got compliments all night.
NARS Powermatte Lipstick in American Woman 112
Try this if you want the teeth-whitening effect without full-coverage lipstick — it's sheer enough for a Tuesday but the berry tint still pulls its weight. Perfect for the no-makeup-makeup crowd.
Serenity Soft Pinch Tinted Lip Oil - Rare Beauty
Cool-Toned Reds That Do All the Work
Not all reds are created equal — warm orangey reds actually made my teeth look MORE yellow. These cool blue-based reds are the ones that fixed that problem completely.
Keep this in your bag for when you need to look put-together in five seconds. The blue-red base practically tricks the eye into seeing whiter teeth. I wore it to a job interview and felt invincible.
Fenty Beauty Stunna Lip Paint Uncensored 2 mL
Snag this if you've always wanted a classic red but felt like they washed you out — the cool undertone is strong enough to counteract any yellowing without looking unnatural. Worth every penny.
PAT McGRATH LABS - Elson MatteTrance Lipstick
Use this when you want old Hollywood energy — the blue base is subtle but your teeth will look noticeably brighter in every single selfie. Discovered it after returning three warm reds that made me look sickly.
Red Matte Lipstick - Matte Revolution - Red Carpet Red
Mauve and Dusty Rose Shades for Everyday
Sometimes I just want a low-key lip that still does the whitening trick. These mauves have enough cool pigment to make my smile look fresh without screaming LOOK AT MY LIPSTICK.
Pair this with literally any outfit — it's that perfect dusty mauve that somehow makes your teeth the focal point of your face. For anyone who wants a go-to neutral that actually does something.
Lip Injection Power Plumping Liquid Lipstick
Toss your tinted chapsticks and try this instead. The cool rose tone is barely there but my teeth looked cleaner every time I wore it. Ideal if you hate the feeling of heavy lipstick.
ILIA - Runaway Balmy Tint Hydrating Lip Balm
Get this for days when you want glossy lips without the sticky nightmare — the mauve-pink has just enough blue undertone to brighten your whole mouth area. Took me ages to find a gloss that actually did this.
Wet Lip Oil Plumping Treatment Gloss - Dip
Plum Lip Colors for a Dramatic Teeth-Brightening Effect
When I really want the contrast cranked up, I reach for plums. These are my going-out shades — the deep cool tones make even slightly off-white teeth look genuinely bright.
Bring this out for date nights — the deep plum is dramatic enough to turn heads but the cool base is what secretly makes your smile look incredible. My partner noticed immediately the first time I wore it.
Urban Decay VICE LIQUID LIPSTICK BLACKMAIL 5.3ml
Switch to this from your usual dark lip — the matte plum finish photographs insanely well and the undertone pulls all the warmth away from your teeth. Found it after a makeup artist recommended cool plums specifically.
Lancôme L'Absolu Rouge Intimatte Lipstick 888 French Idol
Try this deep shade when you want something moody — it reads almost wine-colored and the blue base is doing serious overtime on the teeth-whitening front. For anyone who gravitates toward dark lips in fall and winter.
Be Legendary Prime & Plush Lipstick
Pink Lip Products With Blue Undertones
Pink is tricky because warm pinks can actually make things worse. These specific pinks lean cool enough to give you that bright-smile effect without veering into Barbie territory.
Grab this if you want the laziest possible teeth-whitening hack — just swipe it on and the cool berry-pink adjusts to your lips while making your smile look cleaner. Threw it in my gym bag and never looked back.
Dior Addicted to Dior Bag Charm Jewelled Lip Gloss Duo Compact, Shade 002, Boxed Luggage Tag Charm
Use this when you want that glossy K-beauty lip but also want your teeth to cooperate in photos. The cool pink sheen is subtle but effective. For anyone tired of their smile looking dull in natural light.
Ysl Loveshine Lip Oil Stick 44
Snag this sheer pink — it looks almost neutral on the lips but has just enough cool pigment to shift how your teeth read in person. Perfect if the idea of bold color stresses you out.
Tower 28 Lip Jelly Pistachio 1.34 ml
Wine and Burgundy Shades for Fall and Winter
October hits and I immediately reach for these — wine tones are basically nature's teeth whitener. Deep, rich, and every single one of these made my smile look noticeably brighter in dim restaurant lighting.
Keep this in your coat pocket from September through March — the wine tint is buildable so you control how dramatic it gets, but even one layer makes your teeth look fresher. Wish I'd found it two winters ago.
MERIT Shade Slick Hydrating Tinted Lip Oil
Ditch whatever sheer lip thing you're currently using and try this cult classic — the deep berry-wine tone adapts to everyone differently but universally makes teeth appear whiter. There's a reason it went viral.
Almost Lipstick in Black Honey and Pink Honey Stocking Stuffer
Try this when you want that just-bitten wine stain look — the cool burgundy undertone does exactly what you need it to for your smile. For the person who wants drama without committing to full opaque lipstick.
Hourglass Phantom Volumizing Glossy Lip Balm
Coral and Peach Shades to Avoid — Plus What to Wear Instead
Learned the hard way that warm corals and orangey peaches were sabotaging my smile. These alternatives have just enough coolness mixed in to give you that warm-toned look without the yellow-teeth problem.
Use a tiny dot of this on your lips instead of a straight coral lipstick — the pink base keeps it from going too warm and your teeth stay looking clean. Doubled as cheek and lip color when I was running late last week.
Soft Pinch Liquid Blush
Swap your peachy nudes for this — it reads warm but has a pink-mauve base that prevents that teeth-yellowing disaster. For anyone who loves nude lips but hates how they make their smile look flat.
Glossier Ultralip Cachet
Grab this cooled-down rosy shade if you usually reach for peach — you still get that soft natural vibe but without sacrificing how bright your teeth look. Figured this out after a brutally honest photo from brunch.
tarte Maracuja Juicy Lip Hydrating Plump Gloss
Nude Lip Colors That Still Brighten Your Smile
Finding a nude that doesn't make your teeth look beige took me an embarrassing amount of time. These nudes all lean slightly cool or pink, which is the secret nobody tells you about.
There's a reason this specific nude is everywhere — the pink-mauve base keeps your teeth from blending into your lip color. Wear it when you want to look polished but not like you're trying. Took me three wrong nudes before landing here.
Nude Pink Lipstick: Pillow Talk - Matte Revolution
Try this peachy-pink nude if you've been burned by beige nudes before — it has enough warmth to feel natural but enough pink to protect your smile. For anyone who thought nudes just weren't for them.
NARS Afterglow Sensual Shine Lipstick (Women)
Get this if you want a nude that feels expensive — the slightly rosy undertone is barely detectable but it keeps your teeth looking bright instead of washed out. Discovered it when a Sephora associate steered me away from a beige I was about to buy.
Valentino Rosso Valentino Refillable Lipstick Refill (Women)
Glosses and Balms for Low-Effort Teeth Brightening
Some days lipstick is just too much effort — these glosses and balms require zero skill but still have the right undertones to make your smile look its best. My lazy-day lineup.
Toss this in your bag and forget about it until you need it — one swipe of the berry tint and your teeth instantly look cleaner. For the person who refuses to carry more than one lip product at a time.
Laneige MINI Lip Glowy Balm
Use this as your overnight lip treatment — the slightly cool vanilla-pink tone means even your morning mirror face looks brighter. Switched from plain Vaseline and noticed the difference within a week.
Summer Friday's Lip Butter Balm Authentic 0.15oz/15g
Pair this shimmery pink with anything or wear it solo — the cool pink shimmer bounces light in a way that genuinely makes your teeth pop. Been repurchasing for three years and I'm not stopping anytime soon.
Pre-Made Lip Gloss