Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Haunting Pages: Bai's Horror Book Recs

Purple Star emoji 22 items
This list is for the readers who crave goosebumps, plot twists, and that delicious feeling of needing to keep the lights on. These are my favorite horror and mystery books. The ones that kept me hooked, unsettled, and completely obsessed. Whether you...
Sections
3
 
 
 

Natasha Preston

If you love suspense that keeps your heart racing, you need Natasha Preston in your life. Her stories are dark, twisty, and impossible to put down. Every book on this list is a page-turner that left me hooked, unsettled, and craving more. From psycho...

 
Bailee Steward profile picture
This has been my favorite book for years, and it still gives me chills every time I think about it. Natasha Preston weaves such a haunting and unforgettable story. It’s the kind of psychological thriller that sticks with you long after the last page....
The Cellar (Paperback) by Natasha Preston
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
Natasha Preston strikes again with a story that’s equal parts eerie and addictive. The Haunting pulls you into a web of secrets, fear, and suspense that keeps you guessing until the very end. It’s the perfect mix of chilling atmosphere and can’t-put-...
The Haunting - by Natasha Preston (Paperback)
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
I read The Island recently and wow. I was hooked from start to finish. Natasha Preston blends survival tension with shocking twists that kept me constantly on edge. It’s fast-paced, unsettling, and totally addictive. Easily one of my new favorite thr...
The Island - by Natasha Preston (Paperback)
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
The Lost is a classic Preston thriller. Dark, intense, and impossible to put down. The mix of mystery and psychological tension had me completely hooked, and it’s one of those books that lingers with you long after you finish. If you’re new to Natash...
Lost - by Natasha Preston (Paperback)
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
You Will Be Mine is Natasha Preston at her creepiest…a suspenseful, sinister story that had me second-guessing everyone. The tension builds with every chapter, and the twists kept me flipping pages late into the night. It’s dark, addictive, and absol...
You Will Be Mine - By Natasha Preston ( Paperback )
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
The Party is Natasha Preston’s most recent thriller I’ve read, and I absolutely flew through it. The pacing is addictive, the tension doesn’t let up, and that ending? It had me going absolutely crazy. If you love a jaw-dropping final twist, this one ...
The Party - by Natasha Preston (Paperback)
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
The Lake is another addictive Natasha Preston thriller that had me hooked from the start. With its eerie setting and constant sense of unease, it’s the perfect blend of creepy atmosphere and shocking twists. I couldn’t stop turning the pages. Every c...
The Lake - by Natasha Preston (Paperback)
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
The Fear is Natasha Preston at her most haunting. The premise alone gave me chills, and the story kept me on edge the entire time. It’s tense, unsettling, and filled with the kind of dread that makes you want to look over your shoulder while reading....
The Fear - by Natasha Preston (Paperback)
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
The Twin was absolutely CRAZY. It’s twisty, addictive, and full of that signature Preston suspense, but fair warning, it ends on a cliffhanger that will leave you screaming. If you’re into shocking twists and don’t mind being left hanging, this one i...
The Twin - by Natasha Preston (Paperback)
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
The Cabin is another nail-biting Natasha Preston thriller that had me hooked from the first page. The isolated setting, creeping tension, and shocking twists make it impossible to put down. Definitely a must-read for anyone who loves suspense that ke...
The Cabin (Paperback) by Natasha Preston
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
The Dare is a gripping, edge-of-your-seat Natasha Preston thriller. The suspense is relentless, the twists keep coming, and the tension had me hooked the whole way through. Perfect for anyone who loves stories that are dark, thrilling, and totally ad...
The Dare - by Natasha Preston (Paperback)
placeholder

Natalie D. Richards

 
Bailee Steward profile picture
Five Total Strangers is a heart-pounding thriller that had me hooked from the very first page. Natalie D. Richards masterfully builds tension and delivers twists that kept me guessing until the very end. Dark, gripping, and totally addictive…this is ...
Five Total Strangers - by Natalie D. Richards (Paperback)
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
Seven Dirty Secrets is dark, twisted, and completely addictive. Natalie D. Richards keeps you on edge with shocking twists, secrets that unravel in all the best ways, and a plot that doesn’t let up for a second. Perfect for anyone who loves psycholog...
Seven Dirty Secrets - By Natalie D. Richards ( Paperback )
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
Four Found Dead is a gripping thriller that had me hooked from the first page. Natalie D. Richards expertly ratchets up tension, layering twists and secrets that kept me guessing until the very last chapter. Dark, thrilling, and impossible to put dow...
Four Found Dead - by Natalie D Richards (Paperback)
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
Six Months Later is a tense, twist-filled thriller that keeps you guessing until the very end. Natalie D. Richards delivers shocking secrets, suspenseful pacing, and unforgettable twists that make it impossible to put down. A must-read for anyone who...
Six Months Later - by Natalie D Richards (Paperback)
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
One Was Lost is a dark, twisty thriller that had me hooked from start to finish. Natalie D. Richards expertly builds tension, layers secrets, and delivers shocking reveals that keep you on the edge of your seat. Perfect for fans of gripping psycholog...
One Was Lost (Paperback) by Natalie D. Richards
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
What You Hide is a dark, twisty thriller that kept me on the edge of my seat from start to finish. Natalie D. Richards expertly layers secrets, suspense, and shocking twists that make it impossible to put down. Fans of psychological thrillers will de...
What You Hide - By Natalie D. Richards ( Paperback )
placeholder

Other

 
Bailee Steward profile picture
There’s Someone Inside Your House is a chilling, page-turning thriller that had me hooked from the very first chapter. Stephanie Perkins delivers tension, suspense, and twists that keep you guessing and terrified until the very end. Perfect for fans ...
There's Someone Inside Your House - by Stephanie Perkins (Paperback)
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
The Asylum trilogy by Madeleine Roux is a dark, gripping journey that had me hooked from start to finish. Creepy settings, eerie secrets, and twists that keep you on edge—these books perfectly blend psychological suspense with horror. If you love spi...
Asylum 3-Book Box Set - by Madeleine Roux (Paperback)
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
The Perfect Place to Die is a dark, gripping thriller that had me hooked from the very first page. Bryce Moore expertly builds tension, layers shocking twists, and keeps the suspense high until the very end. Perfect for anyone who loves psychological...
The Perfect Place to Die
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
The Tenth Girl is a tense, twist-filled thriller that kept me on the edge of my seat from start to finish. With secrets, suspense, and shocking twists around every corner, it’s impossible to put down. A must-read for fans of gripping psychological su...
The Tenth Girl
placeholder
 
Bailee Steward profile picture
Ten is a fast-paced, chilling thriller that had me hooked from the first page. Gretchen McNeil delivers high-stakes suspense, clever twists, and a tension-filled plot that keeps you guessing until the very end. Perfect for fans of dark, addictive pag...
Ten
placeholder