Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Concealers Worth Trying
19
items Concealers I've actually tested and kept in rotation, for under-eye brightening, spot coverage, and everything in between. This list contains affiliate links, so I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. What's your biggest concealer str...
Sections
3
Full Coverage & Under-Eye Brightening
Natural & No-Makeup Days
Everyday, Travel & Skin-Like Finish
Full Coverage & Under-Eye Brightening
This is the one I keep repurchasing because it's genuinely brightening, not just covering — the peachy undertone cancels out blue-purple circles instead of just masking them with more pigment. It creases a little by hour 6 if I skip setting powder, b...
Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser
The classic for a reason — this melts into skin instead of sitting on top, so it looks like your skin on a really good day rather than ‘concealer.’ I use the lighter shade under my eyes and a shade that matches my skin for spot coverage, and it holds...
Radiant Creamy Concealer - NARS
This is the one people mean when they say ‘full coverage without looking cakey’ — a little goes a long way, and I always mix a drop of moisturizer in if my skin is on the drier side, since it can grab onto texture otherwise. Best under-eye brightener...
Shape Tape Concealer - Tarte
My budget pick when I don't want to think too hard about it — the shade range is genuinely one of the widest I've seen at this price, and the coverage rivals concealers three times the cost. It's matte, so I mix in a drop of face oil if my under-eyes...
16HR Camo Concealer - e.l.f. Cosmetics
This is my splurge pick and honestly the most hydrating full-coverage concealer I've used — it doesn't sit in fine lines even on my drier days. The doe-foot applicator makes it easy to build up coverage exactly where I need it without overdoing the r...
Bye Bye Under Eye Concealer - IT Cosmetics
This is my splurge-splurge pick, even above IT Cosmetics — it's practically a skincare-makeup hybrid with peptides and squalane baked in, so it actually improves my under-eye area over time instead of just sitting on it. Full coverage but somehow sti...
Revealer Super Creamy + Brightening Concealer - Kosas
This is the one pro makeup artists actually use, and you can tell — it's full coverage without ever looking thick, and the shade range has real depth options unlike a lot of drugstore lines. My splurge pick when I need it to hold up on camera all day...
HD Skin Full Coverage Concealer - Make Up For Ever
The dual-ended applicator is genius — tap it on with the sponge tip, then buff it out, all with one wand. It's a natural finish concealer that doesn't crease on me and lasts through a full day without touch-ups, which is rare for something this light...
Quickie 24HR Full-Coverage Concealer - Urban Decay
Natural & No-Makeup Days
The shade range here is what sells me — 24 options with actual undertone variety, not just light-medium-dark. It's a natural, skin-like finish rather than full glam coverage, so it's my go-to when I want to look like myself but slightly more awake.
True Match Concealer - L'Oreal
This one earns its ‘cakeless’ name — it's the thinnest, most natural-feeling formula on this list, which makes it perfect for no-makeup makeup days when I still want to cover redness around my nose. It's not built for heavy coverage though, so it's n...
Boi-ing Cakeless Concealer - Benefit Cosmetics
This one blurs into skin like a filter instead of sitting as a product, so it's perfect on days I want to look like I have zero makeup on. It's got skincare ingredients baked in, and the finish is soft and dewy rather than matte or cakey.
Skin Blur Serum Concealer - ILIA
This is a stick, not a traditional concealer, and that's exactly why I love it on lazy mornings — swipe, tap, done. It gives the most natural skin-like finish that still covers redness and dark spots without ever looking like makeup.
The Minimalist Perfecting Complexion Stick - Merit
Another skin-tint-meets-concealer hybrid I keep coming back to — it's got a gel-cream texture that melts right in, so my under-eyes look rested instead of covered up. Great for days when I just want to look like a well-rested version of myself.
Swipe Serum Concealer - Tower 28 Beauty
Everyday, Travel & Skin-Like Finish
This is my travel bag backup because it does the job without any fuss — medium coverage, no weird gray cast, and it doesn't crease around my nose the way some drugstore concealers do on me. Not the most exciting pick on this list, but it's dependable...
Fit Me Concealer - Maybelline
I use this more like a foundation than a spot concealer — it's thin enough to blend all over with a damp sponge for light, even coverage, but you can layer it just on problem areas too. It's a great two-in-one if you're trying to cut down your routin...
Conceal + Perfect 2-in-1 Foundation + Concealer - Milani
This is the one I reach for on days I actually want my skin to look like skin, just better — it's a satin finish, not matte, so it sinks in rather than sitting as a layer. It's pricey for what it is, and the coverage is medium at best, so it's not th...
Beautiful Skin Medium Coverage Concealer - Charlotte Tilbury
This is the concealer I reach for on days I'm running around all day — it genuinely does not budge, but it still looks like skin, not a mask. A little goes a long way, so one tube lasts me forever, which makes the splurge worth it.
Flawless Fusion Ultra-Longwear Concealer - Laura Mercier
The original click-pen concealer, and honestly still one of the best travel formats out there — it lives in every bag I own. It brightens more than it covers, so it's perfect for that lit-from-within look on the go.
Touche Eclat All-Over Brightening Concealer Pen - YSL
This one has a skincare-like bouncy texture that just melts into my under-eyes and never settles into lines, even by hour eight. It's become my go-to when I want my skin to look like skin, just a slightly more perfect version.
Forever Skin Correct Concealer - Dior