I use the pencil and I love - doesn't smudge or wear off throughout my day/night
Eyeliners: Liquid & Pencil Liners | NYX Professional Makeup
My roommate recently put me onto this, I've now added it to my daily routine. I pair it with my better than sex mascara and I get the perfect volume + length combo.
Eye Makeup Telescopic Original Lengthening Mascara - L'Oréal Paris
Has never broken me out, and since it's so pigmented a little goes so far. I've had mine for so long, use it almost every day and am still trying to make a dent!
Soft Pinch Liquid Blush - Rare Beauty
I've been loving using a little bit of this and then some Aquaphor, I get a darker tint that's perfect for everyday.
Black Honey Collection: Lipstick, Gloss & More - Clinique