Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

My favorite beauty recs

Purple Star emoji 101 items
My curated beauty lineup — all my ride‑or‑die products that make getting ready feel soft, pretty, and effortless. Think clean‑girl staples, viral must‑haves, and the little things that make me feel put together.
Map
Sections
20
 
 
 
 
 
 

Hair Care (cremes/leave-in/etc.

 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My instant “I have layers” spray. Adds fluff, lift, and drama.
Full Dry Volume & Texture Spray
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Smells like a rich girl’s bathroom and makes my hair glossy without weighing it down.
Ouai Leave In Conditioner
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Soft, shiny, and smells like a warm girl summer. Aesthetic AND effective.
Honey Infused Hair Oil
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Affordable, reliable, and keeps my hair from sizzling when I inevitably over‑style.
Thermal Keratin Smooth weightless Fortifying Heat Protection Spray
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
The universal fixer. Detangles, smooths, protects — basically a Swiss Army knife for hair.
It's a 10 Miracle Leave-In Conditioner
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Drugstore volume that actually shows up. Makes my roots look alive.
Plump For Joy Collection | Volumizing Hair Care
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
For slick-back buns that do. not. move.
Eco Style Gel Olive Oil - Shine & Tame Ends
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Softens everything without greasing it up. Perfect for sleek buns or smooth blowouts.
Farewell Frizz
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My “fix it even if I broke it” shampoo. Makes my hair feel stronger and smoother like I suddenly stopped heat styling (I didn’t).
Nº.4 BOND MAINTENANCE® SHAMPOO
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
The rich, buttery conditioner that makes my ends look like they’ve never seen a flat iron.
No.5 Bond Maintenance® Conditioner for Healthier-Looking Hair
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Humidity who? Turns my hair into literal glass for days.
Dream Coat Supernatural Spray | The #1 Anti-Frizz Treatment
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Minty, tingly, and makes my scalp feel brand new.
Scalp Revival Charcoal + Tea Tree Scalp Treatment
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
The OG glossy‑hair serum. Makes my ends look hydrated and expensive.
Moroccanoil Treatment Original
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
The “my hair is reborn” treatment. One pump and suddenly my split ends are like… gone.
Full-Size Leave-In Molecular Repair Hair Mask 50mL
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My secret for a clean, flake‑free scalp. Clarifies without stripping.
Glycolic Acid 7% Exfoliating Toner (as a scalp rinse)
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This is my lazy‑girl blowout tool. It gives me volume, shine, and that bouncy ‘I tried today’ look in like 6 minutes. Zero skill required, zero arm workout.
One-Step™ Volumizer PLUS
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Affordable, smells expensive, and makes my hair behave. My everyday, no‑drama cleanser.
Signature Shampoo
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
The classic “I didn’t wash my hair” eraser.
Original Classic Clean Scent | Batiste™ Dry Shampoo
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Actually cleans your hair instead of just perfuming it. Elite
Perfect hair Day™ Dry Shampoo
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
I love Olaplex No. 3 because it actually repairs my hair — it reduces breakage, smooths frizz, and keeps my color-treated hair feeling soft and healthy.
Nº.3 Hair Perfector
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Lightweight and bougie. Protects without making my hair sticky.
ghd bodyguard - heat protect spray 4 fl. oz.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Defines curls without crunch. Soft, bouncy, and cute.
Curl Crème

SPF

My ride‑or‑die sunscreens that don’t leave a cast, don’t break me out, and actually make my skin look better under makeup. These are the SPFs I trust with my whole face.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Lightweight, dewy, and feels like skincare. I forget I’m even wearing sunscreen.
Beauty of Joseon Sunscreens
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My no-white-cast, no-breakout SPF. It feels like a primer and makes my makeup sit so smooth.
Bestselling Sunscreen
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My beach‑day SPF. Zero white cast, super glowy, and never breaks me out.
Anthelios Melt-In Milk Sunscreen SPF 60

Tools

My beauty tools that actually make a difference — the brushes, sponges, curlers, and little essentials that make my routine easier and my makeup look better.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This is my ‘I actually have my life together’ makeup case. Fits everything, keeps it organized, and stops my products from disappearing into the void.
Makeup Cases
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This brush changed my life. It detangles without ripping my hair out and makes brushing wet hair actually painless. I use it every single day.
The Ultimate Detangler
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My under-eye bestie. Perfect for setting powder without making me look 90.
Makeup Setting Brush
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
The eyeshadow blender that makes me look like I know what I’m doing.
E40 Tapered Blending Brush
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
The brush that makes my brows behave. Sharp lines, fluffy blend, zero effort.
Brush 12 Dual-Ended Firm Angled Eyebrow Brush
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This mat makes cleaning my brushes stupid easy. I swirl them around with a little soap and it pulls out everything. My brushes stay soft instead of crunchy.
Sigma Spa® Express Brush Cleaning Mat
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
I keep this in the freezer and roll it on my face every morning. It de‑puffs, tightens, and makes me look awake even when I’m absolutely not.
ESARORA Ice Roller for Face
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Using this after setting spray makes my makeup look airbrushed. It dries everything down in seconds and gives ‘celebrity in the makeup chair’ energy.
JISULIFE 3 IN 1 USB Rechargeable Mini Fan
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
I use this so I don’t dig my nails into my primer. Also it just feels… official.
Putty Primer Brush and Applicator
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My drugstore ride-or-die. Gives the same blend as the boujee one but for latte money.
Miracle Complexion Sponge
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Using my fingers for masks? Couldn’t be me. This silicone spatula spreads everything evenly, wastes zero product, and keeps my hands clean.
Facial Mask Brush Anjou 12pcs Face Applicator Brush For Applying
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
I don’t pluck often, but when I do, it’s with these. Sharp, precise, and never miss a hair.
Award-Winning Slant Tweezers
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This puff is literally my blur filter IRL. It presses powder in so smooth and makes my under‑eyes look airbrushed with zero creasing. I use it every single day!
Powder Puff
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This mirror humbled me in the best way. The lighting is so good it shows everything — which means my makeup ends up flawless.
The Best LED Lighted Compact Mirrors
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My secret weapon for smooth makeup days. I use these to clean up my brows and gently dermaplane so my makeup goes on like butter.
Tinkle Dermaplaning Tool 6ct for Women
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This curler is my personality. It grabs every lash without pinching and makes my mascara look 10x better.
Eyelash Curler
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
I sleep in this and wake up with perfect soft curls. No heat, no effort, no damage. It’s my ‘I want to look cute tomorrow without trying’ tool.
Heatless Curling Sets
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This is the curling iron that never misses. It heats evenly, glides through my hair, and gives me those soft, bouncy curls that actually stay put.
Singlepass Curl X - Long Barrel Curling Iron | Ceramic Wand
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
The “I’m entering my rich‑aunt era” dryer. Fast, quiet, and makes my hair look like I actually drink water.
Dyson Hair Dryer | Dyson Supersonic™
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
For when I want volume but also want to pretend I’m a professional stylist. It’s like a round brush and a straightener had a baby and the baby is talented.
thermal brush : blowout babe | thermal ionic hairbrush
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
If you want that bouncy, salon blowout look, this brush is the secret. It grips the hair perfectly and gives so much volume.
The Single Shot Round Blow-Dryer Brush
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Lightweight, fast, and doesn’t make my hair frizzy. It’s the perfect everyday dryer that doesn’t feel like it’s burning my scalp off.
Conair Double Ceramic 1875W Hair Dryer
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
If you want volume that borders on cartoonish (in a good way). Makes curls look alive.
Shark HyperAIR™ IQ Curl-Defining Diffuser
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My Dyson dupe.
Shark® Hair Stylers | Air Stylers & Drying
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
The OG. The classic. The “I’ve been doing this since middle school” straightener that still hits.
CHI Original Ceramic Flat Iron Straightener
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Makes my hair glass‑smooth without frying it. It straightens in one pass and somehow leaves my hair shiny instead of crispy. Elite.
Smart Hair Straightener with Predictive Heat | ghd Platinum+
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Looks insane but works like magic. Gives curls that fluffy, defined, “I woke up like this” bounce.
DevaFuser the Diffuser for Curly Hair
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
For sleek roots and silk‑press energy. Gets everything smooth without drama.
High Heat Gold Ceramic Press Comb
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
The beach‑wave machine. Gives that mermaid, salty‑hair vibe even if you’re landlocked.
Bed Head Wave Artist Deep Waver - Combat Frizz
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This one is so good for the price. It straightens, waves, and curls, and the plates glide like butter. Perfect if you want a cute hair day without spending Dyson money.
3-In-One Flat Iron
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Nothing blends like this lil pink egg. I’ve tried the dupes… they lie. This one makes my foundation look like skin.
Beautyblender® Original Makeup Sponge
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
The reliable queen. Gives bouncy curls that last through humidity, sweat, and questionable decisions.
24K Gold Marcel Iron/Wand
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My curls literally last all day with this. It smooths, curls, dries, and makes my hair look like I walked out of a salon. Expensive? Yes. Worth it? Also yes.
Dyson Airwrap™ multi-styler and dryer

Makeup Remover

The makeup removers that melt everything off — mascara, foundation, chaos — without burning my eyes or stripping my skin. Lazy‑girl friendly and actually effective.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My heavy‑duty remover. Melts mascara instantly without tugging or burning.
Take The Day Off™ Makeup Remover Cleansing Balm
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Melts my makeup in 10 seconds and doesn’t sting my eyes. I literally look forward to taking my makeup off.
Green Clean Makeup Removing Cleansing Balm
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My lazy‑girl makeup remover. One swipe and everything’s gone — gentle and cheap.
Micellar Cleansing Water All-in-1 Makeup Remover

Body Lotion

My soft‑girl body care lineup. These lotions make my skin feel smooth, smell amazing, and give that “I take care of myself” energy.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
How makeup sits on top — foundation blends smoother and looks more radiant!
The Dewy Skin Cream Replenishing and Plumping Moisturizer
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My clean‑girl lotion. So hydrating without feeling sticky — my skin drinks it up.
The Body Lotion 200 ml | Multi-Peptide
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
The smell? The glow? The compliments? This is my ‘I’m a snack’ lotion. Makes my skin feel insanely soft.
Brazilian Bum Bum Cream - Skin Tightening Body Cream
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Smells like a warm sugar cookie. Makes my skin insanely soft and gets compliments.
Shea Better Vanilla Cashmere Body Lotion ...

Fragrance

My signature scents — cozy, clean, sweet, and compliment‑magnet vibes only. These are the perfumes I reach for when I want to feel like that girl.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My clean-girl signature scent. Smells like me but hotter — people always ask what I’m wearing.
Glossier You
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This is my absolute fav. So warm and sweet
Cheirosa 62 Perfume Mist
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Sol de Janeiro 62 Mist Smells like a warm, sweet cloud. Compliment magnet.
Sol de Janeiro
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My cozy, sweet‑girl scent. Warm vanilla that layers with everything and lasts forever.
Kayali Vanilla 28 Eau de Parfum
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
I want to stress how amazing this smells. Warm vanilla & Honey. Smells different on everyone imo.
BellaVita Luxury Honey Oud Eau de Parfum

Lip Care

My lip‑saving lineup. Glossy, hydrating, and perfect for day or night. These keep my lips soft, juicy, and never crusty.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My everyday throw‑in-the-bag balm. Hydrating, shiny, and smells so good.
Lip Butter Balm Collection (any shade)
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My lips stay glossy and soft all day. I use it like a daytime balm because I’m obsessed.
Lip Sleeping Mask Nourish & Hydrate
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My bougie lip mask. Makes my lips look plush and glossy without feeling heavy.
The Kissu Jelly Lip Mask

Hair Mask

My hair‑healing favorites. These masks bring my hair back from heat damage, dryness, and general chaos. Soft, shiny, revived energy.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Thick, creamy, and makes my hair feel like a plush blanket. Instant softness.
nourishing hair mask for dry hair : soulfood
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Drugstore legend. Turns straw into silk in literally three minutes
3 Minute Miracle Moist Deep Conditioner w/ Avocado
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My emergency repair mask. Makes my hair feel soft, smooth, and revived after heat styling.
Hydrating Hair Masks for All Types: Fine, Medium, Coarse, Dry & Damaged

Mascara

My lash essentials — lengthening, lifting, and zero‑flake formulas that make my lashes look like extensions without the appointment.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
• Lifts and curls without a lash curler The hook‑and‑roll brush grabs every lash and gives that wide‑open, doll‑eye effect we love. • Lightweight, fluttery finish Defines and lengthens without clumping, so your lashes stay soft and separated all day...
Roller Lash Curling Mascara
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This mascara gives me instant doll lashes with zero effort 🙌
Better Than Sex Volumizing Mascara
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My drugstore ride‑or‑die. Lifts, separates, and never flakes — looks like lash extensions.
Lash Sensational® Washable Mascara

Setting Spray

My makeup‑locking sprays that keep everything in place through sweat, humidity, and long days. Smooth, glowy, and reliable.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My smoothing, blurring setting spray. Makes my makeup look filtered in real life. Affordable!
Oil-Free Setting Spray for Healthy, Radiant Skin
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This foundation gives that skin‑but‑better glow. It blends so easily and makes my face look smooth and hydrated.
SurrealSkin® Foundation
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This setting spray locks my makeup in all day and makes my skin look so smooth. It’s my ride‑or‑die for keeping everything cute.
Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray: Hydrating Waterproof Setting ...
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My makeup lockdown spray. Keeps everything in place through sweat, heat, and chaos.
All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray

Blush

My go‑to blushes for that soft, flushed, ‘I just drank water and minded my business’ glow. Creams, powders, and tints that blend effortlessly and make me look instantly alive.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Pink Pop ate. It makes my cheeks look so cute and lifted with literally no work.
Pink Pop: Pillow Talk Matte Beauty Blush Wand
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This blush gives the softest, dewy flush. It makes my cheeks look juicy and fresh in that clean‑girl way without feeling sticky.
Saie Dew Blush™ | Liquid Cheek Flush
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Gives that healthy, dewy flush like I mind my business and stay hydrated.
Soft Pinch Liquid Blush | Long-Lasting Dewy & Matte Blushes

Foundation

My go‑to foundations for smooth, even, skin‑but‑better coverage. These all blend easily, never look cakey, and give that flawless, hydrated finish I’m obsessed with.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Gives me the softest, prettiest curls with zero heat. I just wrap my hair before bed and wake up looking like I tried.
Ulta Beauty
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
It makes my skin look naturally radiant with zero effort!
Hollywood Flawless Filter: Glow Booster

Brows

My brow must‑haves for fluffy, lifted, clean‑girl brows. Gels, pencils, and tints that keep everything in place without looking crunchy.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This brow gel keeps my brows lifted and cute all day. It gives that clean, fluffy look I’m obsessed with.
Brow Freeze® Gel

Concealer

My bright‑under‑eyes essentials. These concealers blend like a dream, never crease on me, and give that awake, lifted look even when I’m running on vibes.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Ohhh Maybelline Fit Me Concealer — the budget baddie, the humble queen, the “I’m cute AND I’m only $7” icon. • She’s the “I woke up like this” concealer — light, natural, and low‑key flawless. • Blends out like she’s trying to get promoted — smooth...
Fit Me® Oil-Free Concealer Face Makeup
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Gives me bright‑eyed, well‑rested energy even when I’m running on vibes and iced coffee. • Blends like it has no business blending that well — she melts into the skin like we’re in a rom‑com. • Hydrating, glowy, and never crusty. We do not tolerate...
Revealer Concealer
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
Tarte Shape Tape — Full‑Coverage Queen Behavior She said “dark circles? not on my watch” and then erased them like a toxic ex. • Gives that snatched‑under‑eye moment that makes you look like you slept, hydrated, journaled, and went to therapy. • B...
shape tape™ full-coverage concealer

Primer

My skin‑prep favorites that make my makeup go on smoother, last longer, and look way more flawless. These are the primers I trust under every look.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This primer grips my makeup like crazy. It makes everything last longer and look smoother.
Hydro Grip Hydrating Face Primer
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This primer grips my makeup like crazy. It makes everything last longer and look smoother.
Power Grip Primer

Powder

My setting powders for a smooth, blurred, filter‑in‑real‑life finish. These keep shine in check without making my skin look dry or cakey.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This powder smooths everything out and keeps my makeup in place. It makes my under eyes look so bright and cute.
Easy Bake Loose Baking & Setting Powder

Bronzer

My warmth‑adding bronzers that give me that soft, sun‑kissed glow without looking muddy or orange. These blend effortlessly and make my face look naturally sculpted.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This bronzer blends like butter and gives the softest warmth. It never looks muddy.
Sun Stalk'r Instant Warmth Bronzer

Highlighter

My glow‑girl essentials. These highlighters give that dewy, lit‑from‑within shine — never glittery, always smooth and radiant.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This highlighter gives that soft, glassy glow without looking glittery. It makes my skin look so fresh.
Positive Light Liquid Luminizer | Dewy Liquid Highlighter

Lip Gloss

My juicy‑lip lineup. Shiny, hydrating glosses that make my lips look full, plush, and glossy without feeling sticky.
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This lip oil makes my lips look juicy without being sticky. It’s my everyday cute‑girl gloss.
Fat Oil Lip Drip Lip Gloss| NYX Professional Makeup
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
This lip oil makes my lips look juicy and glossy without being sticky. It’s my everyday pretty‑girl lip.
DIOR Addict Lip Glow Oil Color-Awakening Gloss | Dior US
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My go‑to lip combo for a juicy, glossy pout. It’s so easy and always looks good.
Gloss Bomb Universal Lip Luminizer

Lipstick 💄

My go-to lip colors for every vibe..
 
Caitlin Shay profile picture
My go‑to liner for the perfect pout. It shapes my lips so nicely and goes with every gloss.
Pillow Talk - Lip Cheat - Nude Pink Lip Liner Pencil