Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Most-Worn Lipsticks I Trust

Purple Star emoji 14 items
A curated list of my most-worn lipsticks — from soft everyday shades to bold favorites. These are formulas and colors I trust for comfort, long wear, and a polished finish. Shades are grouped by formula and use for easy browsing.
Sections
2
 
 

Teacher-Proof Lipsticks

These are my favorite put on and stays on all day (even after eating snacks and lunch) so I can put it on and forget about it but still look amazing all day.
 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
Everyday Neutral: A long-wear matte lipstick with strong pigment and impressive staying power. Seductress is a go-to neutral shade that works for daily wear without feeling heavy or drying. A reliable drugstore option when you want polished color tha...
Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Lipstick Seductress
 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
Soft Neutral Pink: A subtle, everyday pink matte that looks polished without drawing too much attention. Inspirer is a reliable neutral shade that works well for daily wear and pairs easily with minimal makeup. Long-lasting and comfortable for all-da...
Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Lipstick, Inspirer
 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
Drugstore Favorite: A true matte lipstick that actually lasts. The shade Revolutionary is my go-to — bold without being drying, and it stays put through a full day without constant touch-ups. A great option if you want long wear without paying luxury...
Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Lipstick, Light Mauve Pink
 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
Warm Red Pop: A rich red-clay matte that stands out without feeling too bold. Self-Starter has warmth and depth that makes it pop, especially when you want color that’s confident but not overly bright. Long-wearing and flattering for everyday or dres...
Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Lipstick, Self-Starter
 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
Soft Pink Favorite: A flattering pink matte that feels polished but approachable. Lover is my go-to pink shade — great for everyday wear when you want color without going bold. Long-lasting, comfortable, and easy to pair with minimal makeup.
Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Lipstick, Lover
 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
Statement Red: A bold, classic red matte that consistently gets compliments. Hustler is my favorite red shade — polished, confident, and eye-catching without looking overdone. Long-wearing and reliable, especially when you want a standout look that s...
Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink Lipstick, Hustler
 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
All-Time Favorite: A classic mauve-rose shade that’s flattering, versatile, and timeless. OG Backtalk was my first Urban Decay lipstick and is still my absolute favorite — polished enough for everyday wear but elevated enough to feel special. A relia...
Urban Decay Vice Lip Bond Glossy Longwear
 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
Favorite Deep Shade: A rich, dusty mauve-brown that adds depth without feeling too dramatic. Dusty Rose (Anastasia) is my go-to darker shade when I want something bolder than everyday neutrals but still wearable. Polished, flattering, and long-lastin...
Anastasia Beverly Hills - Liquid Lipstick
 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
Soft Rose Favorite: A wearable rose-pink shade that looks polished without being overpowering. Dose of Rose is an easy, everyday color that adds warmth and softness while still feeling put-together. Comfortable to wear — and it has a subtle chocolate...
L'Oreal Pro Matte Les Macarons Lipstick Rose

Favorite SPF Tinted Lipsticks

Tinted lip products with SPF for easy, everyday sun protection. I keep this section small and focused on options I actually wear and reapply.

 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
My favorite lip balm with SPF 30. It's a lovely lip gloss with light color that also protects my lips.
Cay Skin Isle Lip Balm SPF 30 Vanilla Brown Sugar
 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
Absolutely favorite tinted lip balm with SPF 35. Doesn't get stuck on my teeth, so just put on and go on with your day.
Sunkissed Berry Sunscreen Lip Balm - Bath & Body Works
 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
This one is my favorite to put on for its feel and smell. Very smooth and silky with a little color. SPF 20.
Revlon Kiss Tinted Lip Balm SPF 20 Hydrating
 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
This one is a winner overall. It has SPF 40, goes on nicely as an oil (so doesn't stick to teeth), and has a beautiful bright color. Most tinted lip balms have very little color. You get a good amount as well.
Scarlet Bloom Lip Oil with Mineral SPF 40 - Bath & Body Works
 
Carebear - Carrie Cross profile picture
Petal Glow is my favorite shade. It's more mauve than the pinks I like to wear and very flattering. Very silky smooth, nice with SPF 20, and a touch of color.
Neutrogena Revitalizing Lip Balm SPF 20, Sheer Shimmer 10, .15 Oz