Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Top Eastern Long Island hidden gem restaurants to dine! 🍽️🤤🍝

Purple Star emoji 13 items
Suffolk county north fork & south fork up & coming restaurants and some old staples
Map
 
Carly Klerk profile picture
The hottest new waterfront restaurant located in Hampton Bays!! Delicious food , indoor @ outdoor bar, day beds by the water and they have frequent DJ’s playing on the weekends🎶
Amalfi Coastal Kitchen & Cocktails | Italian Dining & Outdoor Bar ...
 
Carly Klerk profile picture
The perfect date night dinner spot. High end , delicious Italian. If your a veal lover this is your spot they have SO many options
Pulcinella on the Green
 
Carly Klerk profile picture
This is a new hidden gem! A historic waterfront restaurant newly renovated in Mattituck NY. Waterfront restaurants are so rare on the north shore so I’ve been loving this spot!!
Old Mill Inn
 
Carly Klerk profile picture
Came here for my best friends birthday the other night and we loved it!!! Table side guacamole made fresh, beautiful drinks and atmosphere
IXCHEL Mexican Cuisine
 
Carly Klerk profile picture
La plage is a small indoor & outdoor seating restaurant located on the north shore in Wading River across the road from the beach. You get a perfect sunset, delicious food, with the option of an after dinner walk on the beach ! Perfect date night...<3
La Plage Restaurant in Wading River, NY » French Cuisine
 
Carly Klerk profile picture
Eastern L I Italian gem. I never get sick of eating here
Il Giardino Restaurant by John Gambino
 
Carly Klerk profile picture
Great Greek bite on your way to the orient ferry!!!!
Hellenic
 
Carly Klerk profile picture
Farm to table!!!! Need I say more!? Also bonus full market to shop inside
Fyr & Salt
 
Carly Klerk profile picture
A perfect out east lunch in Riverhead. You can sit outside by the river it is beautiful!
Farm Country Kitchen
 
Carly Klerk profile picture
Delicious home cooked chicken briskets pork you name it. I recommend taking your food across the street and eat on their picnic tables over looking the Peconic river !
Maple Tree BBQ
 
Carly Klerk profile picture
You cannot go wrong with Rumba, the ribs, wings and duck empenadas are a staple. Their Caesar salad (although probably not the healthiest) is to DIE FOR…. I add pulled pork it is so savory
Hampton Bays, NY - RUMBA
 
Carly Klerk profile picture
Idk how eastern Long Island this is considered but always forget about this spot than am blown away by the menu when I go again. One of those places where everything is a good option on the menu
Karvers Grille
 
Carly Klerk profile picture
This was where I fell in love with mussels !!! Great bar menu good servings at a bar menu price , same owners as Spyros next town over just a little more casual in my opinion
Sea Basin