Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Stocking stuffers under $15 that actually get used

Purple Star emoji 15 items
I have two elementary kids, a husband who loses his keys weekly, and a long history of buying cute little stocking junk that was in the trash by New Year's. So this year I only wrote down things under fifteen dollars that someone in this house has ac...
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
This is the mascara I have rebought more than any other, and at eleven dollars it is an easy stocking filler for a sister or a teen. The curved brush grabs the tiny corner lashes I always miss with a straight wand. It does flake a little by hour ten,...
Maybelline Lash Sensational Washable Mascara, Blackest Black
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
My husband works outside and this is the only hand cream he will actually reach for, which is why one jar lives in his truck and one goes in his stocking every year. It is not a lotion, it is thick and almost waxy and it soaks in after about a minute...
O'Keeffe's Working Hands Moisturizing Hand Cream, 2.7 oz Jar
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
Six dollars for a three pound bag makes this the filler I buy when I want something that looks generous and is not junk. I use about two cups after a long Saturday of games and my feet stop aching by morning. The bag is tall and awkward in a stocking...
Dr Teal's Epsom Salt Magnesium Soak, Soothe & Sleep with Lavender, 3 lbs
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
We go through these every fall sideline season and I now buy a pack in October before the good ones disappear. You crack one, shake it, and it stays warm for hours inside a glove or a coat pocket. They are single use, so this is a consumable gift, no...
HotHands Hand Warmers 10 Pair Value Pack - Up to 10 Hours of Heat per Pair
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
Putting a sponge in a stocking sounds like a joke gift until the person uses one and then texts you about it. It goes firm in cold water for scrubbing a pan and soft in hot water for wiping a counter, and it never got that sour smell on me by day thr...
Scrub Daddy Original Sponge Scratch-Free Dish Scrubber, Kitchen & Bath Cleaning Supplies. Scrubbies & Esponjas De Fregar Platos
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
My daughter has 3b curls and detangling used to be a twenty minute fight before I found this. I spray it on damp hair, finger comb from the ends up, and she stopped crying through it. The scent is sweet and pretty strong, so if your kid is picky abou...
Cantu Kids Conditioning Detangling Spray with Shea Butter, Coconut Oil & Honey, 6 fl oz
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
This is my go to for the ten dollar gift exchange because Balsam and Cedar actually smells like a real tree instead of the candle aisle. The ten ounce studio jar burns even for me as long as I trim the wick before lighting it. The scent throw is smal...
Yankee Candle Studio Collection Scented Candle, 10 oz, Balsam & Cedar, Green
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
Ten dollars for eight matte clips meant every woman in my family got one last year and I still had spares. They hold my blown out hair up without the slow slide down that cheap clips do by lunchtime. Two of the eight in my pack had a rough seam on th...
Large Matte Nonslip Hair Claw Clips 8PCS
placeholder
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
A color plus a top coat for ten dollars feels like a real gift in a stocking instead of one lonely bottle. Fairy Tailor is the sheer pink I can put on at nine at night without caring whether it is perfect. It is not actual gel, so do not promise anyo...
Essie Gel Couture Nail Polish Kit, Sheer Nude Pink + Top Coat
placeholder
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
I bought this for my son thinking it would hold him for one afternoon and he has carried it around for months. The new version turns way smoother than the one I had as a kid and the colors are molded in instead of stickers that peel off. Expect a sol...
Rubik's Cube 3x3 Classic Color Puzzle
placeholder
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
Everyone in a cold state already owns one of these and every single one of them is cracked, which is exactly why it works as a gift. The brush head pops off and the scraper has a little row of teeth that breaks up the thick ice instead of skating ove...
AstroAI 27" 2-in-1 Snow Brush & Ice Scraper
placeholder
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
My husband loses his keys weekly and this clips them to a belt loop or a bag strap so they stop living loose in a pocket. The little S shaped clips come off one at a time, so I can hand the sitter one key without surrendering the whole ring. The gate...
Nite IZE KeyRack S-Biner Keychain
placeholder
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
Four holiday flavors in one pack means I can split them across all four stockings and still keep one in my purse. Underneath the flavor it is plain petroleum jelly, which is the only thing that actually fixes my kids cracked winter lips. The flavors ...
Vaseline Holiday Limited Edition Lip Balm 0.25oz Each Raspberry+Shortbread +Sugar Cookie+Gingerbread +Peppermint
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
Six dollars and it has carried us through more waiting rooms and one long power outage than any toy in this house. Both of my elementary kids can play it without an adult refereeing, which is rarer than it sounds. The paper cards go soft and curled b...
UNO Card Game for Kids, Adults & Family Game Night, Original Game of Matching Colors & Numbers
 
Sandhy P. profile picture
Fuzzy socks are the cliche stocking gift and they are a cliche because people wear them until they fall apart. These slouch down instead of squeezing my calf, which is the only reason I keep buying this style over the tight ones. They shed a little f...
Women's Dot Fair Isle Fuzzy Yarn Slouch Socks - Wondershop™ Ivory 4-10