Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Baby's First Christmas Keepsakes
24
items Everything to make baby's very first Christmas unforgettable. These are the gifts and keepsakes families can use year after year! Perfect for baby's first Christmas or as a gift for new parents celebrating their little one's first Christmas.
A first ornament they'll hang on the tree every year — personalize it with baby's name and the year for a sweet keepsake. The kind of ornament that becomes a tradition.
My First Christmas Ornament Customizable
Soft, cozy, and customizable. It's the kind of blanket that gets kept long after baby outgrows it and is perfect for snuggling up during the winter months.
Holiday Heirloom Baby Blanket
This kit turns baby's handprint into an ornament/keepsake you'll treasure forever. A sweet craft to do together and a keepsake for the tree year after year.
Baby's First Christmas Handprint Ornament Kit
A classic Baby's first Christmas ornament and you can get it with baby's name on it!
Baby's First Block Ornament
This ornament with the bootie is so sweet and classic. It marks baby's first Christmas in the most adorable way and looks precious on the tree.
Baby's First Christmas Bootie Ornament
Personalized with baby's name, this pink Santa ornament is made for a baby girl's first Christmas. Soft colors, sweet details, and a keepsake she'll hang for years to come.
Personalized Baby's First Christmas Pink Santa Ornament
A personalized, sweet story for your baby's first Christmas. This book is so fun to read during the holiday season, or even all year long
Baby's First Christmas Personalized Board Book
The softest blanket for snuggles and perfect for Christmas morning photos. Made to be kept and loved for years.
Holly Jolly Santa Heirloom Baby Blanket
If you're a Disney lover like me then this stocking is perfect for your little one. Hang it by the fireplace for Santa's first visit, then keep it as a keepsake.
Disney's Winnie the Pooh and Piglet Quilted Christmas Stocking
The pajamas for Christmas Eve photos — soft, festive, and made for baby's first holiday season. Perfect for matching family pictures or a cozy night before Santa comes.
My First Christmas Baby Pajama
Mickey makes baby's first Christmas even more magical — this sleeper is soft, cozy, and photo-ready. A must for Disney families celebrating a first holiday with baby.
Mickey Mouse ''My First Christmas'' Sleeper for Baby
The classic red Santa hat sized just for baby — an instant Christmas photo upgrade. Soft and gentle on little heads, and it makes every picture feel like the holidays.
Baby 'My First Christmas' Santa Hat - Red
Baby's very own Christmas tree to stack, sort, and play with — 12 colorful pieces that build fine motor skills while they play. It stores neatly when playtime is over, and it's festive enough to leave out all season.
Step2 My First Christmas Tree: Stacking & Sorting Educational Toy with Storage Capability, 12 Pieces
A plush cloud blanket that doubles as a milestone photo prop — track baby's first Christmas and every month that follows. Soft, snuggly, and made for all those first-year photos.
My First Christmas Milestone Plush Cloud Blanket¨ *Seconds Quality*
A sweet two-piece set for baby's first Christmas — ivory and green, soft cotton, and ready for holiday gatherings or Christmas morning. Easy to dress baby in and precious in photos.
Baby 2-Piece 'Baby's First Christmas' Long-Sleeve Bodysuit & Pant Set - Ivory/Green
A cozy little Christmas sweater for baby's first holiday — festive, soft, and just right for family photos or a visit with Santa. The 'Santa Baby' detail makes it extra sweet.
My First Christmas Baby Sweater, Newborn Sweater with Christmas 2025, Santa Baby Sweater, Baby First Christmas, Baby Christmas, Xmas
A keepsake journal to record everything about baby's first Christmas — firsts, memories, and milestones, all in one beautiful book. Personalized with baby's name, it's a gift parents will treasure for decades.
BABYBLOOMS | Baby's First Christmas Keepsake Journal with Personalized Berkeley
Personalized metal ornaments from Shutterfly with a sweet dot design — durable, beautiful, and made to hang on the tree for years. A lovely way to mark baby's first Christmas with their name and photo.
SHUTTERFLY | Baby's First Christmas Dots Metal Ornaments
A sweet first-Christmas book for baby's growing library — perfect for bedtime stories all December long. Simple, gentle, and made for reading together by the tree.
PENGUIN RANDOM HOUSE | Babys First Christmas
Waterford crystal makes baby's first Christmas feel truly special — this boot ornament is an heirloom piece to hang every year. Elegant, timeless, and a gift that becomes a family treasure.
WATERFORD CRYSTAL | 2024 Baby's First Christmas Boot Ornament
A Lenox Rudolph ornament to mark baby's first Christmas — classic craftsmanship and holiday charm in one keepsake. It looks beautiful on the tree and only grows more meaningful each year.
LENOX | 2023 Baby's First Christmas Rudolph Ornament
The ultimate first-Christmas gift — a personalized cashmere blanket and teddy set from Maisonette that's as soft as it is special. A luxury keepsake for baby's first holiday, made to be loved for years.
MAISONETTE | My First Christmas Baby Personalized Cashmere Blanket And Teddy Gift Set
A big, beautiful Santa gift bag in natural organic cotton with embroidery — perfect for holding baby's first Christmas gifts. Reusable year after year, and it looks lovely under the tree.
Large Embroidered Natural Organic Cotton Kids Santa Gift Bag
A photo album embroidered with a teddy bear and personalized for baby's first Christmas — made to hold all those precious first-holiday photos. A keepsake book parents will flip through for years to come.
Personalized Embroidered Teddy Bear Baby Photo Album, Embroidered Baby's First Christmas Album Keepsake, Christmas Baby Book Newborn Gift