These baby plush toys are chosen for comfort, safety, and sweet everyday moments. From ultra-soft newborn plushies to cozy loveys and keepsake gifts, this list features baby-approved favorites that make perfect baby shower gifts and comforting compan...
Sections
4
Ultra-Soft Plush For Newborns
Loveys & Comfort Plush
Bedtime & Nursery Plush Friends
Baby Shower & Keepsake Plush Gifts
Ultra-Soft Plush For Newborns
Gentle, lightweight plush toys made for first cuddles.
Chosen for its cloud-soft texture and floppy ears that are easy for newborns to hold and snuggle.
Jellycat Bashful Beige Bunny 12in
A classic first plush with a lightweight feel, perfect for newborn cuddles and gifting.
GUND Baby My First Friend Teddy Bear Tan
Loved for its neutral color palette and calming softness that fits beautifully into any nursery.
Mary Meyer Putty Stuffed Slate Blue Elephant
Loveys & Comfort Plush
Soothing plush companions babies reach for again and again.
Combines a soft plush head with a gentle blanket body for naps, stroller rides, and bedtime comfort.
Jellycat Bashful Grey Bunny Soother 13.5in
Made with silky bamboo fabric that’s gentle on sensitive skin and easy to wash.
Angel Dear Lovey
Features textured tags babies love to explore while cuddling.
mary meyer lovey - Baby Blankets, Rattles & Mats
Bedtime & Nursery Plush Friends
Extra-cozy plush toys that feel comforting at night and looks sweet on nursery shelves.
Designed to support emotional comfort while still being soft and huggable for bedtime routines.
Slumberkins
Chunky, cuddly, and irresistibly soft—great for rocking-chair snuggles.
GUND Stuffed Bear | Teddy Bears & Plush Animals
Beautifully made with heirloom-style charm that doubles as nursery decor.
Plush Toy Lamb
Baby Shower & Keepsake Plush Gifts
Thoughtful plush toys that feel extra special and gift-ready.
A meaningful keepsake plush that can be personalized with baby’s name.
Cubbies Bunny, Personalised Gift, Great Birthday Gift for Kids ...
A luxury plush with heirloom quality—ideal for milestone gifting.
Steiff Teddy Bears
A soft, cuddly elephant plush with baby’s birth stats embroidered or printed right on it — a meaningful keepsake and a snuggly friend for the nursery!
