Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Spookiest and Most Unique Halloween Cookie Cutters
25
items Bake up a bunch of festive and spooky treats this Halloween season, with unusual creepy cookie cutters you don't see everywhere else. Everybody can make a jack o' lantern or pumpkin cookie, but I've found more clever, unique designs you can use for c...
Here are 3D figural pumpkin cookie cutters from Sur la Table. They let you make standing pumpkins as well as a set of stacked tiered graduated pumpkins. So different than anything else out there! Love it.
Sur La Table 3-D Pumpkin Patch Cookie Cutters, Set of 11
These jack o' lantern cookie cutters from Sur la Table have goofier facial expressions than most other Halloween cookie cutters. Love it! So dorky.
Jack-o'-Lantern Cookie Cutters, Set of 14
Here are Williams-Sonoma's Halloween impression cookie cutters. Be sure to read the included recipe and directions for how to bake these without the cookie spreading and losing the impression. The set includes a jack o' lantern, a cobweb with spider,...
Williams Sonoma Halloween Impression Cookie Cutters, Set of 22
Here's a very unique haunted house cookie cutter from the Sweet Pink Olive shop on Etsy. It comes in many sizes, ranging from a small 2" cutter to make mini haunted house cookies, up to a gigantic 10" cookie cutter. I would love to surprise the heck ...
Blushed Bakes by Reva’s Haunted House 2 Halloween Cookie Cutter, Fondant and playdoh cutters too!
Here's a unique cookie cutter I haven't seen before: a Build a Skeleton cookie cutter set. You'd definitely want to have a coffin shaped treat box to present these in. Love the bow on the skeleton's head!
Halloween Build a Skeleton Cookie Cutter Set, Fondant and playdoh cutters too!
This creative and unique cookie cutter from the Sweet Pink Olive shop lets you create beautiful and elegant gothic coffin cookies. The coffin is decorated with frosting roses you could customize yourself for style and color.
Halloween, Floral Coffin, Day of the Dead Cookie Cutter
Here's a clever set of Halloween cookie cutters that help you make your own haunted village. It's by the Lelano Cookie Cutters shop on Etsy.
BYO Haunted Village Cookie Cutters
This is the scariest Halloween haunted house cookie I've ever seen! You can make one at home using this haunted house cookie cutter from Lelano Cookie Cutters on Etsy.
Haunted House Cookie Cutter
Lelano Cookie Cutters makes this distinctive set of cookie cutters that help you create a Halloween haunted whimsical village made from sugar cookies.
Haunted whimsical village cookie cutter set of 7
This Witch's Porch cookie cutter is the most unique I've ever seen! It looks like the cookie would take a very long time to decorate properly. You'd have the best Halloween cookie in town!
Witch's Porch Cookie Cutters
Here's a selection of really cool house-shaped cookie cutters you can use to make witchy Halloween haunted house cookies. Choose between a cottage, an A-frame, a brownstone, a mansion, a modern or a traditional home.
Arlo's Cookies Houses Cookie Cutters
Here's a unique retro style witch cookie cutter. You can customize her skin color, witch hat ribbon color, and her hair depending on the royal icing you use.
Retro Vintage Style Side View Witch Cookie Cutter
I'm not sure my royal icing frosting skills are up to decorating this adorable retro style black cat cookie, but you might give it a go! This Halloween cookie cutter features a vintage style black cat with a bow tie. It's so adorable! It's from the L...
retro vintage halloween cookie cutter screaming cat with bow
This witchy Halloween cookie cutter is from the Ez Cookie Cuts shop on Etsy. This cookie cutter helps you bake a witch flying on her broomstick in front of a crescent moon.
Flying_Witch Crescent_Moon Cookie Cutter – Spellbound & Sweet! – Two Styles to Choose!
Cut out, bake and decorate your own Labubu witch hat cookies this Halloween! This unique cookie cutter is from the EZ Cookie Cuts shop on Etsy.
Fuzzy Witch Monster Head Cookie Cutter – Cute, Spooky & Full of Charm!
There are a ton of witch shoe Halloween cookie cutters out there, but this one is my favorite because of the whimsical shapes. I love the cuff, the curly toe, and the shape of the high heel on this witch's boot cookie.
Witch Boot Cookie Cutter – Where Spells Meet Style!
Here's a sophisticated vintage style Dracula cookie cutter you could use to make amazing figural vampire cookies for your Halloween soiree. It's from the EZ Cookie Cuts shop on Etsy.
Dracula cookie cutter – a bite of vintage horror! - spooky nostalgia for your sweet tooth!
I've seen a ton of Jack Skellington cookie cutters, but never a really nice detailed Mayor of Halloweentown cookie cutter like this one. Use it to make cookies for your Nightmare Before Christmas themed Halloween party!
Mayor Cookie Cutter | Nightmare Christmas Cookie Cutter | Halloween Party Baking
Here's a detailed Frankenstein's Monster cookie cutter you can use to make intricate cookies for your Halloween monster party. This cutter is from the EZ Cookie Cuts shop on Etsy.
Vintage Frankenstein Cookie Cutter – Spooky Nostalgia for Your Sweet Tooth!
I've seen SO many sugar skull cookie cutters, but here's the first whole ofrenda (altar) cookie cutter I've seen! Now you can cut out, bake and decorate adorable El Dia de Los Muertos sugar skull altar cookies for your spooky season parties.
DIA Altar Cookie Cutter – Celebrate with Sweet Tradition!
Here's a quirky, whimsical set of cookie cutters based on The Nightmare Before Christmas. I love the expressions on their faces: Jack: plotting. Sally: smirking. Zero: Pure joy.
Nightmare Christmas_Set_A Cookie Cutter Set | Jack Skellington, Sally and Zero | Halloween & Christmas Cookie Cutters
Here are Halloween cookie cutters you can use to make Hocus Pocus Sanderson Sister cookies. The set also includes a cauldron that says "I Smell Children" and a cutter to make Binx the cat.
Witch Sister Cookie Cutters- Halloween
Bake up a set of spooky Halloween cookies with these ouija board cookie cutters. They're made by the Sweet Elite Cutters shop on Etsy.
Ouiji Planchette Cookie Cutter
Now you can make creepy Medusa cookie cutters for your Halloween party. This cookie cutter depicts snakes writhing around Medusa's head. It's from the Narwhal Star Studio on Etsy.
63mm Medusa and Her Snakes (Updated) - Embossed Sharp Cookie Cutter
Use this cookie cutter from Narwhal Star Studio to make elegant damask skull cookies for your Halloween soiree.
Damask Skull Embossed Sharp Cookie Cutter