Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Witch City: Terrifying Toys
34
items Tabitha offers creepy dolls, spooky plush toys, scary jack-in-the-boxes, Halloween-themed toys and witch-themed playthings. Perhaps you'll find your favorite new doll companion, a creepy clown, or a cuddly plushie here.
This Warmies "Purple Bat" plush toy can be warmed in the microwave. It's softly scented with lavender to help your little one sleep.
Purple Wing Bat Warmies
This adorable handmade crocheted amigurumi witch doll comes in four sizes. You can choose between 5.9" tall all the way through 12" tall. She's so charming!
Crochet Witch Doll Plush – Handmade Amigurumi Halloween Girl with Hat and Bag, Cute Stuffed Toy, Fall Décor Gift for Kids, AI Generated
Here's the Handmade by Robots "Frozen Jack Torrance" vinyl figure, based on the character from my favorite horror movie, "The Shining."
Handmade by Robots figures are like Funko Pops, only cooler and scarier.
Handmade by Robots - Doctor Sleep Jack Torrance #130
If you want your own creepy little Ghost Face toy peering at you on your desk or from a nearby bookshelf or curio cabinet, here's your chance! It's the Handmade by Robots vinyl collectible toy. (Like Funko, but more textured and terrifying).
Handmade by Robots - Ghost Face
This terrifying vinyl toy is Handmade by Robots' Leatherface, dressed as a pretty woman. He's from The Texas Chainsaw Massacre films.
Handmade by Robots - Texas Chainsaw Massacre Leatherface Pretty Woman #070
This vinyl collectible toy from Handmade by Robots is made to look like it's knitted. It depicts the villain "Buffalo Bill" from the Silence of the Lambs film.
Handmade by Robots - Silence of the Lambs #075
This plush Annabelle doll could almost be cute, if not for her freaky staring eyes. This is Kidrobot's plush toy Annabelle doll based on The Conjuring universe.
Kidrobot Conjuring Annabelle 8in Phunny
I'm actually quite frightened of Oogie Boogie, for some reason. But this Just Play Toys plushie is pretty cute, I have to admit.
Just Play Disney Tim Burton Oogie Boogie Plush
Here's KidRobot's Beetlejuice Phunny Plush toy. His hair is really.. just.. wow!
Kidrobot Beetlejuice Red Tuxedo Phunny Plush
I'm not sure I could actually sleep in a room with this scary Barbara Maitland Phunny Plush toy from Beetlejuice. I might have to cover her with a pillow or coat or something.
Kidrobot Beetlejuice 7.5" Phunny Plush
Here's the other half of the Maitland couple from Tim Burton's Beetlejuice film: Adam. He's by KidRobot's Phunny Plush.
Kidrobot Beetlejuice 7.5" Phunny Plush
Funko Pop hardly ever makes any plush toys. But when they do, they are cute and creepy. Here's their take on Annabelle, the scary doll from The Conjuring universe.
Funko Pop! Plush: Horror - Annabelle
She's tiny but mighty! This bendable Annabelle action figure is only six inches tall. She's from The Noble Collection's toy line.
The Noble Collection Bendable Annabelle
This Funko Pop collectible vinyl figure depicts the creepy doll Annabelle from The Conjuring movies, sitting in her chair. Rocking, rocking, rocking...
Funko Pop Movies: Annabelle-Annabelle in Chair
This blow mold Annabelle doll from The Conjuring lights up. She looks SO cool, and creepy, at night! Once I snuck her into my friend's tent at night when they were camping.. muwahahaha.
Spirit Halloween The Conjuring Light-Up Annabelle
Now you can buy your precious little girl a collectible Annabelle keepsake doll to befriend and play with. Hrm, perhaps you shouldn't..
Star images 18" Annabelle Prop Replica Doll
What's more terrifying than an Annabelle doll? A TALKING life size Annabelle doll!
Spirit Halloween Annabelle Life-Size Doll
Spirit Halloween's plush Annabelle doll is delightfully saucy and smirking. She wears the trademark white dress with red sash and accents.
Spirit Halloween Annabelle Plush Décor
Here is Barrel, one of Oogie's Boys from The Nightmare Before Christmas. It's a Phunny Plush toy from NECA.
The Nightmare Before Christmas Phunny Barrel Plush
This Squishmallows plush toy depicts Jack Skellington yelling. It's a Nightmare Before Christmas licensed plushie.
Squishmallows 8-Inch Jack Skellington Plush
This vinyl collectable toy is M3GAN from the horror movie. It's by Handmade by Robots, and it's meant to look like it's hand knitted.
Handmade by Robots - M3GAN #258
This vinyl collector toy from Handmade by Robots is Bride of Chucky. She looks like she's had a fearsomely bad day.
Handmade by Robots Bride of Chucky Tiffany #228
This vinyl collector toy from Handmade by Robots depicts Regan from The Exorcist during the worst moment of her life. I should point out that this version of the toy glows in the dark. Extra terrifying!
Handmade by Robots - The Exorcist Regan Glow #122
Here's a teeny tiny micro version of The Nun by Handmade by Robots. She looks very angry!
Handmade by Robots - The Nun #011 Vinyl
Here's the teeny tiny micro version of Handmade by Robots' "Annabelle" vinyl figure based on the character from The Conjuring. She looks sweet - don't be deceived!
Handmade by Robots - Annabelle #014 Vinyl
Here is Universal Monsters' Frankenstein's Monster, by Handmade by Robots. He's vinyl, but made to look like he is hand knitted. He glows in the dark!
Handmade by Robots - Frankenstein #237 Glow
This glow in the dark vinyl collector figure is The Wolfman from the Universal Monsters series. He's by Handmade by Robots, and is part of their Knitted line.
Handmade by Robots - Wolf Man #248 Glow
Here's your chance to own and display a glow in the dark Dracula vinyl collector figure! He's by Handmade by Robots.
Handmade by Robots - Dracula #240 Glow
This terrifying toy is a vinyl collector figure from Handmade by Robots. It depicts Leatherface from The Texas Chainsaw Massacre. I'm shivering just looking at him!
Handmade by Robots Texas Chainsaw Massacre Leatherface #394 (Metallic)
Cuddly, or creepy? Here's a death's head moth plush toy from the Squishable line of plushies.
Squishable/Mini Death's-Head Hawkmoth Plush Toy
If you like death's head moths, you might also enjoy this mini poison hawk moth plush toy from Squishable!
Squishable / Mini Poison Hawkmoth Plush
Here's the Squishable mini Mothman plush toy. As we gaze into his serene red eyes, we can only wonder what he's plotting.
Squishable/Mini Baby Mothman Plush Toy
This plush Plague Doctor toy is pretty big, standing 16 inches tall. He's cuddly but fierce.
Plague Doctor 16" Weighted Plush Toy
This frightening plushie is a hellion from the Cthulhu mythos. He has tentacles and red eyes that blaze into your soul.
Pacific Giftware Hellion Cthulhu Plush