Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Cookie Decorating Station I Set Up Every Christmas Eve With My Kids
30
items Every December 23rd I used to scramble through junk drawers looking for sprinkles from last year and end up with a sticky counter, crying toddler, and cookies that looked like abstract art. This is the exact setup I now pull together in under 20 minu...
Sections
6
Cookie Dough and Baking Mixes That Don't Require a Pastry Degree
Cookie Cutters That Actually Cut Clean Lines
Icing and Frosting That Won't Turn Into a Puddle
Sprinkles and Toppings That Make Cookies Look Finished
Station Setup Supplies So Your Table Survives the Night
Finishing Touches That Make It Feel Like a Real Tradition
Cookie Dough and Baking Mixes That Don't Require a Pastry Degree
I used to make dough from scratch and by the time it was ready, the kids had lost interest and wandered off to watch TV. These roll-out-and-go options keep everyone at the table.
Grab this if you want dough that actually holds its shape when tiny hands press cookie cutters into it. Last year my 4-year-old made a recognizable star on the first try. That had never happened before with homemade dough.
Pumpkin Pie Sugar Cookies Recipe
Keep a tube of this as backup for when the mixed dough runs out and someone starts crying. I pull it from the fridge, slice, bake, done. Specifically for the parent who knows round two of decorating is inevitable.
Pillsbury Ready to Bake Refrigerated Sugar Cookie Dough
Use this for the darker cookies so kids can tell them apart from sugar cookies on the plate. Smells incredible baking and my oldest now requests it specifically. Way less fuss than hunting down molasses at 9pm.
Betty Crocker Gingerbread Cake and Cookie Mix, 14.5 oz.
Toss this in the cart if someone at your table has a gluten sensitivity. My sister-in-law cried the first Christmas she could actually decorate and eat the cookies with everyone else.
Simple Mills Almond Flour Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix
Snag this if you want cutters, sprinkles, and mix all in one box. I bought it as a lazy backup and it ended up being the thing my kids reached for first. Under five bucks, which felt almost suspicious.
Great Value Holiday Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Kit
Cookie Cutters That Actually Cut Clean Lines
I threw away my old cookie cutters after realizing they were the reason every snowman looked like a blob. These ones press clean and pop out easy, even from soft dough.
Try the candy cane and the tree shapes first. They're deep enough that dough doesn't stick inside the edges. My kids fight over the star so I bought two sets. Problem solved.
Wilton Metal Holiday Cookie Cutters, 12-Piece Set
Get these if your cutters keep bending out of shape. The metal is thicker than what I had before, and after three Christmases they still look brand new. For anyone tired of wobbly gingerbread men.
R&M International Christmas Mini Cookie Cutter 6 Piece Set
Pair these with the shaped cutters for making ornament cookies. My daughter layers a small circle on top of a bigger one with different colored icing. She's eight and honestly her cookies look better than mine now.
Ateco 5457 Stainless Plain Edge Round Cutter Set - 12 / ST
Use this one if you have a toddler helping. The rubber grip on top means little hands can press down hard without the metal edge hurting. My 3-year-old calls it “the squishy one” and won't use anything else.
Wilton Gingerbread Boy Comfort Grip Cookie Cutter
Swap your plain cutters for these if you want built-in patterns. They stamp a design right into the dough before baking. Saves decorating time and makes even uniced cookies look intentional.
Sweet Creations 3D Mini Christmas Tree Cookie Cutter Kit
Icing and Frosting That Won't Turn Into a Puddle
Two years ago I made royal icing from a recipe online and it slid right off every cookie onto the cooling rack. Never again. These actually stay where you put them.
Grab the pouches over the tubs. The tip is already attached so there's no piping bag disaster. I hand one to each kid and let them go. Cleanup took me four minutes last year.
Wilton, Ready-to-Use Blue Vanilla-Flavored Icing Pouch
Keep all three colors out at once. Kids will argue over red first, then green, then white becomes the favorite by round two. For families who want color variety without mixing anything.
Betty Crocker Decorating Icing Tube, Red, 4.25 Ounces
Use this if you want that hard, glossy finish on cookies. Mix it, spread it, walk away. It dries firm in about an hour. I finally got cookies that looked like the Pinterest photo instead of a melted mess.
Wilton, Royal Icing, 14oz, White Stiff Consistency Ready-To
Toss a can in the cart as the “base layer” frosting. Spread it thick, then let kids pile sprinkles on top. It's forgiving and cheap enough that I don't wince when half of it ends up on the table.
Great Value Vanilla Frosting Tub, White, 16 oz
Try the squeeze bottles if your kids are between 5 and 8. More control than a pouch, less mess than a tub. My son drew an actual face on a gingerbread man last year and we all lost it.
Wilton White Cookie Icing Set, 2-Count
Sprinkles and Toppings That Make Cookies Look Finished
Plain frosted cookies are fine but the second you dump a bowl of sprinkles on the table, kids light up. These are the ones that survived the sticky-finger test at our house.
Get the six-cell container because each kid can claim their own color. Stopped about 90% of the sprinkle fights at our table. The snowflake-shaped ones are weirdly popular with adults too.
Wilton 6-Cell Assorted Christmas Sprinkles, 6.7 oz.
Bring this out for the kid who just wants to dump an entire container on one cookie. It's cheap enough that you won't care, and the mix of shapes keeps it looking festive even when applied with zero precision.
Betty Crocker Christmas Mix Sprinkles 6 oz
Use these for eyeballs and buttons on gingerbread men. They're small enough for detail work but big enough that a 5-year-old can pick them up. My daughter lines them up perfectly and it's honestly impressive.
Wilton Sugar Pearl Sprinkles 5 oz White Edible Cake
Snag these tiny round ones for the kid who wants “rainbow cookies for Santa.” Not traditional Christmas colors but my son insists Santa likes rainbow better, and honestly who am I to argue with that logic.
Great Value Non Pareil Sprinkles, Rainbow, 3.15 oz
Toss this on star cookies and they actually sparkle under the kitchen light. My neighbor asked if I bought the cookies from a bakery. I said yes because the truth felt too braggy.
Wilton Gold Sanding Sugar Edible Sprinkles 2.6 oz. Bottle
Station Setup Supplies So Your Table Survives the Night
The first year I did this, our dining table had frosting ground into the wood grain for months. Now I lay everything out on stuff I can toss or wipe clean in seconds.
Lay sheets of this across your whole table before anything comes out. When decorating is done, roll it up, sprinkles and all, and throw it away. I will never scrape dried icing off wood again.
Great Value Ultra Strong Paper Towels, 6 Double Rolls
Use these as sprinkle stations. Pour each type into its own cup so kids can reach in and grab. Way less spillage than flat bowls. Toss them after. For the parent who refuses to wash one more dish on Christmas Eve.
Hefty Party On Disposable Plastic Party Cups, Blue
Grab these pre-cut sheets instead of fighting with a roll that curls up. They lay flat on the pan immediately. Sounds small but when you're juggling excited kids and a hot oven, flat paper feels like a miracle.
Reynolds Kitchens Cookie Baking Sheets
Switch to these if your old pans have that dark burnt layer that makes everything stick. The light-colored surface bakes more evenly and cookies slide right off. I retired my college-era pans and never looked back.
Mainstays 3-Piece Nonstick Cookie Sheet Set, Gray
Keep the canister right on the table during decorating. Sticky fingers get wiped between cookies so frosting colors don't turn brown. Also saves you from finding dried sprinkles stuck to chairs three days later.
Clorox Scentiva Wipes Coconut Waterlily 75ct
Finishing Touches That Make It Feel Like a Real Tradition
Setting out cookies for Santa went from an afterthought to the part my kids talk about all January. These small details made it feel like something they'll actually remember.
Pair this with a glass of milk and your kids will lose their minds. My son checks the plate first thing Christmas morning before even looking at presents. Four bucks and it's become the most important dish we own.
Holiday Time Red Santa Ceramic Serving Tray
Toss a stack of these on the table for wiping hands and wrapping cookies to take home. Last year my daughter wrapped two cookies in a napkin “for Santa's reindeer” and left them on the porch. I ate them at midnight.
Great Value Disposable Paper Napkins, 12x12
Get a couple of these for the kids who take decorating seriously. My daughter puts hers on and announces she's “the head baker” and suddenly the whole operation runs smoother. Also saves their pajamas from frosting stains.
Holiday Time Christmas Gingerbread Apron
Use these to bag up extra decorated cookies for neighbors or teachers. The holiday print makes it look like you put in effort. I hand them out December 26th and people act like I gave them something expensive.
Ziploc® Brand Holiday Storage Gallon Slider Bags
Try setting finished cookies on this so kids can admire their work. My son stood there for ten minutes arranging his cookies by “best to worst” and narrating the rankings. Worth it for the entertainment alone.
Wilton Stacked 4-Tier Cupcake and Dessert Tower