Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!

Eastern Long Island, NY favorites

Purple Star emoji 9 items
I no longer live on Long Island but please enjoy my favorite places in honor of me!
Map
Sections
4
 
 
 
 

Italian

 
Cynthia Romero profile picture
A wonderful local owned restaurant. The workers who work behind the scenes in the kitchen craft these wonderful plates with intentionality and love what they do.
Cafe Gia

Mediterranean

 
Cynthia Romero profile picture
An excellent place to dine in eastern Long Island. I’ve been to this place for over 20 years. Their chicken kebab was my favorite menu item!
Pita House
 
Cynthia Romero profile picture
The gyro was my favorite item off the menu to order! They have a great online order portion that is user friendly.
Hampton Gyro of Riverhead

Burgers

 
Cynthia Romero profile picture
This is the first Long Island branch of the franchise “Ford’s Garage.” The signature burger is my favorite of all. It is worth the visit, not to mention the beautiful building aesthetic highlighting the Ford vehicles across all decades.
Ford's Garage Smith Haven
 
Cynthia Romero profile picture
Go Burger in Ridge was a favorite place of mine to frequent. A local owned restaurant filled with great customer service.
Go Burger RIDGE
 
Cynthia Romero profile picture
This is a beautiful please to have gatherings with friends and coworkers. I love the customer service! Their drifter’s original burger was my go to order each time I went.
Drifter's Kitchen and Bar

Bagel Shops and Deli

 
Cynthia Romero profile picture
This is the place I frequented the most. I truly enjoyed their two egg whites, American cheese on sourdough bread. Their coffee was also very tasty!
Wine Country Deli & Catering
 
Cynthia Romero profile picture
I enjoyed their strawberry bagels they had to offer. Great customer service when I went!
Strathmore Bagel Cafe
 
Cynthia Romero profile picture
I enjoyed getting their iced coffee with honey. I frequented this coffee shop a lot in summer 2025.
Hampton Coffee Company