30
items 
Our first reservation vanished into thin air — the host just shrugged. These three places actually respected the occasion and gave us a table where I could get on one knee without elbowing a stranger.










First hotel had a ‘caldera view’ that was technically a sliver of blue between two construction sites. Moved hotels mid-trip and it saved the whole week.










Every sunset spot I'd bookmarked from social media was a wall of selfie sticks. These three gave us breathing room and honestly better angles.










Sitting poolside every day sounds great until day three when you're restless and sunburned. These got us moving and gave us stories we still retell at dinner parties.










Red Beach looked incredible in photos and terrible in person — overcrowded, no shade, and the walk down nearly killed my knees. These were the ones that actually delivered.










Restaurant fatigue hit us by day four. These broke up the fancy-dinner cycle and honestly produced some of our favorite bites of the whole trip.










Rented an ATV on day one and nearly drove off a cliff because nobody mentioned the roads have no guardrails. Switched strategies after that near-death experience.










My proposal photos were almost just shaky selfies because I forgot to plan this part. Booked a photographer last-minute and those pictures are now framed in our hallway.










By the time she said yes, my shoulders were up by my ears from a week of secret-keeping. These spots unknotted me physically and mentally.










Brought home a magnet and a keychain from my first Europe trip and regretted not getting something meaningful. This time I came back with things we actually use and look at.








