Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Tried Off Brand Snacks My Kids Can't Tell Apart From Originals
36
items Grocery bills were eating my paycheck alive, and my kids would riot if I switched their favorite snacks. So I ran blind taste tests at our kitchen table for three months straight. These store brand and budget snacks passed the kid test every single t...
Sections
6
Crunchy Chip Swaps That Fooled Everyone
Cookie Dupes That Survived the Lunchbox Test
Cracker Alternatives Kids Actually Reach For
Sweet Treat Swaps for After Dinner
Fruit Snack and Gummy Dupes They Devour
Drink and Snack Bar Swaps Worth Stocking Up On
Crunchy Chip Swaps That Fooled Everyone
My oldest is a Doritos loyalist who once spotted a generic bag from across the room. These chips sat in the Doritos bowl and he grabbed handful after handful without a single complaint.
Swap these into your regular chip bowl on taco night. My son ate half the bag and asked me to buy more Doritos. I just smiled and said nothing.
Great Value Nacho Cheese Tortilla Chips, 2.5 oz Bag
Bring these to a cookout and nobody will ask why you didn't get Lay's. The crunch is identical and the flavor dust actually sticks to the chip instead of falling to the bottom of the bag.
Great Value Sour Cream and Onion Potato Chips
Try these if your kid lives for Ruffles Cheddar and Sour Cream. Poured them into a bowl for movie night and my daughter said they tasted even cheesier than usual.
Great Value Cheddar and Sour Cream Potato Chips Party
Keep a bag in the pantry for sandwiches and school lunches. They're thinner and crispier than Lay's Classic, honestly. At half the price I felt a little silly for waiting so long.
Great Value Original Potato Chips, 2.25 oz
Use these for nachos and queso dipping. My picky 7-year-old declared them perfect, and she rejects anything that looks slightly different from what she's used to.
Great Value Bite Size Tortilla Chips, 13 oz Bag
Grab these for dip nights. The ridges hold French onion dip just as well as Ruffles, and you save enough to actually buy the good dip too.
Great Value Lightly Salted Wavy Potato Chips, 7.5 oz
Cookie Dupes That Survived the Lunchbox Test
Packing lunches five days a week was draining my cookie budget fast. I rotated these in and not one note came home saying the cookies were wrong.
Toss a few in a lunchbox and watch them disappear. My kids' friends started asking for the Oreos at our house and they've been eating these for six months without catching on.
Great Value Twist & Shout Chocolate Sandwich Cookies
1
Perfect for the kid who counts exactly how many cookies they get. These are the same tiny size as Chips Ahoy Minis and they taste like someone's grandma actually made them.
Great Value Mini Semi-Sweet Chocolate Baking Chips 12
Pair these with a glass of milk after school. My daughter said they're better than Keebler because the fudge layer is thicker. She's not wrong.
Great Value Fudge Striped Shortbread Cookies, 11.5 oz
Get these if your kids fight over vanilla vs chocolate. Both flavors in one package ended a daily argument at my house and saved me from buying two separate packs.
VALUE Definition & Meaning
Snag a pack for road trips. They're lighter and crunchier than the Little Debbie version, and they don't crumble into a million pieces all over the car seat.
Great Value Peanut Butter Wafer Bars, 2 oz, 6 Count
Try these for a slightly less sugary option that still feels like a treat. My son thinks they're the Mother's brand ones. I nod along every time.
Great Value Iced Oatmeal Flavor Cookies, 18 oz
Cracker Alternatives Kids Actually Reach For
Goldfish crackers alone were costing me $5 a week. I needed crackers that could survive a toddler's standards and a preschooler's suspicion of anything new.
Pour these into a snack cup and hand them to your toddler. Same fish shape, same orange dust on tiny fingers. My 3-year-old calls them fishies and has zero clue.
Great Value Cheddar Cheese Baked Snack Crackers, 21 oz
Use these anywhere you'd use Ritz. They work for peanut butter stacks, mini sandwiches, and topping casseroles. Crumble just the same and cost about a dollar less per box.
Great Value Chick'n Bites Baked Snack Crackers, 7.5 oz
Swap these for Cheez-Its and see if anyone notices. My husband didn't figure it out for two weeks, and he's the pickiest one in the house.
Annie's Organic Cheddar Squares, Baked Cracker Snacks
Toss a handful into soup bowls. Kids who need crackers floating in their tomato soup won't spot any difference. Bought three bags last winter and never looked back.
Great Value Soup & Oyster Crackers, 9 oz
Grab these if you're trying to sneak a little more fiber into after-school snacking. They taste like Triscuits but crumble less, which means fewer crumbs ground into my couch.
Great Value Whole Wheat Buttery Rounds Baked Crackers
Keep a sleeve in your bag for hangry meltdowns at the store. They're the same flaky, salty bite as Club Crackers and they've prevented at least four public tantrums.
Great Value Baked Buttery Round Crackers, 13.7 oz
Sweet Treat Swaps for After Dinner
Dessert demands happen nightly at my house. Buying name brand treats every week was adding up to a second grocery bill, so I quietly started switching things out.
Try handing one of these to a kid who loves Little Debbie Fudge Rounds. Same gooey chocolate layers, same sticky fingers. Absolutely no complaints from my crew.
Little Debbie Snacks Fudge Rounds, 8ct
Stick these in the toaster on rushed mornings. My kids swore they were Pop-Tarts until my oldest found the box in recycling. She shrugged and asked for another one.
Great Value Frosted Strawberry Toaster Pastries
Pack these for soccer practice snacks. They're soft, sweet, and every kid on the team grabbed one without questioning the brand. Way cheaper when you're feeding a whole squad.
Great Value Marshmallows, 10 oz Bag
Swap these for Hostess and see what happens. The frosting swirl looks identical. My son lined them up next to each other once and picked the store brand as the real one.
Great Value Creme Filled Chocolate Cupcakes, 16 oz
Warm one up for 10 seconds in the microwave and it tastes fresh from a bakery. For kids who demand something warm and sweet on cold mornings, this is it.
Great Value Glazed Honey Buns, 10.5 oz, 6 Count
Grab a box for the peanut butter lover in your house. Crunchy wafer, thick peanut butter, chocolate coating. My daughter ranked them above Little Debbie in a blind test.
Great Value Peanut Butter Wafer Bars, 2 oz, 6 Count
Fruit Snack and Gummy Dupes They Devour
My kids would eat their body weight in Welch's fruit snacks if I let them. Finding cheaper versions that passed their taste buds took some trial and error, but these made the cut.
Toss a pouch in every lunchbox and backpack pocket. Same squishy texture as Mott's, same fruity burst. My kids go through a box a week and have never questioned the switch.
Great Value Fruit Smiles Snacks, Original Flavor, 40 Count
Use these for road trip bribery. They look and taste close enough to Welch's that my daughter, who inspects every snack like a detective, approved them on the first try.
Welch's Mixed Fruit Fruit Snacks Value Pack, 0.9 oz
Pour these into a candy dish and watch them vanish. Softer than Haribo, which actually works better for younger kids. My 4-year-old prefers them and I'm not about to argue.
Great Value Gummy Bears Candy, 52 oz Bag
Bring these to birthday parties as a backup treat. They've got that same sour-sweet combo kids go wild for, and the bag is big enough to share without running out halfway through.
Great Value Gummy Worms Chewy Candy, 48 oz Bag
Swap these for Fruit Roll-Ups on grocery day. My son unrolls them the same way, plays with them the same way, and eats them the same way. Zero difference detected.
Great Value Fruit Strips, Mixed Berry and Strawberry
Snag these if you want to feel slightly better about the fruit snack habit. They've got veggie juice blended in and my kids have no idea. A small parenting win I'll take.
Great Value Fruit Smiles Snacks, Tangy Flavor, 40 Count
Drink and Snack Bar Swaps Worth Stocking Up On
Between juice boxes, granola bars, and pouches, I was spending more on portable snacks than actual meals. These swapped in without a single whine from the backseat.
Keep a flat of these in the garage for grab-and-go mornings. They taste exactly like Mott's boxes and my kids' only complaint was that I didn't buy enough. Budget problem solved.
Great Value 100% Apple Juice, 96 fl oz
Throw one in your kid's bag for practice or tutoring. Same chewy, chocolatey bar as Quaker, but you get more bars per box. My pantry stays stocked for half the price now.
Great Value Chocolate Chip Chewy Granola Bars Family
Try these for the kid who wants something breakfasty but refuses to sit down and eat. Strawberry filling, soft crust. Tastes like Nutri-Grain and fits in a coat pocket.
Great Value Fruit & Grain Cereal Bars, Mixed Berry
Grab a box for movie nights and school snacks. Individual bags mean no fighting over portions. My kids think it's Skinny Pop and I have not corrected them once.
Great Value Popcorn Snacks Cookies Chips Variety
Use this on sandwiches, apple slices, and celery sticks. It's thick, salty, and crunchy in all the right places. Switched from Jif eight months ago and nobody has said a word.
Great Value Crunchy Peanut Butter, 40 oz
Stock up on the big tub and portion them into baggies for the week. Same vanilla-sweet flavor as Barnum's, same tiny animal shapes. My toddler sorts them by animal before eating, completely fooled.
Shop Animal Crackers Graham Snacks for Kids