Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Pumpkin Products That Made My Pets (and Me) Lose It This Fall
48
items Every autumn I go overboard on pumpkin everything — candles, skincare, lip balms — and somehow my dog starts sniffing my face like I'm a treat. If you're the type who wants to smell like a pumpkin patch from October through January and your pets keep...
Sections
10
Pumpkin-Scented Body Care That Lingers All Day
Warm Spice Fragrances My Dog Keeps Sniffing
Pumpkin-Toned Lip Colors for Fall Faces
Pumpkin Spice Skincare That Actually Does Something
Warm-Toned Eyeshadow Palettes for Pumpkin Season
Candle-Like Scents That Make My Whole Bathroom Smell Like Fall
Pumpkin-Scented Body Care That Lingers All Day
My cat literally followed me around the house after I used one of these. I wanted something warm and spicy without smelling like a Yankee Candle factory — these nailed it.
Swap your regular lotion for this when the temperature drops — the warm caramel-vanilla base plays like a cousin to pumpkin spice, and my dog tried to lick my ankles after I put it on. Perfect if you want cozy without smelling like a literal pie.
Bum Bum Body Cream
Use this right out of the shower and the warm amber scent sticks around for hours. My roommate's cat curled up on my lap within five minutes of applying it — coincidence or not, I'm keeping this stocked through March.
Body Soufflé
Grab this if your skin gets flaky the second October hits. It's rich without being greasy, and the subtle herbal-warm scent mixes beautifully with any pumpkin fragrance you layer on top.
Nécessaire The Body Lotion Eucalyptus
Toss this in your bag for dry-hand emergencies — the warm rose-vanilla scent gives autumn vibes without trying too hard. My pet sitter actually asked what perfume I was wearing. It was just this.
OUAI St. Barts Body Crème
Keep this on your nightstand for before-bed slathering. Rich enough to fix those cracked elbows by morning, and the subtle warmth pairs with any pumpkin candle you've got burning. My retriever approves.
Creme de Corps Collection - Body - Kiehl's Since 1851
Warm Spice Fragrances My Dog Keeps Sniffing
Tried six perfumes last fall — these are the ones that made my golden retriever shove his nose into my wrist every single time. Warm, spicy, cozy without being cloying.
Spritz this on a chilly morning and watch your pet investigate your neck for twenty minutes straight. Smoky, woody, a little sweet — it's the closest thing to smelling like a cabin without actually going anywhere.
Replica by the Fireplace Perfume
Try this if you want to literally bottle the smell of crunching through leaves. My dog went absolutely bonkers sniffing my jacket after I wore this to a pumpkin patch. Lasts all day, too.
REPLICA Autumn Vibes, Eau de Toilette by Maison Margiela
Pair this with any spicy body cream and you basically become a walking pumpkin chai latte. Warm, creamy, zero sharpness. For anyone who wants cozy without the department-store-perfume-counter energy.
Kayali Vanilla 28 Perfume
Snag this before your holiday party — one spray and you smell like the most interesting person in the room. My cat sat on my scarf for two hours after I wore this. Warm tobacco and vanilla, rich but not overwhelming.
Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille
Ditch anything citrusy for fall and switch to this — honeyed warmth with a spicy backbone. Wore it to a bonfire and three people asked what I had on. Even my friend's beagle was curious.
NEST New York Golden Nectar Eau de Parfum Duo Spray ...
Pumpkin-Toned Lip Colors for Fall Faces
Spent two autumns looking washed out before I figured out that the right pumpkin-orange lip shade actually wakes up my whole face. These are the ones I reach for when my summer tan is long gone.
Try this warm terracotta shade when your go-to nude starts looking lifeless in November lighting. Creamy formula, no flaking, and it stayed on through an entire corn maze without reapplying.
Nars Audacious Lipstick-Jane
Grab this burnt orange if you've been scared of warm lip colors — it's the gateway shade. Wore it to Thanksgiving dinner and my aunt who never compliments anything told me I looked great.
Mac Matte Lipstick
Toss this in your coat pocket for an instant warm-toned glossy lip on the go. Not sticky, smells faintly sweet, and my dog tried to kiss it off my face which honestly tracks.
ShineOn Lip Oil Jelly
Switch to this when you want that deep, warm berry-pumpkin vibe without committing to a bold lip. It looks different on everyone — my sister and I wear the same tube and look completely different.
Clinique - Black Honey Almost Lipstick
Pumpkin Spice Skincare That Actually Does Something
Real talk — most pumpkin skincare is just marketing. These actually have pumpkin enzymes or warming ingredients that made a visible difference on my dull fall skin. My cat sniffed every single one.
Use this once a week when your skin starts looking gray and tired in October. It tingles, smells like actual pumpkin pie, and my face looked like I got a facial after just ten minutes. My dog kept licking my chin.
Pumpkin Enzyme Mask Enzymatic Dermal Resurfacer
Grab this for mornings when your face looks like it didn't sleep even though you got eight hours. The citrusy-warm scent wakes you up, and it absorbs fast enough to put makeup over immediately.
Origins GinZing Energizing Gel Cream (Women)
Try this gentle scrub before any big fall event — it buffs off dead skin without being harsh, and the brown sugar scent is basically pumpkin-adjacent. My skin felt like silk for two days after.
Sugar Polish
Keep this for Sunday night resurfacing when a week of cold wind has wrecked your texture. Yes, it tingles. Yes, it works. Woke up Monday looking like a completely different person.
Skincare Drunk Elephant
Swap your summer moisturizer for this the second your skin starts feeling tight. Rich, plumping, zero greasiness. My cat rubbed her face against mine after I applied it, which I'm taking as a five-star review.
Tatcha Dewy Skin Cream Gives You Luxuriously Hydrated ...
Warm-Toned Eyeshadow Palettes for Pumpkin Season
Found myself reaching for the same three brown shades every fall until I actually invested in palettes with real depth — burnt oranges, warm coppers, deep spice tones that don't all look the same on the lid.
Grab this if you want one palette that handles every fall look from subtle office warmth to full smoky pumpkin eye. The shade Burnt Orange is worth the whole palette alone — blends like butter.
Anastasia Beverly Hills - Soft Glam Eyeshadow Palette
Use the warm copper and rose-gold shades for a five-minute fall eye that looks like you tried way harder than you did. Took this to a wedding and got compliments from strangers.
Pillow Talk – Instant Eyeshadow Palette
Try the rosy-warm shades here if straight-up orange scares you — it's pumpkin-adjacent without the commitment. Great for people who want autumn vibes but still lean toward neutrals.
Urban Decay Naked3 Soft Pink Eyeshadow Palette
Snag this literally pumpkin-themed palette if you're going all in. Smells like pumpkin spice (seriously), the shade range covers everything from latte to full-on jack-o'-lantern.
Too Faced Pumpkin Spice: Second Slice Eyeshadow Palette
Switch to this when you want those deep, earthy pumpkin tones without any glitter. Matte lovers, this is your fall lineup. Every shade is wearable and nothing pulls muddy on the lid.
25+ NARS Eyeshadow Palettes for sale | Updated Oct 2026
Candle-Like Scents That Make My Whole Bathroom Smell Like Fall
Started layering shower products with warm scents and now my bathroom smells like a pumpkin bakery without a single candle. Even the dog waits outside the bathroom door now.
Toss this in your shower and your whole bathroom smells like pumpkin bread for an hour. It's a three-in-one so it replaces half your bottles. Lathered up with this and my dog waited outside the door whimpering.
Philosophy Pumpkin Icing Shower Gel, Shampoo & Bubble ...
Use this if you want that warm caramel-meets-autumn shower experience. Doesn't strip your skin like most body washes, and the scent lingers on your towel long after you're done.
Brazilian Play Moisturizing Shower Cream-Gel - Sol de ...
Pair this with a warm-scented conditioner and your hair smells like an expensive fall candle all day. My coworker leaned in during a meeting and asked what shampoo I use. Worth every penny.
Oribe Gold Lust Repair & Restore Shampoo, SAMPLE
Keep this on your shower shelf for nights when you need to decompress. Clean, warm, soapy — it layers under spicier scents beautifully. My cat sits on the bath mat and purrs when I use it.
REPLICA Bubble Bath Perfume EDT | Maison Margiela Official
Grab this for a subtler warm floral that bridges summer into fall without feeling out of season. Light enough for daily use, fancy enough to make your shower feel like a spa moment.
OUAI Body Cleanser Melrose Place - Travel Size - 3 fl oz
Fall Blush Shades That Give Pumpkin Flush Without Looking Clownish
Spent one entire October looking like a clown because I picked the wrong warm blush. These give that flushed-from-the-cold, just-came-inside-from-a-hayride look without overdoing it.
Try the tiniest amount of this warm terracotta on your cheeks — tap, don't swipe. Looks like you just walked in from apple picking. A little goes absurdly far so this tube lasts through spring.
Rare Beauty - Grateful Soft Pinch Liquid Blush
Grab this peachy-warm shade if traditional pink blush washes you out in fall. Buildable, blendable, and it made my cheekbones look like they actually exist. Wore it every day for three weeks straight.
NARS Blush, Gina, .16 oz
Use the cream side first, dust the powder on top, and your blush literally will not budge through a full day of pumpkin patch photos. Warm-toned, natural, stays put.
Major Headlines Double-Take Crème & Powder Blush Duo
Dab this on cheeks, lips, and eyelids for a one-product warm glow. Perfect for the person who refuses to carry more than three things in their bag. My fastest fall face ever.
BeachPlease Tinted Balm for Lips + Cheeks
Switch to this neutral-warm shade when you want blush that whispers instead of shouts. It survived an outdoor fall wedding — eight hours, no touch-up, still looked freshly applied in photos.
Tarte Amazonian Clay 12-hour Skintuitive Blush~ New
Warming Body Oils My Pets Cannot Stop Investigating
Every time I use a body oil with any hint of warmth or sweetness, my pets act like I'm hiding food on my person. These smell incredible on skin and apparently also on dog noses.
Spritz this on damp skin after a shower and you'll glow like a fall goddess. Warm, slightly nutty scent. My golden retriever pressed his entire face into my forearm — took that as a strong endorsement.
NUXE Huile Prodigieuse Multi-Purpose Dry Oil
Use this on your legs before throwing on tights and the warmth radiates for hours. Smells like salted caramel on skin. My cat rubbed against my calves so aggressively she left fur on my jeans.
Bum Bum Body Firmeza Oil I Visibly Firming Oil ...
Keep a few drops mixed into your moisturizer for a subtle warm glow on your face. Light citrus-ginger scent that plays beautifully with heavier fall fragrances. Absorbs fast, no greasy pillow situation.
Kiehls Daily Reviving Concentrate
Grab this unscented base and add a drop of your favorite fall perfume for a custom scented body oil. Sinks in fast, fixes every dry patch, and works on hair ends too. Triple threat.
Josie Maran Argan Oil
Try this if you want a warm floral oil that makes your skin feel like velvet. Applied it before bed and woke up to my dog sleeping with his head on my oiled-up arm. He knew what was up.
Natural Jasmine Body Oil
Pumpkin-Adjacent Hair Products for That Warm Autumn Scent Trail
Nothing hits quite like someone walking past you and catching a warm, spicy scent coming off your hair. These leave a trail that apparently works on humans and pets alike.
Put two drops through your ends and your hair smells warm and slightly sweet for the rest of the day. My friend's cat literally tried to eat my ponytail. This stuff has been in my rotation for four years and I'm never switching.
Moroccanoil
Spritz this into day-two hair for volume and a subtle warm scent that mixes perfectly with any fall perfume. Went from flat Wednesday hair to looking like I just came from a blowout. My dog sniffed my head approvingly.
Dry Texturizing Spray - Oribe
Use this on wet hair before blow-drying and the warm scent bakes in. Cuts frizz, adds shine, and smells like you spent money at a salon. My cat sat on my pillow and refused to move — scent thief.
Hairdresser's Invisible Oil Collection
Grab this for mornings when brushing your hair feels like a punishment. Detangles instantly, leaves a light warm scent, and doesn't weigh down fine hair. Saved me from cutting my own knots out last November.
New Drybar Prep Rally Prime & Prep Detangler Sealed 5 Oz
Toss this on for twenty minutes when the cold air has turned your hair into straw. Came out feeling like I had entirely new hair. The subtle honey-warm scent lingered through two washes.
Briogeo Don't Despair, Repair! Hair Mask
Cozy Fall Self-Care Extras That Complete the Whole Pumpkin Vibe
These are the finishing touches — the stuff that ties the whole warm-spicy-cozy situation together. My pets have strong opinions about every single one.
Slather this on before bed and wake up with lips that aren't cracked and bleeding from the dry air. Tastes like pumpkin pie. My dog licked my face at 6 AM which honestly might have been about this.
Laneige Lip Sleeping Mask Pumpkin Spice
Pair this with all your warm-scented hair products and wake up still smelling like fall instead of a smashed cotton pillowcase. My cat claimed it immediately. We now share. She gets it during the day.
Silk Pillowcase
Keep this burning while you do your whole fall skincare routine and your bathroom becomes a spa. The throw on this candle fills a room in minutes. Even my usually indifferent cat comes to sit nearby.
Spiced Pumpkin Latte | 3 Wick Hearth Candle
Dab this on your cheekbones over moisturizer for that dewy fall glow — looks like you just came inside from crisp air. Works under makeup or alone. My dog booped my glowy cheek and left a nose print.
Glow Drops Skincare