Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
🍕 The Ultimate Omaha Pizza Guide: NY Style, Neapolitan & Beyond
15
items My dad lived in NYC his whole life before moving to Nebraska—so when we say we’re picky about pizza, we mean it. 🍕
We’ve been on a mission to find the best slices in Omaha: thin, foldable New York style, bubbly Neapolitan, crispy coal-fired—you name...
Map
Sections
5
New York Style
Neapolitan/ Wood or Coal Fired
Chicago Style
Gluten Free
Sicilian
New York Style
Thin, bendable crisp New York crust right here in Omaha!
Crisp crust, a tad bit thicker than actual Brooklyn, but cheese is the perfect amount done. 10/10 Fun fact: Their other restaurants are in New York and they wanted to open one here!
Williamsburg Pizza Omaha
The OG- we would have called this one our favorite 5 years ago and no one could come close. New recipe, new owners, still fabulous though and nobody beats their garlic knots or cannolis.
Frank's Pizzeria 1170 Capitol Avenue
My husbands favorite- a little pricier, but crust is crisp to perfection and you can fold it perfectly like the New Yorker’s do
Virtuoso Pizzeria by David Losole
They only do pizza here- very similar to Williamsburg! Highly recommend if you're in Omaha and looking for a really good pie.
tasty pizza - Omaha
Don Carmelo’s serves up authentic New York–style pizza right here in Omaha — think thin, foldable slices with perfectly crisp edges, gooey cheese, and that classic East Coast flavor that feels straight out of the city.
Don Carmelo's
Neapolitan/ Wood or Coal Fired
Top rated Neapolitan inspired pizza places in Omaha!
Really good pizza- the only authentic wood fired spot in Omaha! Absolutely love it for a date night, hang out, or party!
DANTE
Coal fired crust- light and airy, super cool vibes! Does have a rooftop which adds to the whole experience.
Pitch Pizzeria
My go-to pizza door dash order. While not exactly New York, it’s a good size pizza for one person- crisp, thin, perfectly cooked cheese.
Smokin' Oak Wood-Fired Pizza and Taproom
Chicago Style
Ahhhhh, can't forget the Chicago style crust!
Deep dish and stuffed style pizza- to die for! Very unique toppings and flavors, MUST TRY!
Pizzeria Davlo
Chicago-based franchise that offers more Chicago-flavored options!
Rosati's Pizza
Gluten Free
For anyone looking for a GF crust!
My best friend is gluten free- she loves this place every time she visits! Gluten free crust and vegan desserts!
Brick Oven Pizzeria
Offers a gluten-free crust so you can build your own GF pizza!
Mama's Pizza
Sicilian
Sicilian pizza is all about that thick, airy crust with crispy edges, rich tomato sauce, and a layer of melty cheese — it’s hearty, square-cut, and pure comfort in every bite.
Bakery style rectangular crust- so delicious if you’re looking for something a little different pizza wise!
La Casa Pizzaria
Thick, rectangular Sicilian‑style pies with hearty sauce; a local institution and bakery favorite. 10/10 have to go.
Orsi's Italian Bakery & Pizzeria
Hole in the wall but their takeout Sicilian is FANTASTIC. My dad forgets Bernie's exists, but when he remembers, he absolutely loves the pizza.
Bernie's Original Pizza Parlor