I make Phantom LEGO sets for a living, so my shelf is not casual. This is the collection that rewards knowing the story, built around Leroux's novel and a century of adaptations.
The 1910 novel everything else stands on. Read it before you argue about adaptations.
The Phantom of the Opera, Leroux, Hardcover
Public domain masterpiece, and the unmasking still works a hundred years later.
The Phantom of the Opera 1925 Lon Chaney
Dust is the enemy of a black-clad minifig. Sealed acrylic solves it.
Acrylic minifigure display case, dustproof
Sets read better at eye level than on furniture. The rail stops the slow slide.
Wall shelf with rail for LEGO sets
A chandelier scene deserves stage lighting. Warm white, never cool.
Warm white LED strip lighting for display cabinets
Etsy is where the good mask makers are. A wall mask anchors the whole shelf.
Masquerade half mask, display quality, from Etsy makers
The one object guests always wind up.
Phantom music box, Etsy makers
The building is the third lead character. A period print says you know that.
Vintage-style Palais Garnier print
Costs almost nothing, completes everything.
Red rose with black ribbon, silk
Framed period sheet music, the cheapest real atmosphere a shelf can buy.
Public domain opera sheet music, framed
My own book. An adventurous prequel to the Phantom of the Opera, following young Raoul at sea. The reason this whole shelf exists.