Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Found Pizza Gear That Makes Frozen Pizza Taste Like Brick Oven
34
items Frozen pizza shouldn't taste like cardboard on a soggy cracker, but somehow it always does. If you're tired of pulling limp, pale pies out of your oven and pretending they're fine, this is everything I use to make a $5 frozen pizza taste like somethi...
Sections
5
Pizza Stones and Steels That Actually Fit Standard Ovens
Pizza Peels and Turners for Getting Pies In and Out Clean
Oven Thermometers and Heat Tools for Dialing In Temperature
Seasonings and Finishing Touches That Fake the Brick Oven Flavor
Pizza Racks, Screens, and Storage for Weekly Pizza Night
Pizza Stones and Steels That Actually Fit Standard Ovens
Half the pizza stones out there are either too big for a normal oven or too thin to hold heat. I cracked two before finding ones that actually work without a PhD in oven dimensions.
Grab this if your oven is a standard 30-inch model. Fits perfectly on the middle rack. My frozen Digiornos went from soggy-bottomed sadness to actually crispy in about two weeks of use.
Cuisinart Chef's Classic Bakeware 14" Pizza Pan
Use this for anyone who prefers a rectangular stone. Slides right onto the rack with room to spare. The crust browns so evenly now that my wife stopped suggesting we just order delivery.
Old Stone Rectangular Pizza Stone Oven
Switch to this if you've cracked a ceramic stone before and don't want the heartbreak again. Cast iron is basically indestructible. Preheated at 500 degrees, it gave my frozen Totino's a char I didn't know was possible.
Lodge, Cast Iron Pizza Pan, 15 inch, Black, Pre-Seasoned
Keep this one if you bake pizza more than once a week. ThermaBond means it handles thermal shock way better than cheap stones. I pulled it from a 500-degree oven and set it on a cool counter. No crack. Finally.
Pizzacraft 15" Square ThermaBond Baking/Pizza Stone
Try this for grilling season. Works in the oven too, but on a charcoal grill it gave my frozen pizza actual smoky flavor. Neighbors came over asking who I ordered from.
Weber, Pizza Stone, 16 inches, Black, Glazed surface
Snag this if you hate cleaning up after pizza night. Comes with a scraper that actually works. The stone itself runs thick, so it holds heat like a beast. My crusts have never been crispier.
Heritage 15" Ceramic Pizza Stone Set
Pair this with your highest oven setting and prepare to be a little shocked. Steel conducts heat way faster than ceramic. My frozen Screamin' Sicilian cooked in 7 minutes flat with a bottom crust that actually shattered when I bit it.
NerdChef Steel Stone
Pizza Peels and Turners for Getting Pies In and Out Clean
I dropped a fully loaded pizza onto the bottom of my oven exactly once. The smoke alarm went off, the dog panicked, and I ordered Chinese. Never again.
Grab this before your next pizza night. The handle is long enough that you won't burn your knuckles reaching into a 500-degree oven. Slides right under frozen pizza without any drama.
Cuisinart 12-in Aluminum Pizza Peel
Use this if you want something lightweight. Wooden peels are charming but heavy. This aluminum one lets me get the pizza on the stone in one smooth motion. No more half-folded disasters.
Chef Pomodoro Aluminum Metal Pizza Peel
Keep this one around for serving. It looks good enough to bring straight to the table. Guests always assume I made the pizza from scratch when I slide it off this thing.
Honey Can Do 16x18-Inch Aluminum Pizza Peel
Try this for larger pies or homemade dough. Wide enough to handle a full 16-inch pizza. The raw wood grip feels solid and doesn't get slippery even when my hands are covered in flour.
New Star Foodservice 50363 Wooden Pizza Peel, 18 x 19
Ditch your old wobbly pizza cutter. This one rolls through crust, cheese, and toppings without dragging everything sideways. For anyone who's tired of sawing through pizza like it's a piece of lumber.
OXO Good Grips NEW Large 4-Inch Pizza Wheel and Cutter
Swap to this if your current cutter can't handle thick crust. The blade is sharp enough to go through deep dish in one pass. Dishwasher safe too, which matters when Friday night laziness kicks in.
KitchenAid Stainless Steel Pizza Cutter Wheel with Finger
Toss your wheel cutter and try a rocker blade. One press down and the whole slice separates clean. Perfect for anyone who makes pizza for kids and needs even slices fast before the arguing starts.
Checkered Chef's Pizza Cutter - Rocker Type Pizza Cutter
Oven Thermometers and Heat Tools for Dialing In Temperature
Your oven lies to you. Mine said 450 and was actually running at 390. No wonder my crusts were pale and sad. These fixed that problem overnight.
Throw this in your oven today and prepare to be annoyed at how wrong your built-in dial is. Mine was off by 60 degrees. Sixty. Once I adjusted, my pizza crust actually browned for the first time.
Taylor, Oven Thermometer Solo Classic, Analog
Use this if you want something that stays put. The hook clips right to the rack and doesn't slide around every time you open the door. Built like a tank, which I appreciate after two flimsy ones broke.
Rubbermaid Commercial FGTHO550 Stainless Steel Oven
Grab this for its oversized numbers. I can read it without pulling the rack out and losing all my heat. For anyone over 40 whose eyes aren't what they used to be, this is the one.
CDN Oven Thermometer ProAccurate®
Keep this around for checking the internal temp of thick-crust pizza or calzones. Sounds weird but knowing the center is actually cooked through changed my deep dish results completely.
ThermoPro, Meat Thermometer, TP-16, Large LCD Display
Point this at your pizza stone before sliding the pie on. If the stone isn't at least 475, wait. This one trick alone made more difference than any single product on this list. Seriously.
Lasergrip 774 Upgrade Infrared Thermometer - Blue
Try this for stuffed pizzas or anything with raw toppings. Poke it in the thickest part and actually know when it's done instead of guessing and cutting it open like a surgeon mid-bake.
KitchenAid Leave-in Meat Analog Thermometer
Snag this as a backup probe. The cord is long enough to close the oven door on it, so you can monitor temp without opening the door every three minutes and letting all your heat escape.
Taylor Stainless Steel Digital Foldable Probe Meat
Seasonings and Finishing Touches That Fake the Brick Oven Flavor
A frozen pizza is a blank canvas if you treat it right. These are the things I add after it comes out of the oven that make people genuinely confused about whether I made it or ordered it.
Toss a generous shake of this on any frozen pizza right before it goes in the oven. Oregano, basil, garlic, all pre-mixed. Turns a bland Tombstone into something that actually smells like an Italian restaurant.
Badia Italian Seasoning, 1.25 oz
Sprinkle these on if you like a little kick. The flakes toast slightly on the hot cheese and get this nutty, smoky flavor. Way better than the sad little packets that come with delivery pizza.
McCormick Kosher Crushed Red Pepper, 2.62 oz Bottle
Dump a pile of this on top during the last two minutes of baking. It gets golden and crispy around the edges. Cheap trick, huge payoff. For anyone who thinks frozen pizza cheese is too bland.
Kraft Natural Grated Parmesan Cheese Shaker, 8 oz Bottle
Drizzle this over your pizza right when it comes out. Just a thin stream across the whole thing. It adds richness that frozen pizza completely lacks. My slices suddenly tasted like they cost $4 each instead of $0.80.
Filippo Berio Extra Virgin Olive Oils for Cooking ...
Try a zigzag of this across pepperoni pizza and watch people lose their minds. Sweet, spicy, sticky. It caramelizes on the hot cheese and creates this flavor that no frozen pizza has any right having.
Mike's Hot Honey Gluten-Free Paleo Honey with a Kick 12 oz
Pinch a few flakes onto your pizza right before serving. Sounds fancy but it costs like $6 and lasts months. The crunch plus the salt pop makes cheap frozen pizza taste intentional instead of desperate.
Maldon Sea Salt Flakes, Organic Pyramid Crystals (8.5 oz)
Pizza Racks, Screens, and Storage for Weekly Pizza Night
Once you start making frozen pizza that actually tastes good, it becomes a weekly thing. These keep the process smooth and your kitchen from turning into a disaster zone every Friday.
Use this for nights when you don't feel like preheating a stone for an hour. Nonstick means the pizza slides right off. Perfect for weeknights when you just want food fast without a whole production.
Wilton, Bakeware Pizza Pan, 14 Inch, Silver, Non-Stick
Grab this perforated pan if sogginess is your main enemy. The holes let hot air hit the bottom of the crust directly. My Red Baron went from doughy to crispy and I didn't change anything else.
Farberware Bakeware Nonstick Pizza Crisper and Baking
Keep this as your backup crisper. Lighter than the Farberware and fits in a smaller oven. For anyone in an apartment with a tiny oven who still wants decent pizza, this actually delivers.
Baker's Secret 3 Pack 12 Inch Nonstick Carbon Steel Pizza
Switch to this if you're sick of nonstick coatings flaking off after six months. Bare aluminum, simple, works forever. I've had mine for three years and it looks the same as day one.
Nordic Ware Naturals 16" Aluminum Air Crisp Pizza Pan
Toss your leftover slices in here instead of wrapping them in foil like a barbarian. Airtight seal means they don't dry out overnight. Next-day pizza actually tastes like pizza, not like refrigerator.
Rubbermaid Brilliance Glass Food Storage Containers, 2-Pack with Lids, BPA Free and Leak Proof, 4.7 Cup
Wrap your pizza stone in this for easy cleanup on lazy nights. Peel it off, throw it away, stone stays clean. Saved me from scrubbing baked-on cheese at 11 PM more times than I can count.
Reynolds Wrap Aluminum Foil - Heavy Duty - 300 sq. ft.
Bring your pizza to the table on this instead of a cutting board covered in knife marks. It has a handle, a groove to catch crumbs, and it makes Friday pizza night feel like an actual event instead of sad oven food.
Totally Bamboo Arkansas Shaped Serving & Cutting Board