Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
I Finally Found Fill-Your-Own Advent Calendars That Beat Store-Bought Every Year
30
items Those pre-filled advent calendars with stale chocolate and mystery candy? My kids stopped opening them by December 10th. I spent two years testing fillable calendars and figuring out what actually makes someone excited to open a tiny door every morni...
Sections
5
Fillable Advent Calendar Boxes Worth Reusing
Chocolate and Candy Fillers That Crush Pre-Made Calendars
Small Toy and Trinket Fillers Kids Actually Play With
Grown-Up Fillers for Adult Advent Calendars
Wrapping Supplies and Finishing Touches
Fillable Advent Calendar Boxes Worth Reusing
Threw away three flimsy cardboard calendars that fell apart by December 5th. These are the ones that survived multiple seasons and still look good sitting on the mantel.
Grab this if you're tired of cardboard that buckles under the weight of anything heavier than a Hershey Kiss. Painted it with my daughter last year and it still looks perfect sitting on our bookshelf.
Walmart Sells a 'Beautiful' Wooden Advent Calendar You
Set this up on the entry table and guests kept asking where I got it. Each little house opens from the back, so you can stuff earrings, candy, notes, whatever fits. Worth grabbing early because it sold out by mid-November last year.
BRUBAKER Advent Calendar Wooden Christmas Book
Use these for a classroom party or if you're building calendars for multiple kids without spending a fortune. They fold flat for storage, which saved me a whole shelf in the closet.
24 Days Christmas Countdown Calendar Box Filled
Perfect for the person who wants something that doubles as actual decor. Hang tiny ornaments inside each box and the tree fills up as December goes on. My six-year-old was more excited about this than the real tree.
Holiday Countdown Calendar Advent Gift Box Christmas
Pair this with a crafty kid and a rainy Saturday afternoon. My nephew decorated his own and was ten times more invested in opening it every day because he built the thing himself.
Advent Calendar Kit
Switch to these if drawers feel too small for what you want to stuff inside. I fit full-size candy bars, socks, and small toys without any cramming. Hang them on a curtain rod or string and you're done in ten minutes.
Christmas Advent Calendar Gift Bag Set with 48
Chocolate and Candy Fillers That Crush Pre-Made Calendars
My whole motivation for going DIY was realizing I could fill 24 slots with chocolate people actually want to eat instead of that waxy mystery chocolate from a drugstore calendar.
Toss two different flavors in each day's slot and suddenly your advent calendar is better than anything Lindt sells pre-made for twice the price. The dark chocolate ones disappear first in our house, so buy extra.
Lindt LINDOR Assorted Chocolate Christmas Candy
Try telling a kid they get a Reese's cup every morning in December and watch their face. These fit perfectly in small drawers and nobody has ever complained about finding one behind a tiny door.
Reese's Miniatures Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
Keep these for the adult advent calendar. Caramel filling, dark chocolate, sea salt. My wife said this was the first year she actually cared about opening her calendar before coffee.
Ghirardelli Premium Chocolate Assortment Squares, 12.5 oz
Snag these for kids who aren't huge chocolate fans. Each mini bag fits perfectly in a drawer or pouch. My son ranked his advent calendar “way better than Tyler's” at school, which felt like a parenting win.
Haribo Gold Bears / Goldb?ren, 100 Mini Bags, 980g Tub
Swap these in if you're building a calendar for a kid with a nut allergy. Allergy-friendly, actually tastes good, and the portions are exactly the right size for small calendar compartments.
Customer reviews for YumEarth Organic Fruit Snacks
Ditch the fancy stuff for a few days and throw in some of these. Keeps the calendar from feeling predictable. My dad literally asked me to make him an advent calendar after he saw the mix I put together.
(3 pack) Tootsie Roll, Midgees Chocolate Candy
Small Toy and Trinket Fillers Kids Actually Play With
Spent one year filling every slot with candy and my kids were in a sugar spiral by December 12th. Mixing in small toys kept them guessing and honestly they played with some of these for months after.
Use one can per day for almost half the calendar. My daughter made a tiny Play-Doh ornament from each day's color and lined them up on her windowsill. Cost me like three dollars for fifteen days of content.
Play-Doh, Party Bag, 15 Pieces, Assorted 1 oz Cans
Grab a pack and split them across different days. My son lost his mind finding a car behind door number 17. He's seven and still talks about it. Way better than the plastic junk in store-bought toy calendars.
Hot Wheels, 1:64 Scale Toy Car or Truck, Styles May Vary
Perfect for anyone building a calendar for a kid between 4 and 10. Fits in almost any drawer or pouch and keeps them busy for at least an hour, which is basically a holiday miracle.
Crayola Silly Putty Egg Container-Red 4.00
Break this set into small bagged portions across several days. By Christmas they've built the whole thing piece by piece. Took some planning but my nephew said it was the coolest advent calendar he'd ever had.
LEGO, Classic Creative Monsters, 11017, 140 Pieces
Toss a couple tattoo sheets in random slots for a surprise change of pace. My kids wore them to school like badges of honor. Teachers kept asking where they got the dinosaur ones.
Melissa & Doug Temporary Tattoos: Jewelry
Split the pack across two or three days. By mid-December they had a full set and spent Christmas break actually using them. Beats another piece of candy they eat in four seconds and forget about.
Crayola Mini Twistables Crayons, 10 Per Pack, 12 Packs
Grown-Up Fillers for Adult Advent Calendars
Made one for my wife last year on a whim and she said it was the most thoughtful gift she'd gotten in five years. Felt guilty it only took me an hour to put together.
Tuck one flavor behind each of four doors. My wife found the pomegranate one on December 8th and immediately hid it from the kids. Real products people actually use, not random filler.
Burt's Bees Gift Sets for Lip and Skin Care
Wrap individual tea bags in tissue paper for different days. Pair one with a note that says “drink this after the kids go to bed” and you've won the holiday. My sister cried over a chamomile packet, so apparently this works.
Celestial Seasonings, Herbal Tea Sampler
Scoop some into a small jar for one of the bigger calendar days. Smells incredible and feels like a spa moment in a house that normally smells like chicken nuggets and dog.
Tree Hut Coconut Lime Shea Butter Sugar Body Scrub, 18 oz
Slip one into a pouch or drawer and it's the kind of thing someone actually uses through January. My coworker found one in her calendar and kept it in her desk drawer all winter.
(3 pack) eos Shea Better Ultra Derm Hand Cream
Building a calendar for a guy? Cut this into smaller chunks, wrap them individually. Sounds weird but my husband said finding soap behind door 14 was “oddly exciting.” His words, not mine.
Duke Cannon, Big Ass Brick of Soap, 10 oz, Sawtooth
Throw a face mask behind one of the later doors when the holiday stress is peaking. December 20th, everyone's frazzled, and suddenly there's a mini spa night waiting. Timing matters.
Customer reviews for Yes To Coconut Paper Mask, 0.67 Oz
Wrapping Supplies and Finishing Touches
First year I used plastic bags and masking tape. Looked like evidence from a crime scene. These small details are what made people actually think I bought a fancy pre-made calendar.
Wrap each filler item in a different color before tucking it in. Takes an extra five minutes total and makes every door feel like a real gift instead of loose candy rattling around.
Hallmark 6-Pack Assorted Tissue Paper (Dark Solids) 30
Stick these on bags, boxes, or drawers so you don't have to handwrite numbers at midnight. My handwriting looks like a doctor's prescription, so these saved the whole project from looking homemade in a bad way.
Avery, Printable Round Labels, 2.5" Glossy White, 90 Labels
Use this instead of regular tape. It disappears on wrapping paper and doesn't leave that shiny plastic strip. Small detail but it's the difference between “oh cute” and “wait, you made this?”
Scotch Gift Wrap Tape Dispensers, Satin Finish, 3/4 in. x
Tie little bundles or hang bags from a branch with this. Took my calendar from looking like a school project to something people actually photographed for Instagram. Under four bucks.
Baker's Twine, 2 Pound Cone
Write a tiny note or joke on each tag before attaching it to that day's treat. My daughter kept every single tag in a box. Apparently “you're cooler than a snowman” was peak comedy for a five-year-old.
Kraft Gift Tags
Clip bags or pouches to a string across the mantel and it looks like something from a holiday catalog. Bought these on a whim and they've become the backbone of every calendar I build now. Stock up because you'll use them for everything.
Mainstays Wooden Dry Laundry Clothespins